Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nato maschio e ho fatto detransizione circa quattro anni fa, dopo essermi identificato come trans e aver preso estrogeni per cinque anni, e ora sono un uomo che ha fatto detransizione. L'infanzia con istruzione domestica in una rigida famiglia calvinista, con un padre distante e una madre controllante, mi ha lasciato emotivamente bloccato come un bambino in un corpo da uomo adulto, cosa che ora vedo come la radice del mio desiderio di fuggire dalla mascolinità. La terapia del trauma, l'EMDR per il CPTSD, la meditazione, gli psichedelici, la distanza dai miei genitori e infine la fede cattolica hanno risolto la mia disforia di genere. Mi pento della ginecomastia che ho causato con gli estrogeni e degli anni persi, ma non provo più disforia e mi piace chi vedo allo specchio. Ho una storia che comprende alcolismo, HIV, divorzio e un precedente tentativo di suicidio, ma la mia vita e la mia salute mentale sono migliorate sostanzialmente dalla detransizione.
Storia completa
I was born male, and I'm in my mid 40s now — 36 when I came out as trans, 42 when I quit hormones after five years, and about four years out from detransitioning as I write this. I have no children, though I possibly could have some.
Growing up, I was homeschooled in a very rigid Calvinist environment. My father was distant and frightening, my mother was controlling and enmeshing and was my "teacher," and I was physically and emotionally held down, hurt, made submissive and small and alone through the period a boy is supposed to be having peers and becoming a man. I was afraid of my father and had an emotionally disorganized attachment to my mother. I now believe they systematically emasculated me and created the conditions for me being dissociated from myself and uncomfortable with embodied existence. I've connected the dots between my childhood, my addictions, and my identity issues, and I haven't gotten over blaming them for the extremely controlling way they raised me. When I try to talk to them about it now that I've detransitioned, they see no connection despite how obvious it is to me.
I was an "8yr old child who just wanted to be loved and protected, in a big hairy threatening adult male body in a world that I didn't understand." I hated my body hair, fixated on being feminine, and fantasized about being good and submissive and feminized. I internalized the view that men are categorically the oppressors — "Hey hey ho ho, the patriarchy has got to go" — and wanted to be lovable and trustable by women, believing I could never do that as a man. Porn was part of my story too; I believed it disrupted my thinking.
I came out as trans at 36. Coming out was not just euphoria but life-changing — going out "as me" was amazing, getting called she/her and by my chosen name was wonderful, I loved estrogen and being free of masculinity. But fundamentally the life-changing thing was, for the first time, taking charge of my life and identity, going all in, living my truth instead of being suppressed as I had been my entire childhood. I was trans for five years, socially and legally identifying as the other sex and changing my hormones. My trans middle name was a variant of the word "peace."
Because my parents didn't "accept me," I got away from them — a clean break from ever meeting their expectations — and was able, with what I've called my "entire clan of progressive women helpers," to grow up out of my infantilized self. I got into therapy, found communities, began meditating, went all in trying to be well and understand reality. I took very heavy psychedelic doses with therapeutic intentions, talking it through with my therapist, and did DMT several times, which I found very helpful in getting to reality "under" my trauma-related narratives and attachments. Along the way I had spiritual experiences, sober and not.
The therapy I was in was a trans-positive, feminist, trauma-informed, body-positive modality with a female counselor. It took two years of work with her, with her never betraying or belittling me, for me to trust her enough to uncover and share how broken and unworthy I felt inside. That's when we began approaching the work as CPTSD therapy and preparing to do EMDR, which was life-changing — literal spiritual experiences and breakthroughs and feeling what "safe" felt like for the first time, along with a lot of ugly crying. I also did talk trauma therapy, body awareness work, and meditation. I received a CPTSD diagnosis and began understanding dysregulation and emotional flashbacks. A Buddhist book, "Love Your Enemies" by Sharon Salzberg, was very important on my journey.
Notably, when I asked my counselor outright if my childhood stuff had anything to do with my gender stuff, she assured me it didn't, and I believed her. Basically every other question I asked she'd refuse to be my authority, but that one she affirmed. Yet working through my trauma led me to stop being reactive to having a male body.
