Tutte le storie

Un maschiaccio che non ha mai fatto la transizione, ora aiuta gli altri

Femmina · Desistito/a227
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma che si è impegnata a fondo nelle discussioni online sulla detransizione e gender critical, offrendo sostegno e prospettive critiche agli altri. Mi descrivo come una donna maschiaccio felice di essere vista per ciò che è, e riconosco ad attività all'aperto come il backpacking, l'escursionismo e l'arrampicata il merito di aver risolto la mia disforia. Credo che il trauma e la misoginia interiorizzata vengano spesso scambiati per disforia di genere e sostengo l'elaborazione del trauma prima di considerare la transizione. Ho dubbi sulla mancanza di ricerche a lungo termine sui bloccanti della pubertà e sugli ormoni del sesso opposto iniziati in infanzia. Non descrivo alcuna transizione medica personale né rimpianti, perché non ho mai fatto la transizione.

Storia completa

I was born female and have lived as a woman throughout my adult life. I've never identified as trans or transitioned, but I've spent a lot of time in online spaces discussing gender, transition, and detransition, and I've formed strong views on these topics based on my own experiences and reading. I've noticed that I've been criticized far less as a woman than people might expect. I've been seen as attractive even with under-eye bags, redness, scars, and uneven skin tone. My clothes don't have to match to look good, and my clothing, skin, and hair can all be messy and still be found as normal or even attractive. I don't get cat-called or harassed by women in general. Many men in my life have told me about the pressures women describe, and I recognize that experiences vary depending on the spaces you visit online, where you live in real life, and many other factors. I have a deep voice for a woman, which I attribute partly to smoking cigarettes. I've offered reassurance to others about their voices, telling one person their voice reads as female or androgynous to me. I'm a tomboy woman and I'm very happy being seen as whatever I am. I have huge shoulders for a woman, which we call swimmer shoulders, and I consider them no less feminine. I have white blonde eyelashes and don't wear makeup, just sunscreen. I've found that shifting my goal from being conventionally beautiful to being myself has been transformative. Inner beauty and self-love matter more to me than conventional standards. What really changed my life was consciously focusing my energy away from how other people view me and toward things I love that empower me as a human being. I realized other people's perception of me has no actual implication for who I am. For me, the activities that helped were backpacking, hiking, and rock climbing, all traditionally men's activities. My dysphoria disappeared when I became physically and emotionally engaged in activities that forced me to rely on myself. Others' social and gender opinions no longer mattered to me. I've thought a lot about how trauma relates to gender identity. I believe transitioning physically can be another way to avoid trauma processing and can cause long-term health and mental damage. Many girls and young women experience abuse and associate being a woman with being weak and vulnerable to more abuse, so it's logical not to want to be a woman in that case and to try to make oneself into a lesser target, i.e., a masculine man. How our mothers and fathers are treated, or treat each other, affects our perception of gender too. Growing up seeing or experiencing one parent's abuse can alter how we feel about that gender and about ourselves. Many, if not all, abuse victims experience some sort of body image issues or bodily dissociation, and these are often mistaken for gender dysphoria related to being trans. Abuse from a young age has a profound effect on the body and mind, and that effect cannot be seen for what it is without healing and processing. It takes years, if not decades, for people to heal from serious abuse and multiple traumas. I think it's absurd to think trauma has no connection to gender identity and body image. I've recommended reading The Body Keeps the Score. I've also spoken about internalized misogyny as something that needs to be addressed as soon as possible. Seeing feminine things as weak is misogynistic. Women are strong as hell, and there is no right way to be a woman. I've suggested that a good therapist or trusted friends can help unpack these feelings. I've encouraged others to commit to caring for the body they're in now, despite gender or sex, and to use meditation, exercise, hobbies, art, books, and crafts to help with obsessive self-image thoughts. I've advised people considering transition to shut off transitioning-related media consumption completely for a month or two and see how they feel in their life with as little influence from media as possible. I know this can be difficult because media brings a sense of community and therefore comfort, but I believe it's extremely important if anyone is thinking about transitioning. On hormones, I've shared information about physical side effects from medical sources like the Mayo Clinic, while noting I can't speak to emotional side effects from personal experience. I've said that switching hormones causes huge upsets in normal sex drive, mood, and physique, varying person to person, and that it's not normal for women to be tired or low-energy all the time. I've noted there isn't much information out there about long-term puberty blockers and opposite-sex hormone use since childhood, or whether effects can be naturally reversed in adulthood by quitting artificial hormones, and I've recommended having T levels tested and working with a doctor to ensure health and safety. I've observed that plenty of women continue to have breast growth from 20 to 25 naturally, and I'm not sure how or if testosterone would factor into that. I've also noted that certain experiences are common for pretty much all women, even if being a trans woman magnifies them somewhat. I don't describe any personal regret about transition because I never transitioned. My current identity is a detransitioned-adjacent perspective: I am a woman who has never transitioned but who holds critical views on transition based on my experiences and research. I continue to engage in these conversations and offer support and perspective to others navigating gender-related questions.