Tutte le storie

Nessun ormone, nessuna diagnosi: solo la decisione che la transizione non avrebbe aiutato

Femmina · Desistito/a527
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una persona che ha fatto desistenza e che non ha mai fatto una transizione medica né preso ormoni. Provo ancora un po' di disforia di genere, ma ho concluso che la transizione non aiuterebbe perché, nel profondo, il mio sesso è immutabile. Faccio i conti con la misoginia interiorizzata e sospetto di poter essere lesbica e non bisessuale, con un'eterosessualità obbligatoria imposta da quella stessa misoginia. Mi identifico come femminista radicale e sono critica verso la transizione, il genere come costrutto sociale e quello che vedo come un attivismo trans sessista ed estremamente online. Non ho dichiarato alcuna diagnosi formale, storia di traumi o intervento medico.

Storia completa

I have identified as desisted — I never medically transitioned, and I came to the conclusion that transition would not solve my problems. I have been active in detrans and desistance discussions since at least April 2023, and I describe myself as a desisted person who still experiences gender dysphoria, at least in part. On my own dysphoria, I have said plainly: "desisted men and women like myself can admit that we still have 'strong' gender dysphoria, at least a part of us, but personally I know that transition would not solve any of my problems, therefore not help my GD because well; at my core, I am my sex, as anyone is. This is unchangeable, whether one likes it or not." That conviction — that sex is fixed and unchangeable — is the core of where I landed. I have also said that I never medically transitioned, and that I "sound like this and have never been on hormones," in the context of reassuring others about voice. I have never given a detailed account of what first led me toward identifying as trans, and I don't want to invent one. What I have disclosed is that I struggle with internalised misogyny. I wrote: "I hate that I somehow seem to think and lean towards the idea of me as a woman is somehow has any less value than any man. Misogyny is hell." I also disclosed uncertainty about my sexuality: "Worst part is, I think I might be a lesbian and not bisexual, but my internalized misogyny pushes me towards being comphet... In the end, the struggle is way too much real and I'm with you." I framed this as something installed young: "It feels so innate, maybe because it was installed into us while we were young and hard to break out of that mindset." I also noted that healing from it takes time: "We didn't start believing we were lesser in one day, so expecting yourself to stop feeling this way in a day is not realistic." I have also disclosed that I still struggle with residual identification in dreams: "I'm more often than not a cis man in my dreams. Why? No idea. And I never even medically transitioned." This suggests the identification has not fully resolved, though I have not described it as distressing in recent posts. On causes and contributors, I have been critical of online culture as a driver of transition-adjacent thinking. I said: "I think it's all so extremely online and toxic. Why oh why can't someone wear masculine clothing and still be a woman which she is? Same goes for any man that likes femininity whether it's makeup or clothing. It's seen as progressive when it's just what? Extremely sexist? How modern and not backwards.." I also said gender itself is harmful: "Gender, in my opinion, is quite a harmful social construct. One we aren't getting rid of anytime soon, unfortunately." I have been suspicious of posts I read as fabricated: "Call me terminally online or something but this post reads like it was made by a trans person trying to make detrans people bad." On process, I have not described a specific therapy, spiritual experience, or medical scare that moved me toward desistance. What I have described is a reasoning process: I concluded that transition would not solve my problems because my sex is unchangeable. I have also referenced a study I half-remember: "I remember a study someone linked on this sub before that the more a trans person transitioned, the worse their depression got or something (?)" and I have repeatedly said that further transition tends to backfire: "The entirety of this sub usually tries to explain that transitioning more and more fires back, when it's 'meant to help'. Often times it creates more gender dysphoria and there's more struggling." On medical: I have never taken hormones and never had any medical intervention. I have said so explicitly on more than one occasion. I have no fertility concerns, no surgical regrets, and no irreversible changes to report. On mental health: I have not disclosed a diagnosis. I have discussed depression conceptually, arguing that "Varying degrees of depression is still just depression. No matter the amount, it is still a disorder. And most definitely not everyone has it." I have discussed body dysmorphia versus gender dysphoria at length, arguing they are connected: "dysmorphia is when a person finds flaws about their physical appearance, but those flaws are often very minimal (hardly seen by others)" versus dysphoria, which I described as "when a person views their body as ugly because they don't like their gender." I noted the diagnostic asymmetry: "it is interesting that dysphoria isn't called a mental illness, while dysmorphia is." I also pushed the point further: "isn't it delusional to think one can be/is/feels like the other sex?" On adversity: I have not disclosed trauma, abuse, assault, bullying, or family dysfunction. I have no family or relationship details to report beyond noting that I have been supportive of others whose families are supportive. On sexuality: I have said I might be a lesbian rather than bisexual, and that internalised misogyny pushes me toward compulsory heterosexuality. I have not described how my sexuality presented before or after desistance beyond that. On regret: I have not expressed regret about hormones or surgery, because I never had them. I have not described lost time or social losses in explicit terms. The closest I have come is acknowledging that "life is hard after detransition" — though I was quoting and defending another person's point when I said that, not describing my own experience directly. On outcomes: I have not described my current quality of life, career, family situation, or support network in detail. I have been an active and often blunt commenter in the community, offering reassurance about voices, challenging what I see as bad-faith posts, and pushing back on what I view as trans activist framing. On attitudes toward transition for others: I am broadly critical and skeptical. I have argued that transition tends to make dysphoria worse, that gender is a harmful construct, and that sex is unchangeable. At the same time, I have been encouraging to people who are already medically detransitioning: "don't give up on yourself, hormones took you to right now. They can work and give you the opposite too you know" and "The road may be rougher, however it doesn't mean you cannot come up on top!" I have also been critical of radical feminism's blind spots while identifying as a radfem: "As a radfem I'd say so but every community differs greatly" and I warned a trans-identifying person that in radfem spaces "your identity will not be respected... what we care about is a person's sex." I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting in these communities.