Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nata femmina e a circa 21 anni ho fatto la transizione per vivere come uomo, con otto anni di testosterone, dopo un’infanzia di forte misoginia in famiglia, bullismo per i miei «interessi maschili» e stereotipi di genere interiorizzati che mi facevano credere di essere maschio dentro. Ho fatto detransition circa sei anni fa smettendo il T di colpo, cosa che ha causato una grave perdita di capelli permanente, il mio più grande rimpianto, ma da allora sono guarita completamente dalla disforia di genere e passo al 100% per femmina. La detransition ha migliorato drasticamente la mia vita, anche se ho perso gli amici della comunità trans, che oggi descrivo come simile a una setta. Ho ancora alcuni effetti permanenti (voce più profonda, peli sul viso da radere, clitoride ingrossato) ma ho imparato ad accettare il mio corpo. Oggi sono una donna eterosessuale che ha fatto detransition, credo che la transizione sia a volte utile ma spesso guidata da stereotipi e misoginia, e sostengo la consapevolezza sulla detransition e mi oppongo a interventi irreversibili come la falloplastica.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in the 2000s in a household where being compared to my mother was used as an insult. My father was a misogynist who constantly told us how weak and stupid women are, and my mother was mentally abused daily in a loveless marriage she stayed in 'for the kids.' She did not rescue us while we were being beaten because my dad told her to leave, and I have memories of being abused, crying for her help, and watching her walk away with her head down. My sister also had an undiagnosed mental disorder and was full of screaming rage even as a small child. This combination left me with deep internalized misogyny — I grew to hate women and therefore hated myself for being female, without realizing it.
From a very young age I was bullied by peers and reprimanded by adults for having 'male interests' — WWF wrestling, Ninja Turtles, Mighty Ducks, videogames, Spiderman, superheroes, toy cars, sports — and for rejecting 'girl things' like dolls, dresses, and makeup. I was called a tomboy and even a lesbian for innocuous interests. I was not allowed to watch WWF because my parents said it was only for boys, so I watched it in secret and wondered if I was 'a boy on the inside.' My clothes were chosen for me because my parents would have been embarrassed to let me wear 'boy clothes' (which were just normal t-shirts and pants that weren't pink). I was also told I had to grow up, get pregnant, and have children because that is 'a woman's duty in life,' which terrified me because my mother was miserable, was cheated on, and stayed in the marriage anyway — she seemed to me like a broken and abused baby dispenser. I was raised in a religious household that taught me a woman's duty was to be obedient, passive, modest, and maternal. All of this led me to believe my body was a birth defect that needed to be cured.
I was also a victim of sexual harassment and resented the females in my life for abusing me. My dysphoria became severe: I avoided public restrooms for about six years during public school and college, holding it until I got home — at worst I would only pee once a day. I avoided mirrors or used only a small mirror to see my face, because looking at my body (especially my breasts and vagina) would ruin my day or make me spiral into self-harm. I wore a chest binder for 14 years and hated my breasts intensely; they were the biggest source of dysphoria and the thing that most 'shattered' my male appearance.
I believed I was trans since childhood. To get a prescription for testosterone I only had to tell my gender therapist that I always thought I should have been born male. Her follow-up questions were not thorough — things like 'Why do you keep your hair short?' and 'You've NEVER worn a brassiere??' — and I was approved after just three appointments. In hindsight the 'evidence' that I was trans was all bogus. I had undiagnosed PCOS before starting T, which gave me 'crazy frankenperiods' that went on for literal weeks. My endocrinologist seemed uncomfortable prescribing and I now suspect a law or policy prevented her from denying me.
I identified as male for about six years before actually transitioning, and lived as a man for eight years on testosterone, starting at about 21 years old. I was deeply involved in a transgender support group in Virginia for about six years. Group therapy speakers stressed the importance of cutting friends and family out of our lives who didn't agree with our transition, and I remember thinking unequivocally that I was totally prepared to do that. I surrounded myself with only people who thought the same way, forming what I now see as a cycle of misinformation — a 'utopia' where gender was fluid or didn't exist, essentially a support group for people born with a 'birth defect' we needed to correct with hormones and surgery. I was absolutely sold on transitioning; no one could have talked me out of it. I also had a teenage obsession with yaoi that made me wish I were male, which I now recognize as a sexual/fetish factor influencing my transition.
My life seemed to improve for the first year on T, but in hindsight that was more the satisfaction of accomplishing my goal of starting HRT when everyone said I couldn't. Over the course of eight years I realized the dysphoria didn't go away. I couldn't get a job to support myself and continued living in a very unhappy environment because no one would take me seriously enough to hire me. I never passed well enough after 7+ years on T to be recognized as male — I was stuck in what I described as the '13-year-old-boy-or-30-year-old-bulldyke realm' — and it was the most humiliating time of my life with no real support system. I had no surgery because I could never afford it, and the inability to afford top surgery tormented me for years.
