Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto desistenza — nata femmina, omosessuale, mai transitata medicalmente, quindi non ho nulla da rimpiangere. Ho vissuto una non conformità di genere nell'infanzia e anni di riflessione sulla transizione all'università, ma ne sono uscita riconoscendo che il mio desiderio era sfuggire alla condizione femminile più che diventare maschio, e i pensieri intrusivi sono svaniti. Ora sostengo una terapia esplorativa invece che affermativa, avverto sui danni alla salute degli ormoni del sesso opposto e sostengo attivamente online chi fa detransition e desistenza nonostante i ban da altri forum. Mi identifico come donna che ha fatto desistenza, vicina all'area lesbica, che rifiuta il concetto di identità di genere e insiste sul fatto che il sesso non può essere cambiato.
Storia completa
I was born female, and I have never medically transitioned — I am a desister, not a detransitioner. That distinction matters to me: for me, desisted means nothing medical ever happened, no hormones, no surgeries, and I came through it unscathed with nothing to regret.
My story starts in childhood. Other kids would ask me if I was a boy or a girl, and their second question was always "wouldn't you prefer to be a boy?" — because I had short hair, loved playing soccer, and socialized better with boys than girls. I usually got invited to boys' birthday parties but much less to girls' ones. When we played and a boy figure was needed, it was always me. I never understood their question. I was me, and I was comfortable with my short hair, sports clothes, and boy friends (I had a few girl friends too, but fewer). I remember being mistaken for a boy as a teenager and in my early twenties.
In college I started frequenting what were first gay spaces open to bi people, then the T entered the room and "its sweetly worded lullaby started entering my head." I hesitated for years. The only thought that kept me from transitioning was that I wouldn't do anything until all doubts were gone. After years of pacing myself, I understood several things: what I really wanted was to be heard and listened to the way boys were; I wanted safety, to be able to walk down the street without being harassed; I wanted my words not to be questioned because I was a girl. On the other side, I knew that if I were to be a boy, it wouldn't be what I'd look like after multiple surgeries — my idealized idea did not include being small and having scars all over. In other words, I already knew I wouldn't be a real boy regardless of what I did to my body. Once I accepted that my thoughts came from wanting to escape the female condition, the intrusive thoughts slowly went away.
I also realized before going medical that it was all idealized thoughts and blind self-delusion — thinking the grass would be greener on the other side. Realizing that having scars and a dysfunctional body were not what I had in mind: what I had in mind was a magical button, and that one doesn't exist. For me it was knowing there was no way back if I ever changed my mind, and I did change my mind; with time and other priorities it became less and less important.
Society made me believe women were not as good as men, not as skilled, not as resilient, not as strong, not as intelligent — only good for soft stuff, home stuff. I stopped wishing I had been born a man when I understood women are stronger and I am a woman. There's a saying in my mother tongue that behind every great man there is a woman, and when in doubt I remind myself of that. Up to us to keep showing the world women are as capable as men, and they don't need to adopt other behaviors to do it.
I know that if I had been born ten years earlier I would have transitioned out of sheer pressure of today's society — I'd be in someone else's spot, probably in a weaker-minded position, letting myself be sweet-talked into transitioning by the T community. Many of us would have been transed if we had been born a decade earlier.
English is not my mother language; in my native language sex carries a dirty undertone and "gender" was the polite way of saying sex, which is why I resist the push to separate the two. I'm desisted, I'm homosexual, and I want to be given the same value as anyone else — no special category, no special treatment, no weaponized sexuality. I don't want to be part of groups aiming for visibility and demanding special rights; I want to show the world we are as much within the norm as anyone else, and that means being invisible within the masses.
I have been active in this community for years, offering support, and I've been banned from other subreddits — once for saying biology isn't transphobic, once for supporting detrans people, and once for explaining that repressors and detransitioners are not the same. I've also been banned from a trans subreddit where a mod told me to get a college biology book when I said one cannot change sex. At work, the LGB staff group has been taken over by T ideas since they added that letter, and voicing disagreement gets you hell while HR, not wanting to be labeled phobic, agrees to whatever they push.
I care deeply about young people being pushed into transition, about therapists who affirm rather than dig for root causes, and about the health harms of cross-sex hormones. I encourage people to find non-affirming therapists or psychoanalysts, to explore root causes, to quit the internet and live outside, and to keep clear of ideological circles. I've shared the Cass Review and WPATH files with friends. I believe desisted and detransitioned people are far more numerous than the 1% figure often cited, and I think it would help if more of us spoke publicly so public perception becomes accurate.
On body image: I was convinced I looked like a teenage boy for the longest time despite boys telling me my traits were too fine to be those of a boy. Self perception is part of the problem we all faced. What works for me is removing the mirrors from home — my life drastically improved. I also dealt with baggy clothes in college and it took a few months to get accustomed to tighter clothes again; it's mostly a question of habit.
I have dealt with intrusive thoughts and found that keeping my mind busy, consciously diverting my attention, and questioning the thoughts until I understood why they come works for me. For me they were unrealistic expectations of what my life "could be if…" — once I realized they were all idealized thoughts, they started to go away. When a disruptive thought crosses my mind I acknowledge it by saying "thank you for sharing" and let it move on.
I am a desisted woman who is homosexual, and I hold critical, often oppositional views about transition for others while being supportive of individuals working through doubt.