Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una persona desistente che in precedenza si identificava come trans e che poi ha smesso, e ora parlo e mi identifico come donna etero. La mia desistenza è nata dal rifiuto dell'autoanalisi ideologica sulle «narrazioni interiorizzate» che credo mi avesse portata a identificarmi come trans in primo luogo, e dico di essere «più libera ora di concentrarmi su ciò che posso controllare nella mia vita». Ho chiuso un'amicizia con una persona che si identifica come trans e consiglio a chi si trova in situazioni simili di limitare le perdite, dare priorità alla sicurezza economica e alla salute fisica e frequentare solo persone che li capiscono. Sono schietta e antipolitica, critica sia verso le nicchie online trans sia verso quelle detrans, perché le vedo piene di egocentrici in competizione per l'attenzione, e ho una visione del mondo fortemente anticapitalista. In questa trascrizione non parlo di ormoni, interventi, preoccupazioni sulla fertilità, complicazioni mediche, terapia né ideazione suicidaria.
Storia completa
I am a desisted person — someone who previously identified as trans and has since stopped — and I have spoken about that experience openly on this board. I never gave a detailed medical or timeline account of my own transition and detransition in these comments, so I will not invent one; what I can say is that I describe myself as desisted rather than currently identifying as trans, and I refer to a period roughly five years before October 2022 when I was, in my own words, 'just like you' — meaning I was engaged in the kind of guilt-ridden, insecure rumination about narratives, discourses, isms and phobias that I now associate with how I ended up identifying as trans.
My detransition or desistance appears to have been a process of stepping back from ideological self-scrutiny. I explicitly reject the practice of being 'hyperfocussed on what narratives we've internalised and how these allegedly harm people,' and I say that being concerned with what someone has 'internalised' is not a worthwhile use of anyone's time. I believe that process — endlessly scrutinising what kind of narratives and discourses one is forwarding — 'is what got us here,' and I say it 'probably led to her identifying as trans to begin with' when speaking of another woman. I now describe myself as 'more free now to focus on what i can control in my life,' and I say that politics and identity niches — 'the trans and detrans niches' — are full of inconsiderate egotists vying for book deals, retweets and Patreon subs, looking for ideological excuses to crush their competition. I have no interest in that fight: 'not our fight — and even when it was we had no power over the outcome of that fight.'
I am blunt and assertive rather than hedging, and I have been told off for it. One commenter called me a 'complete idiot,' which I took as a character attack against the rules of the sub; I defended my bluntness, saying I was being honest instead of 'doubting myself, and walking on eggshells.' I say that 'learning to shit-sandwich everything, walk on eggshells and be sophisticatedly, exquisitely kind won't pay the bills, won't keep you physically healthy, you can't put it on your CV.' I also say that 'none of my friends and family seem to think so' when accused of lacking compassion, and that I only care what people in 'meatspace' — real life — have to say about me, 'because that's where almost everything worth doing and everyone worth caring about is.'
I have direct experience of a friendship ending over transition. I advised a woman (OP) to 'cut your losses' with a trans-identifying friend, saying she should 'rebuild herself' and that friends are people you should be able to be at ease around. I explicitly said I was 'Speaking from experience here with my own trans-identifying former friend,' and I recommended that the two parties part ways and stop thinking about each other, focusing instead on themselves and on the people who rely on them — primarily their families. I framed this advice around financial security and physical health over the next twenty years, arguing that as the environmental and economic situation deteriorates, self-determination will depend on having resources, and that parents and siblings may need support too. I said there is 'no glory or dignity in martyring yourself for people you have fundamental philosophical disagreements with.'
I also advised that there is 'no point in wasting your time with anybody who doesn't and will probably never grok your way of seeing the world, who you are, and what is right and wrong,' and that this applies regardless of whether the other person identifies as trans — if I were advising a trans-identifying person, I would tell them not to bother trying to get through to detrans people. I take a strongly anti-capitalist and anti-political view: I say every avenue of meaning and power carved out by misfits and the poor as an escape from capitalism is eventually co-opted and commodified, 'we see it with gender and alternative sexuality culture now, and we'll see it with drug culture in the future.' I am also critical of what I call 'critical studies' as opposed to actual critical thinking and epistemology, describing the former as indoctrination and guilt-ridden rumination rather than passion-driven thought.
In more recent comments from January 2024, I wrote from a explicitly feminist and female perspective about women in creative spaces, saying 'they don't care if they push young straight women out of creative spaces and towards the wasteland of abusive relationships, shitty underpaid jobs, and motherhood drudgery that is out there for us,' and that 'every straight woman is a potential mum.' I encouraged women not to let others 'stop doing your cool shit so they can nod to themselves and say a woman would never do anything so cool.' This suggests I now identify and speak as a straight woman.
I do not express regret in these comments in an emotional or detailed way, but I do treat my past identification as trans as something that resulted from a harmful process of ideological self-scrutiny that I have since abandoned, and I describe myself as more free now. I do not mention hormones, surgery, fertility, medical complications, diagnoses, therapy, or suicidal ideation anywhere in this transcript.