The process of detransition was gradual. I reached a point where being seen as male wasn't triggering; I stopped giving myself my estrogen shots right on time and eventually stopped for a few weeks. Body hair coming back didn't freak me out. Part of it was philosophical — I stopped believing in constructivism and started perceiving sex as a basic feature of embodied human reality, which made me sad I had turned away from that. I had chickened out of my castration appointment, so I still could possibly participate in creating life. At first detransition was mere acceptance — "I no longer believe it's true that 'woman' is a word that applies to me" — and increased toleration for androgenic characteristics. Being called "he" didn't crush me anymore. I made a post announcing I no longer identified as a woman and basically disappeared from those social spaces.
A spiritual leader in "the community" pretended to be supportive of my "discovering a new facet of my identity" while publicly accusing me of being on team "wants to kill trans children." I decided to completely check out of the social spaces I had been in. I couldn't handle being part of the culture war aspect of trans/detrans or going along with the philosophy of trans, so I mostly checked out of that social world.
I became Catholic. I had never been to Mass; I figured out what parish I was in, went as a visitor, was touched by the homily, went back the next week, said hello to the deacon, and joined OCIA (Order of Christian Initiation of Adults), which took most of a year. I'm just a lay faithful now. I was a trans uu and went to seminary trying to figure out life and reality and help queer religion for collective liberation, and Jesus met me along the way. I've mentioned having been trans to people and literally no one's made a big thing about it.
Medical specifics: I was on estrogen injections. My testosterone was 30 ng/dL around my last estrogen shot, 289 three months later, 444 three months after that, then dipped and stabilized around 400. I gave myself gynecomastia, which I would take back if I could — I have "man boobs" now and am working on losing the weight I gained on estrogen and after detransitioning. The fibrous glandular tissue won't go away on its own; involution can reduce mass but I've considered keyhole surgery, though I'm worried about permanent nerve pain. I haven't decided about surgery.
I've dealt with a lot: I describe myself as an "ex alcoholic sui survivor detrans hiv+ divorced under employed grad school dropout." I tried to check out (a suicide attempt) at some point. I've had addictions including alcohol and porn; quitting porn has been the most difficult thing I've quit. I was an atheist for a long time. I'm currently underemployed and work delivering Amazon packages, where I discovered I was getting a lot of BPA exposure through Amazon labels, so I started growing broccoli sprouts, eating beans, and getting rid of plastic dishes and nonstick pans.
Family: I feel guilt about not being a good brother and uncle and normalizing trans stuff. My parents are super conservative, my siblings are normy liberal centrists. They all know I detransitioned but I haven't exactly apologized. We pretend things are fine, like we always have. I can't be around my parents without my original issues resurfacing; being around them triggers my wanting to emasculate myself and shrink down into nothingness, and a lingering draw toward feminine presentation.
On regret: I'm sad about not having grown up into my body sooner, and I'd take back the gynecomastia. But basically I'm over my body dysphoria — I'm no longer angry or grossed out by my body, though I still sometimes have the sense of not knowing how to do "being a man in the world." I still feel some degree of "behind the curve" when it comes to living my calling as a man. I do like who I see in the mirror. I don't experience what I used to call gender dysphoria anymore. I don't entirely regret the trans experience because I did a lot of figuring myself out and healing; I called it a "heroic journey even if where you once thought you were heading was a mirage."
Currently: I'm working, going to church, going on hikes, lifting weights (full-body compound movements — pushups, dumbbell rows, goblet squats, Romanian deadlifts), and building virtue. My quality of life has improved substantially; I'm okay with existing. I've moved past mere acceptance into actually living into my masculinity as the gift of my reality as a created being.
On advocacy: I don't believe anyone "is trans" in the essential sense; I now hold a biological essentialist and Christian realist view of the human person. I accept that based on what I previously understood "transphobic" to mean, it's impossible for me to avoid that label if I'm going to share what I've learned. I don't believe it's right to be mean or harsh to individuals caught in the emotional pain that leads to transition. I don't encourage medical transition and generally advise working with, not against, the body. I've been told no one has tried to put me on a stage as a cautionary tale in four years.