Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha fatto detransizione o che non ha mai completato la transizione, mi identifico come autoginefilo e credo che la mia disforia di genere derivi da traumi infantili e da un feticismo, non da un’identità femminile. Non ho descritto ormoni o interventi, ma ho intenzione di presentarmi in modo più androgino anziché fare la transizione, dicendo che vorrei sempre tornare a essere maschio. Sono molto critico verso i terapeuti di genere, l’ideologia trans e le comunità trans online, ma anche contrario agli utenti omofobi nel subreddit detrans. Ho consigliato terapia, antidepressivi e CBT a me stesso e ad altri con sentimenti simili. Non ho reso nota una diagnosi formale, una data precisa di detransizione né alcuna ideazione suicidaria.
Storia completa
I have been active in the r/detrans community since around April 2019, and much of what I have written there is advice I have given to other people questioning their gender — advice that is clearly rooted in my own experience and beliefs about my own situation.
I identify as autogynephilic (AGP). I have written plainly, "I am an AGP myself," and "I have no intention to be a female and I would always want to go back being male." I have also said, "I don't really want to be a woman or anything if I woke up as the most attractive women in history I would go back to a slightly more ugly version of myself, so in no way am I trans." At the same time, I have described real distress with my natal sex: "I can't stand living in a female body, I would miss being male." That sentence, together with my repeated references to being male and to AGP, indicates I was born male. Because of that conflict, I have said, "For me transitioning isn't an option, I have to switch back and forth between male and female, so I'm planning on being more androgynous." I have not given explicit ages, dates of first dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgeries for myself, so I cannot build a precise timeline from this transcript.
My thinking about my own feelings has been heavily shaped by Blanchard's typology. I distinguish between what I call "homosexual transsexuals" (HSTS), who I believe have a partially feminized brain because of their female sexuality and attraction to masculine men, and autogynephilic transsexuals, whom I regard as males with a fetish. I have linked to research (an NCBI article) arguing that AGP trans women are not women, and I have argued that AGP is not pseudoscience: "autogynephilia is not pseudo science it's a real thing." I have also said that "gender identity is not a thing" and that gender is not a spectrum, citing an Aeon essay against the gender-spectrum idea.
I believe my AGP developed out of trauma. I have written that "many of us have had trauma wich causes us to want to turn into our autogynephilic persona" and that trauma doesn't have to be abuse — "children are delicate so they can easily be traumatized, your memory can also be repressed too." I have suggested that AGP creates a female persona built up through sexual reward and used as an escape from one's real self, and I have speculated that "AGP and AAP are types of dissociative disorder, but very complex ones." I have also linked AGP to other mental health conditions: OCD, trauma, BDD, BPD, sexual frustration, DID, anxiety disorders, psychosis, autism, and ADHD, and I have said that treating these comorbidities can diminish dysphoria.
I have not described undergoing hormones or surgery myself, but I am clearly concerned about their risks: I have warned that "hrt can cause liver problems and cancer," that "transitioning at 50 is horrible," and that most trans people "attempt suicide after transitioning." I have described GRS in graphic terms as "chopping of your dick and making a hole inside of you" and argued that the result "wouldn't be a functional organ anymore." I have repeatedly urged people to talk to a therapist before irreversible procedures and to explore past abuse as a possible cause of bottom dysphoria.
My own mental health picture is partly implied rather than stated directly. I have mentioned depersonalization/derealization in the context of someone else's post, and I have recommended antidepressants, CBT, and psychotherapy for dysphoria and comorbid conditions. I have not disclosed a formal diagnosis for myself.
On sexuality and relationships, I have commented on others' situations — for example, telling someone their boyfriend "needs to accept that he is in a gay relationship" — but I have not described my own relationships or sexual orientation directly, other than through the AGP framework I apply to myself.
I have not described a formal detransition event for myself, though I posted asking "Any Autogynephilic detransitioners here?" and I have said "I would always want to go back being male," which suggests I have either transitioned or considered it and want to reverse course. I have also said I plan to be "more androgynous" rather than fully transition or fully detransition.
I am critical of gender ideology and of gender therapists, whom I have called "full of BS pseudoscience and a waste of money." I have called r/egg_irl "an actual cult." I have also tried to get another user banned from r/detrans for what I described as homophobic and offensive comments targeting the LGBTQ+ community — showing that while I am critical of trans ideology, I also push back against overtly homophobic speech in the community. I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond these Reddit posts.
Overall, I would say my regret is not about specific medical procedures I have undergone (I have not described any), but about the whole framework of my dysphoria — I see it as a trauma-driven fetish rather than a genuine identity, and I want to reconcile myself to being male while acknowledging that I "can't stand living in a female body."