Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha desistito e si identifica come persona che ha fatto la detransizione: al liceo ho vissuto come un ragazzo di nome Nicholas ma non ho mai fatto una transizione medica. Ora mi identifico come lesbica con opinioni fortemente gender-critical, e attribuisco il mio desiderio passato di essere vista come maschio in gran parte alla misoginia, alla paura di essere sessualizzata e al fatto di non piacermi "essere una DONNA nello specifico". Non ho mai avuto ormoni né interventi, quindi nessun rimpianto fisico, ma descrivo l'inadeguatezza sessuale e romantica che provavo come la parte peggiore dell'identificarmi come uomo trans, e dico che se avessi fatto la transizione e fossi stata rifiutata perché troppo femminile mi sarei uccisa. Ho accennato al fatto che una volta mi hanno detto che ero "psicotica", a una fobia degli aghi, a una paranoia per la salute e a una personalità incline alle dipendenze, e dopo una serie di brutte relazioni mi sono in gran parte ritirata dalle persone. Resto critica verso la transizione per gli altri, soprattutto per i giovani, e al momento non ho pensieri suicidi.
Storia completa
I was born female, and I have never physically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — yet I went through a period where I felt like I was detransitioning anyway. In high school I had gone in presenting as a boy, and later tried to come back as a girl, which my family experienced as sudden and worrying, even though I had been thinking about it for a long time. My final name when I was living as a guy was Nicholas; I described it as "just a guy vibing" and said my biggest problem was that I didn't like being a WOMAN specifically, rather than anything about maleness I wanted.
I now define myself as a woman — "an adult human female" — and I say plainly, "You're a girl," to others in my position, and I don't mean it mockingly. At the same time, I describe myself as one of those people who doesn't feel strong identifying attachments to being male or female: if my consciousness were put in any other body, I'd still be me. I'm a desister, not someone who medically transitioned and reversed it.
What pushed me toward identifying as male wasn't a desire to become a man so much as aversions and fears I associate with being a woman. I've written at length about the female experience of constant sexualization, fear of assault, being told men are stronger and never to trust them, the paralyzing fear when a strange man knocks on my car window. I've said the worst thing about being a trans man for me would have been the sexual and romantic inadequacy I felt — having desires in line with my natural body, being emotional, not wanting to "wear the pants" all the time. I said that if I had transitioned, spent the time and money, then fallen in love with a girl who left me for a natal man because I was "a little bit too much of a faerie," I would actually kill myself — "I'm not joking." I called masculine inadequacy "probably the most painful thing I've ever experienced."
I'm very critical of how transition is promoted now. I argue that "mentally ill and traumatized people don't make rational decisions about their world or body and one way it presents is by choosing to be transgender." I think a lot of the current wave is children not knowing what's going on with them — hormones, puberty, trauma bonding, attention-seeking — and I'm skeptical that as many of them are autistic as they claim, saying they're mistaking the fear and awkwardness of young adulthood for autism. I recall that when I was younger, the "list of disorders to have" was BPD, DPD, autism, ADHD, depression, with ASPD if you were edgy and DID if you were weird, and "all of them had gender fuckery going on." I was on Tumblr "in the depths" of it, where the help provided was warnings that binding can damage breast tissue, hormones aren't a boy/girl pill, and surgery can have complications — versus today's "oppression Olympics." I've said I don't care if somebody transitions if they know the hidden consequences, and that surgery is expensive, permanent, and if you regret it the body part will never be the same.
I'm a lesbian and I hold strongly gender-critical views. I've defended the TERF label, saying it's "a buzzword used by men, and women with internalized misogyny, to invalidate the thoughts and feelings of women," and that "there's nothing wrong with being a TERF." I've said "non-men loving non-men" is offensive — "please,,, just let women have something." I identify as a "sexually feminine switch bisexual woman" in one comment while elsewhere insisting on keeping the lesbian label; I've advised others not to give up the lesbian label if it's one of the last stable things in their identity. I've described myself as an "atheistic witch" and argued spirituality shouldn't be used to validate being transgender.
On adversity and mental health: I've referenced having "a rough week," health paranoia (I do sugar tests even though I'm not diabetic, having to smack my finger hard to distract from a lancet because of needle phobia), an "addictive personality" that's lucky alcohol causes me physical pain, and being told I was "psychotic" at one point by someone else in a thread about my situation. I've been called manipulative before, by an ex. I've described my life as "moving laterally" and said I don't bother with people anymore because I've had too many bad experiences: a cheating ex girlfriend, an old man who asked if I'd use my body as payment for a truck, an ex boyfriend who wouldn't talk like a human or wash regularly, three crazy girl friends, a boy who told me his abandonment issues five minutes after meeting, another who said I was "girlfriend material" but "hates my personality." I'm 5 foot nothing and own an old straight-piped diesel F-350. I'm the oldest of 3 kids; our parents didn't care what we were interested in. My sister is a straight girl who dresses like a boy and laughs when misgendered; my brother is a long-haired hippie. I said "I didn't NEED anymore childhood. I had enough."
I've had therapy experiences I was skeptical of — I said a therapist's question shouldn't be "How do you know what you really are?" and warned that patients are customers, recounting ditching a nurse after she noted she thought I was "fishing for drugs" when I raised ADHD. I've advised others to get new therapists and to interrogate the root causes of wanting to be seen as male, which I attribute largely to misogyny. I've been blunt in giving advice — telling someone "WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO HAVE CHILDREN WITH A FUCKING ALCOHOLIC?" and pushing them to leave an obsessive, unhealthy relationship. I don't do advocacy or activism; I said this is the only "queer space" I participate in.