I started to slowly let myself question everything. I used to stop myself from considering that I wasn't trans or that I was on the wrong path, shutting down any moment of doubt immediately. I partnered up and moved far away from where I grew up with the intention of stopping HRT cold-turkey and living as a completely different person for a while, just to see how it felt. I skipped my weekly injection one week and never took another dose. It was the best decision I made in 14 years — the fog dissipated and I could finally rationalize my behavior and my past desire to become a man.
Stopping cold-turkey had serious consequences. About two weeks after skipping my dose I noticed my hair falling out more rapidly. Between stopping T and allowing my body to reestablish normal estrogen production, my hormones were so out of whack for a couple of months that my hair fell out at an alarming rate for about two months. I had about 3/4 major hair loss, and after over three years off T it has not grown back — my doctor says it probably never will. This is my single biggest regret of how I detransitioned, and I now advise others to wean off gradually instead. I also experienced menopausal symptoms for a couple of weeks including muscle aches and hot flashes/night sweats. My period came back almost immediately after stopping, just as weird as ever for a few months before balancing out. A doctor told me I didn't seem to need estrogen or birth control to regulate my hormones further, though I was later put on an estrogen booster combined with birth control specifically to treat my PCOS, which made my periods much more manageable.
The physical recovery has been extensive. After about 2.5 years I considered myself fully 'recovered' from the effects of testosterone. I lost muscle mass and my fat redistributed again. I do not believe T changed my bones since I started at 21 after puberty and stopped growing. My facial hair got much thinner and the bluish undertone faded so much it's hard to tell I can grow a beard, though I still shave every other day and plan to get laser hair removal. My clitoris got a bit smaller after stopping but is still larger than it was before; knowing women naturally have larger clits helped me accept the permanent change. My voice was very deep on T but got a bit higher within a few months off T through voice training using MtF YouTube videos — it will never be at the pitch it was before, but it's in the female range and I never get 'Sir'ed over the phone anymore (though occasionally still on the phone, as recently as four years and six years off T). Testosterone visibly aged my skin, hair, and face, and I looked easily ten years older than I should have at the start of detransition; a daily skincare routine with a facial scrubbing brush, foaming cleanser, and retinol cream brought me back to looking my own age. I also used to jut out my lower jaw to make my chin look stronger and picked photo angles to hide my insecurity about my jawline.
Emotionally, I was unable to cry for the first year after stopping T no matter how hard I willed myself, which was frustrating because crying is therapeutic. My ability to cry came back very gradually over a year and a half. I also had great difficulty with social interaction while presenting as trans — I was hyper-selfconscious, constantly worrying whether people thought I looked or acted masculine enough, whether I sounded male enough, whether they could see through the veil, whether they were laughing at me. After detransitioning, social interaction changed for the better in a night-and-day, massive difference.
I told my family after a few months and they were happy for me. Moving away from the state I transitioned in and the pro-trans environment was the biggest help; I totally blossomed and found myself. However, I lost my trans community. Two close friends I'd made over six years in the support group slowly stopped inviting me out and eventually cut me out of their lives after I detransitioned, because my realization that hormones didn't help me cast doubt on their 'commitment' to the community. I was seen as fake or a quitter. I now describe the experience as having left a cult where nonbelievers are excommunicated. My view of the trans community shifted 180 degrees.
Sexually, I am female and straight (attracted to men), though I did date women while transitioned because I thought I should as a 'man.' I have a hunch I might be on the autism spectrum based on adult research into ASD for my nephew and recognizing Aspergers traits in my childhood, though I've never been diagnosed. I also fought for puberty blockers when I was younger but was never prescribed them, thankfully.
Detransition significantly improved my life in ways I couldn't have imagined. I feel fully recovered from gender dysphoria — it has been reversed, which is wild to think back on because I never believed a life without dysphoria was possible. I came to terms with being a woman with a crappy childhood that fostered internalized misogyny. I now see my body modifications as a testament to how far I've evolved and wear them with confidence. I pass 100% as female and haven't been mistaken for a male even once since detransitioning. I consider myself lucky to have been too poor to afford top surgery, because now that I no longer have dysphoria, the absence of my breasts would just be a reminder of an awful period of my life. I wrote a long essay posted to a gender-critical subreddit titled 'My escape from the trans echo chamber' about how gender stereotypes affected me.
My attitude toward transition for others is nuanced: I believe transitioning can benefit some people, but I think many, including myself, unknowingly did it for the wrong reasons based on misogyny and false gender stereotypes. I would not try to stop anyone from transitioning, but I stress that some effects are irreversible, that HRT doesn't ensure you'll pass, and that it may not cure dysphoria. My message to detransitioners is that regret is not worth taking your life over and that detransition is always possible. I actively advise others considering phalloplasty against it, being blunt about the risks including permanent loss of sensation. I encourage people still in discomfort after HRT to consider detransition, telling them it's really never too late.