Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I first started wondering whether I was trans in my early twenties, though I had been gender non-conforming and experiencing gender dysphoria for much longer than that. I had also struggled with depression long before it was formally diagnosed. I went ahead with medical transition: I was on estrogen for about six months and socially transitioned for about four months before I stopped HRT in early June 2020 because I had serious concerns about whether it was helping me.
What made me question the whole path was that transitioning did not alleviate my dysphoria the way I had hoped. Instead, it seemed to foster a more negative relationship with my body. Since beginning to transition I developed dysphoria about things that had never bothered me before, or that I had even liked — my shoulders, hands, feet and arms. I was wasting far more time and energy critically analyzing my body and my voice than I ever had before, and it never measured up to my own standards. On top of that, I didn't feel any different about my gender. I woke up feeling like the same person I always had been.
A turning point came at a protest in early June 2020, where I dressed in guy clothes and used my natural voice just to see how it would feel. It felt nice. Everyone treated me like a guy, and the only awkward moments came when someone asked my name or when I ran into people I knew. It felt good to chant and shout loudly and proudly without straining my voice or quieting myself. I felt more trust in my body — I could walk, crouch, sit and jump without worrying about what parts of my body I had to hide or about managing uncomfortable clothes not designed for my body. I came to think a lot of my frustration with my body was actually coming from expecting it to do things it was never intended to do, namely look like a woman's body. Still, looking around at the women at the protest, I did feel jealous of some of them for their femininity — but I also recognized that just because I may wish for something doesn't mean it's a productive or healthy thing to pursue.
I stopped estrogen cold turkey with the support of my endocrinologist after six months. I went through a period of pretty deep depression right after stopping, but it was temporary. My breasts shrank somewhat after stopping — they haven't gone away completely and may never — but they're only slightly noticeable in a normal t-shirt, and a sexual partner I saw after stopping HRT didn't even notice anything had changed until I told him. My endocrinologist told me she supported my decision, though I guessed she expected me to go back on estrogen at some point, which felt condescending.
I saw a therapist regularly throughout this period, and I recommended others in my situation do the same — specifically a regular therapist rather than only a gender therapist, so they could work through all sides of the issue including trauma and anxiety. I was very scientifically minded and a materialist, and I did not believe in gendered brains. I didn't fully buy into ROGD as a separate phenomenon, thinking it was more of a political definition than a scientific one, and I wasn't convinced by the AGP theory either, though I could relate to some of its points. I thought gender dysphoria was the most accurate explanation for why people transition, but I did not think having dysphoria meant a person had to transition. I came to think of it as analogous to depression or anxiety — a disorder. I was skeptical of people who came into detrans spaces with sweeping claims about what causes transition, comparing their reasoning to Christians who claim listening to Lady Gaga will make you gay. I pushed back hard against what I saw as unsubstantiated, conspiracy-level claims being used to soapbox in the community.
I am bisexual and attracted to men, though rarely very masculine men, and my attraction to men is not centered around bottoming. I had feminine traits from a young age that I felt I was forced to repress. I began transitioning with no illusions about ever passing. Politically I identified as a Marxist, and while detransitioning made me rethink a lot of beliefs, I still held to the fundamental analysis of class exploitation. I was critical of gender-critical (GC) feminists, arguing that their disgust at masculine features on trans women was really disgust at gender non-conforming male bodies generally, and that figures like Julia Serano had my interests more in mind than GC commentators did. I also defended the detrans subreddit staying a space for detransitioners rather than becoming an anti-trans soapbox.
By mid-July 2020 I was in a very dark place. I wrote that I was a 22-year-old male who had been ostracized pretty much my whole life and clinically depressed for at least the last 10 years. I had struggled to find motivation to keep living my whole life, latching onto various milestones — getting to middle school, high school, the next performance, a trip, college — none of which ever made me happy. Transitioning had been the first time I felt I had a future I could look forward to and be happy in. Once I knew that wasn't true, I was back to only being alive because I hadn't committed to killing myself. I was eating once a day, showering a few times a week, and laying in bed all day. I was living with roommates but isolating myself, had never had many friends, and felt that every time I got close to someone they drifted away. I had been left on read when trying to make plans. I played an instrument and had even gotten some local recognition for it, but had no motivation to pick it up. I was seeing a therapist.
By August 2020 I was still struggling. I had stopped HRT and isolated myself from most people around me, and had even been on a couple of dates as a guy, but I couldn't stop the desire to go back on HRT and transition. I was scared I wouldn't be able to repress and would end up 'cracking' later and being an even more masculine trans woman. I said I didn't want to be trans, I just wanted it to stop. I hated interacting with the world looking like a man in a dress, but not having to be perceived by other people made it easier to accept my body as it was. I hadn't been able to fully squash the trans feelings.
In September 2020 I shared a breakthrough: I no longer thought of myself as a woman. I wrote that I may still be sad or frustrated that I'm not one, but I'm still not — 'I'm a man and there's nothing wrong with that.' I acknowledged I wasn't where I wanted to be mentally yet, but saw it as a step-by-step process. By October 2020 I was actively looking for a therapist available to meet online with the goal of living with dysphoria and minimizing it — someone who would help me accept my birth sex and move forward without transitioning. I was in the United States, and I noted that I was already in therapy but it was under my transitioned name and identity.
I want to be clear about my overall view: I am not opposed to transition and believe it is the right path for many people, just possibly not for me. I came to see it like a medicine — a godsend for those who need it, but not without side effects, and it may not make sense for someone whose symptoms are more mild. I was frustrated that hearing dysphoria could only be alleviated by transitioning had influenced my decision to begin, though I understood it as a byproduct of trans people having to constantly defend their existence, so I wasn't overly bitter. I did not think detransitioning meant gender dysphoria doesn't exist, and I felt many people in the community were looking for some alternative psychology to explain why they transitioned when the truth was likely more complicated. I did not believe in predictions of a mass detransition 'floodgate,' and I pushed back against people I felt were hoping for one as revenge, arguing instead that a small section of people who transition end up detransitioning but that doesn't make us worth any less as individuals.