Tutte le storie

Radicalizzazione su Tumblr, guerre dei pronomi e l'uscita nel 2022

Femmina · Detransizionato/a739
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata, nata femmina, molto non conforme al genere da bambina, con una diagnosi, e ho fatto la transizione dopo essermi radicalizzata da adolescente nei circoli SJW di Tumblr, in parte per senso di colpa da persona bianca e per il desiderio di non essere vista come un'«oppressora». Per anni ho fatto la transizione con ormoni e modifiche corporee, sono stata verbalmente violenta con le persone care per via dei pronomi, e nel 2022 sono arrivata a credere che i mammiferi non possano cambiare sesso, ho lasciato l'ideologia e ho iniziato la detransizione. Mi pento dell'ostilità mostrata verso la mia famiglia, dei brutti risultati fisici e degli anni perduti, e dico «non riesco a perdonarmi», anche se sto lavorando per accettarmi. Sono ebrea e israeliana, non mi identifico più come di sinistra e ora vedo la transizione come statisticamente poco probabile da funzionare e simile a una setta, e sostengo dei limiti, soprattutto per i minori. Non ho descritto pensieri suicidi miei, solo affermazioni manipolatorie che un tempo facevo alla mia famiglia.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up very gender nonconforming — as a child I wasn't like the other kids, my interests didn't stereotypically align, and I always stood out. I received diagnoses (I was "a cut-and-dry case") and, looking back, I now describe that discomfort with my sex as appearance-based anxiety — "a very anxious, repetitive, almost ruminating/obsessive compulsive behavior to constantly rehash issues of my 'gender.'" I transitioned and lived for years as a trans person, taking hormones and pursuing body modifications. I now say I have "sleptwalk into this" and "woke up in a body that I totally ruined," feeling horror at the changes. I describe the process as having been "like joining a very strict religion" — I told myself it was self-exploration but it wasn't. What pulled me in, I now believe, was social contagion on Tumblr roughly 12 years ago (around 2010, when I was a teenager). I was nerdy and unlike others in my class, and I bonded online with low-status kids. "On Tumblr, the bullying was about being 'oppressed.' It wasn't 'cool' to be normal." Over time I accepted ideological premises and my inhibitions became "more liquid" — I liken it to joining a religion/cult where you slowly compromise your values. A big motivator was white guilt: I didn't want to be seen in the same light as the "oppressors," so transitioning was a way to be "down with the cause" and escape the stereotypes of my sex and race. I also say generally that people transition because they dislike the stereotypes of their sex — for many girls, wanting to be seen as intelligent, capable, strong rather than "just made for babies," out of jealousy for males perceived as superior. I was "nerdy," low-status, and seeking peer approval on multiple fronts — race and sex — from the "woke community." I was extremely antagonistic toward my loved ones during that period. I said things I knew were not true — "I will kill myself!" and "I have always wanted to be a girl!" — to pressure them, causing real strain in our relationships and family. I was "verbally abusive" to people who wouldn't use my pronouns: "I was a zealot, and I have enormous regret." I demanded pronouns "or else it was this whole, big, fundamental disrespect." I also felt an ideological, moral obligation to "be vocal" and "normalize being trans," overriding my natural privacy. The turning point was realizing that mammals cannot change sex — "it was as if I just awoke one day with clarity" and everything came crashing down. I saw that all the changes were built on a faith-based premise that wasn't physically real. I also became disillusioned with the left generally: "When I saw the upper limits of the worldview, it all fell apart for me extremely quickly. I tried to keep it all together, for a time, but I sincerely felt as though I was living in the closet." I am no longer a leftist and no longer accept intersectionality. I describe the ideology as functioning like a cult and say "we pretty much got radicalized and joined a cult." By June 2022 I had decided to detransition but had not yet done so. I was paralyzed with anxiety about stopping treatment — too afraid to even ask my doctor because it would feel like "admitting defeat." My main fears were the medical downstream effects of stopping, what I would look like, and whether loved ones would reject me — both those who finally got on board after my antagonism and those who had pushed me to "accept my true womanhood." I was held back by sunk cost and embarrassment. I also worried about the social fallout and about admitting I was wrong after asserting I was "so certain to the contrary." I later confirmed I was actively detransitioning: "I have transitioned. But now, I'm detransitioning. Because living like this is tiring." I described the burden: taking all the medicine, constant anxiety about whether I pass, worrying about imperfections at certain angles, and the frustration of updating documentation for name and gender marker. "It's all so much work and, after all of this, it just doesn't feel like a life." I wish I had focused on accepting my nonconformity rather than making huge changes. I also had a natural aversion to modifying my body even before transition — even getting my ears pierced felt like "chipping away at my body" and "violating it somehow" — yet I pushed through it, which now makes me emotional to think about. I have enormous regret about how I treated people and about the whole endeavor: "I feel foolish and embarrassed that people in my life were right." I say "I can't forgive myself" while hoping others in my position might forgive themselves. I frame my body changes as botched plastic surgery: "I got body modifications, plastic surgeries, that just were not right for me." I say transition "has resulted in really poor appearance for me" and that I went in with unrealistic expectations of looking convincingly the other sex — "That was on me." I also say I have "accidentally misgendered myself" and that using my chosen pronouns requires active effort — "I never accidentally use my chosen pronoun" — which felt like my brain "telling on me." On fertility I have not spoken directly, but I do list "fertility" among the things one loses in transition. On medical needs, I was on hormones and describe being tired of "all this medicine" and the "upkeep" of extreme body modifications. Mentally, I describe chronic anxiety, rumination, cognitive dissonance ("Every day, the cognitive dissonance was so great"), and exhaustion — "It's exhausting," "I feel burnt out," "I'm pretty tired of being at crossroads." I distanced myself from therapists because I saw "the way that they allow their own agendas to take primacy over their very own patients," though I acknowledge I may need to find one willing to have hard conversations. I have not described suicidal ideation of my own beyond quoting things I said manipulatively to family. I am Jewish, born and living in Israel, speak Hebrew daily, have been a practicing Jew my entire life, and have voted for the leftist party in my country every cycle — though I no longer identify as a leftist. I don't own a TV. I have a private, throwaway-account sensibility and have moved away from the LGBT impulse to "come out" or announce life decisions: "I have no obligation to anyone or anything, and my life is mine, and only mine." On sexuality I have not described orientation directly, but I do discuss sexual factors as general transition motivations: I ask others considering transition "Do I experience sexual arousal when I imagine myself as a female? Is there presence of a sex/pornography addiction?" and I say "Sexual gratification isn't a reason to change your body. Porn is really bad for males, especially." I also affirm that some people do transition for sexual gratification reasons and that they "are real, and they matter." I now hold a strongly critical view of transition, especially for others: I think it is "statistically improbable that transition will work for most individuals," that it is among "some of the most risky, physically taxing, and variable" body modifications, and I support "reasonable guardrails, most especially with children." I am skeptical of ideology of any sort and advocate a simple, pragmatic life. I have not described formal activism, but I do share my story publicly as a cautionary tale and say "If my life story can help someone wrap their minds around these choices and be better informed, what more can I ask for?" I admire detransitioners like Helena Kerschner who speak out and have exchanged messages with her. I am critical of "oppression olympics," deplatforming, and what I see as high-control, coercive behavior in activist circles, and I defend broad free-speech principles.