Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I'm a desisted male — born male, gay, and autistic — and I've been writing about what led me to identify as nonbinary and what desisting has actually felt like day to day.
I publicly identified as nonbinary for a few years and was socially trans for around four years. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — so I describe myself as desisted rather than detrans, and I've tried to be careful to give space to people who actually went through medical changes. I've been fully desisted for a while now; as of one of my posts I'd been fully desisted for nearly a year, and elsewhere I described myself as "desist*ing*" because the process is ongoing. I'm 6'4" with size 13 men's shoes and a naturally higher voice than many men, and I've never been androgynous-looking, which matters because I know I could never pass as a woman no matter what.
The core of my experience is that I have never felt male. Not in the vague way people say most cis people don't 'feel' like their gender — more that when I'm around other men I feel fundamentally different from them, like there's something unknown and intangible they have that makes them male that I lack. I feel about as far from maleness as from femaleness despite being born in a male body. On a work Zoom with almost all men I legitimately could not see myself as a male the same way they were. I can't be in a group of men and see myself as anything but a genderless, nonbinary individual, even when they treat me as a man. Everyone else seems to see me as unambiguously male, so why can't I? It feels like there's something I'm missing that other men have but I don't know what it is.
I think several things fed into this. I'm autistic and was infantilized my entire life for it, and I'm high-masking. I realized I was gay during high school and stayed in the closet for the rest of it; the point at which I started feeling ostracized by other boys was, not coincidentally, the point at which I started thinking I might not be male at all. I grew up with nothing in common with other males and found it easier to connect with women. I attended a public high school with a uniform — black dress shoes, khakis, long-sleeve oxford shirts or polo, ties for boys — and I actually enjoyed the ties back then, liked tying alternative knots, and didn't feel like I didn't deserve to be male because I was surrounded by people of all genders who shared my intellectual interests. I was never good at being social or making friends. I'm a rhythm gamer, and I've noticed that male-dominated niche hobbies are often policed by other men as 'gay' or feminine, and those spaces can be toxically masculine; I've avoided those communities partly because being a male in a male-dominated space makes me feel like I'm somehow part of the problem or making things worse for women.
Homophobia was at least a factor. I wouldn't say it was the primary reason for my transition, but having some way to say I wasn't gay felt amazing. I still dream of being a woman so I can be with guys and not feel disgusting. My sex drive is nearly nonexistent, and most of the homophobia I experienced was because of that rather than me being out. I've also come to believe internalized misandry is a considerable factor in why I hate my genitalia and body — a commenter raised it and I realized I'd actively avoided considering it because I'd been told it doesn't exist or is a cop-out. I've taught myself to hate being a man, having a male body, and presenting masculinely, and convinced myself it's completely incompatible with me, due to both internalized homophobia and internalized misandry. I also feel guilt over the benefits I reap from patriarchy by being male, and I hate being part of the demographic responsible for so much violence against women.
Desisting has been confusing and, in some ways, made things harder. I present 'as male' in the real world now, which was a huge and scary step, and I've been mentally preparing to lose my longer hair. Online I still prefer no pronouns or they/them; I'm not at the stage where I can be he/him and pretend I'm a gay male. Unisex clothes that look good on either sex feel affirming — I borrowed an oversize jean jacket from my mom's closet that fit me perfectly and nobody batted an eye, and I hadn't felt that good about my appearance in years; the contentment came from the unisexness of it. I've had a strange dream about wearing 18th-century men's clothing for a play in which my dysphoria vanished completely, which felt affirming in a way that wasn't just costume fun.
Words still sting. He, him, his, handsome, man, brother, sir, mister — they give me an instinctive discomfort to the same degree as when I was outwardly trans. Statements like 'men can't get pregnant' or 'men can't get periods' make me irrationally uncomfortable, not because I don't know they're true but because they remind me I'll never be part of a sisterhood. I've been avoiding anything sexual for a while because looking at or touching my genitalia in the shower gives me discomfort and guilt; sometimes they feel 'on loan,' like I'm waiting for the body I was supposed to have. I have a lot of issues with my height because it illustrates sexual dimorphism, which makes me anxious and hopeless — it's impossible for a man to come close to having the anatomy of a woman. I've thought about surgery and told myself I could cope with complications, but intellectually I don't think I could, which is one of the only things that has kept me from pursuing transition. I'm not going to transition; I've seen the horror stories. I'm certain it isn't AGP — there's nothing sexual about it, and I'm not even attracted to women.
I've also felt unsafe and out of place. Until recently I avoided any gendered bathroom at the expense of my bladder, never going into women's rooms because I didn't belong and gender-neutral spaces are rare; I've now started using men's bathrooms again, but I feel sized up and like something bad could happen. I live in a large city where bending gender roles or being gay ranges from accepted to risky to my physical safety depending on the area, and I've learned where it's safe; I've done what I hope is a good enough job of 'passing for straight.' People have weaponized my height against me — 'you're a 6'4" man, what do you have to be scared of' — to invalidate my fears.
I've been going to therapy, but my therapists have been unhelpful and/or overly affirming. I've looked for detrans/desist male spaces and found them scarce; detrans spaces are primarily women, which is wonderful, but it can feel lonely and makes me hesitant to discuss issues specific to men. I changed my name recently — I got rid of my father's last name — and found it relieving, a weight off my shoulders. I don't think identifying as nonbinary helps me accept being male; it's a hurdle I'm still trying to get over. I want to find ways to experience something like gender euphoria as a man, and I've realized I need to work on internalized misandry and internalized homophobia. There aren't many gay or neurodivergent males in fiction or otherwise whom I look up to, and I think finding that would help. I still struggle to see myself as a man, but I'm not in the same pattern I used to be in, and I have faith I'll get there — though it may be a lifelong challenge.