Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in the UK. Looking back, I have always felt neutral about gender — "just nothing" — ever since I was a young child, and I think being autistic made stereotypical gender stuff confusing to me. I started dressing more masculine in 2014 and identified as non-binary, then in 2015 I thought I was a trans guy and got referred to a gender doctor at the end of 2015. I started to rethink it and put it off, then got back in touch for a new appointment in late 2016. It took until October 2017 for me to actually get testosterone, so it wasn't a quick process and I had a lot of time to think — though I did have moments of doubt before starting.
I had body dysmorphia since puberty and had been overweight since around age 15, when I stopped going to school because of mental health issues and ate a lot to cope. I started puberty early, developed breasts early, and got made fun of for it, which gave me extreme chest dysphoria — my chest was much bigger than other people's. I now think that if I had been a normal weight I might never have thought to transition, because growing up as a fat woman left everything feeling sour.
I started T in autumn 2017 and was on it for around 1 year 10 months, taking a hormone blocker shot every 3 months alongside it because I was overweight and they said my periods wouldn't stop with T alone. I had top surgery in February 2019 and took my last T shot at the end of August 2019. I'd always known I wasn't really a "trans man" but identified that way because I'd rather be seen as a man than a woman. Once I started passing fully as male I realised how awful it felt to be called a man — it was far outside my comfort zone. I think I mainly wanted to be seen as a man because men don't have breasts and I didn't want people noticing mine.
After top surgery my dysphoria largely disappeared, and shortly after I decided to stop testosterone and identify as a woman again. Top surgery helped me discover my true self, and I do not regret it — having a flat chest feels good and I feel I can love my body. I never grew much facial hair, so I was passing as female again fairly quickly, though my deep voice still throws people off. I began questioning things about 4 months before stopping T, and stopping early in the questioning felt like the right call.
I identified as a non-binary lesbian, then as a butch/GNC lesbian. I came out to my mum as a lesbian rather than as FtM — she was always accepting of that — and she said I probably would have coped with just a breast reduction, which I agree with, though I try not to dwell on it. My abusive father chose my birth name, so I don't feel connected to it; I kept the androgynous name I picked while identifying as male. I felt embarrassed that I'd realised I was a GNC lesbian, and I was still waiting for the right time to tell my mum, while she and others still thought I was non-binary and some places still used he/him for me, which made me feel like a fake.
Around 5–6 months off T my dysphoria just went away, which I never expected. I stopped caring about pronouns and labels. But I also had real difficulties: I was ashamed of disliking my low voice and did voice training secretly, hoping to sound more feminine again. I worried about whether my period would ever come back after T plus hormone blockers, and I was angry that when I told the doctor I was stopping T, they tried to put me on injections to stop my period returning without me even mentioning it. I also lacked proper therapy from the doctors who prescribed hormones and signed me off for surgery — I was put on hormones partly because they did not have enough therapists to talk to, which makes me wonder if I would have gone on hormones at all if it weren't for lack of resources. I had social dysphoria about having a flat chest and worried other women wouldn't find me attractive without breasts; I considered very small implants or padded bras. I also dealt with rib issues from years of binding — I get winded easily if I wear something tight on my ribs, and I noticed my ribs seem very wide.
Then I transitioned again. I describe myself as essentially FtMtFtMtF, but I get shamed and told how unhealthy it is, and people speak to me as if I'm stupid. In February 2024 I posted that I was thinking of detransitioning again. By March 2024 I said I had stopped T "just under 2 months ago," so I had restarted testosterone at some point and come off it again around January 2024. I'm now detransitioning for a second time.
At 26 I finally got a routine going to lose weight and have lost around 27kg / 60lb so far, with about the same still to go. As I lose weight I feel happier as a woman again. I'm 5'3, with wide hips, a small nose and a round face, and I'm butch — I enjoy baggy sweatshirts and fun sneakers rather than dresses. My mum told me I'd never be seen as a woman again unless I dress feminine, which hurt; I think part of her doesn't want to offend me since she called me a guy for ages. I'm trying not to obsess over "passing" since that dominated my life for so long.
Voice has been a major struggle. I found American voice-feminising tutorials didn't work for me in the UK, and even the highest I could comfortably speak was "only 4% female" — forced, painful, and like putting on an accent. I felt defeated seeing others post voice results. I asked about Vocal Feminisation Surgery as an option, though I'd never seen a story of it from an FtMtF. I also asked about whether wide ribs were from T, binding, or body dysmorphia.
Mentally I still struggle: I have depression, sleep a lot, and have fatigue. I have body dysmorphia and said I don't think I will ever like a single thing about myself. I sometimes feel glad I can call myself asexual because I can't imagine being intimate with anyone or being found attractive again — but really it's a safety blanket and an excuse, because I want to be loved and feel I never will be, and I feel dissociated from myself. I hate myself too much.
Since my first detransition something has bothered me intensely: the claim that growing up female and male is the same. I now argue strongly that male and female socialisation IS different, and that growing up female is what made me detransition. I feel resentful towards trans women specifically — I'm ashamed of being jealous that they get to grow breasts while mine are cut off, that they perform femininity and get complimented while I'm an "ugly GNC butch," and that looking at MTF subreddits makes me feel like a failed woman who doesn't deserve to return to womanhood. I have painful periods since stopping T and can't afford reconstruction. I also resent feeling silenced in trans spaces — I went from being a powerless female in society to a powerless masculine person in the trans community, and I believe male privilege persists even after transition. I'm critical of AGP and of what I see as porn-driven transition narratives among trans women, while having sympathy for men who transitioned from trauma or who were wronged by doctors. I still have trans friends — all of my friends are trans — and I want them to be happy; my closest ones are non-transitioning they/them people I feel safe with. I believe GNC presentation should be the answer rather than medical transition, and I hope that if people know it's okay to present however they want, society will go back to only having "true trans people, aka very few." I'm angry but also glad I've "put my foot down" and am "more awake to it all."
I have no regrets about top surgery overall — I'm neutral-to-glad they're gone — though I sometimes wish I'd had a reduction, and I take some comfort that the female side of my family has a high risk of breast cancer and my risk is now lowered. If I ever get reconstructive surgery it would be as small as possible while still looking natural, because I like my flat chest.