Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione e ha passato anni nelle comunità detrans offrendo sostegno, risorse e rassicurazioni agli altri che stanno valutando o attraversando la detransizione. Inquadro la transizione come un fallimento sistemico e medico più che come un errore individuale e incoraggio gli altri a lasciar andare l'autocolpevolizzazione. Sottolineo che i vestiti e la femminilità non sono incompatibili con l'essere femmina e che i cambiamenti fisici dovuti alla transizione sono, in certo senso, un cambiamento estetico temporaneo. In questi post non ho descritto la mia cronologia di transizione, gli interventi medici o la storia di salute mentale. All'inizio del 2024 resto attiva in questi spazi, offrendo consigli pratici, comprensione e incoraggiamento.
Storia completa
I first found myself writing to others in detransition spaces in April 2019, when someone had posted about suicidal thoughts after realizing they wanted to detransition. I told them to see a psychologist right away for the suicidal thoughts, and I shared links to a Tumblr run by someone detransitioning that listed Reddit and Facebook groups for detransitioners, blogs by people detransitioning, and a blog post by a mother and daughter who had detransitioned. I noted that some of those blogs were gender critical and that this would be a sympathetic community if they wanted to discuss things online without judgment from the trans community. I tried to reassure them that what they had been through was very traumatic but that people have come out the other side, and I framed physical transition as 'a cosmetic change that is in some senses temporary,' adding that not all women have the same bodies and many have been through mastectomies. I told them that realizing where they stood and what they wanted was a step forward toward finding the right path to treat their gender dysphoria. In a follow-up comment that same day I told them they were taking as rational an approach as they could, doing the right things by getting support from their partner and therapist, and to 'carry on being brave.'
In April 2020 I responded to someone who had been through what I took to be a similar experience, asking whether they would tell their parents now, saying it sounded like their parents would be supportive and would want the best for them whatever they decided, and hoping they could find support from family and detrans groups. In another comment that month I pushed back on the idea that femininity had to be abandoned to live as a man: 'You still can wear all of that stuff. Why not wear what you want and what you feel happy in?' I said I understood that the trans community is very gender conformist, which makes people transitioning to be a man think they shouldn't wear feminine clothes, but that 'they are just clothes. Nothing to do with your sex or personality.' I also commented on a medical question, suspecting that age and weight (and therefore cardiovascular health) would be more significant factors in potential recovery from a disease than whatever else had been proposed. In mid-April 2020 I simply offered sympathy and an internet hug to someone going through a hard time.
By January 2024 I was writing about the systemic pressures behind transition. Reposting after a comment removal, I told someone feeling guilty that I hoped they could in time let go of the guilt and the thought that they had done this to themselves. I wrote that 'in some ways transitioning isn't really an individual choice' because of the pressure on young people, and especially women, to conform to prescriptive gender norms, and because transitioning is presented by the medical establishment as basically the only escape. I argued it is easier to put the onus on the individual to fix the problem than to fix it at the source, and that it is a whole system: 'you were not responsible for having experienced that pressure, the guidance you might have received or many other steps along the way.'
I have also engaged with more casual threads in these communities, telling someone in January 2024 that I couldn't tell their sex from a photo because either way they looked childlike, guessing female, and in February 2024 complimenting someone's hair as 'so nice and shiny.'