Tutte le storie

Senza casa politica, ma presente per chi fa detransition

Maschio · Desistito/a39
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo cristiano eterosessuale che sostiene chi fa detransition e che non ha mai fatto la transizione; ho l'OCD e una storia di testosterone basso risolta con cambiamenti di stile di vita e non con la TRT. Sono critico sia verso le comunità gender-critical sia verso quelle dell'attivismo trans, che trovo isteriche e ideologicamente esigenti, e mi definisco senza casa politica. Credo che la transizione medica venga spinta perché è redditizia e facile per i fornitori, e sostengo chi fa detransition, credendo che nessuno debba fare detransition da solo. Non ho personalmente alcun rimpianto per la transizione ma provo profonda simpatia per chi ha compiuto passi permanenti prima che «la nebbia si diradasse».

Storia completa

I am a straight, light-skinned, heterosexual man of faith — a Christian — and I've never identified as trans or detransitioned myself; my involvement in these spaces comes from observing and supporting others. I was diagnosed with OCD, which shows up for me as needing to do random or nonsensical things four or five times until I "hit the sweet spot," but I've never heard of gender identity disorder or gender dysphoria being linked to OCD. I've read plenty about autism, molestation victims, and deeply closeted homosexuals living in hostile environments as factors in gender dysphoria, but nothing about OCD. Growing up I had an issue with low testosterone — I was just born that way — and my mother didn't want to start testosterone replacement therapy as step one. She got a second opinion from a doctor with more clout, who told me to get off my butt, work out, and eat healthy and see how I felt. It took some doing, but I hit my stride and the problem resolved itself over time. I joke that we'll see how things are when I'm old and busted. That experience shapes my view that forcibly trying to change the natural flow of one's body will throw things out of balance. I have a good friend who went off hormones — I describe it as "withdrawal," though non-elegantly — and I watched him bounce back after refusing any more of the "Flavor Aid." I told him his body was trying to return to its natural equilibrium after being pumped full of mixed signals, and since those substances affect how our minds work, it's going to be a rough ride. I compared it to my best friend still having a smoker's cough four months after quitting cold turkey, lessening over time. I've encouraged people taking those steps with "baby steps" and advice to take their time healing rather than pushing the pedal to the floor. I'm wary of ideological communities in general. I'd tell someone to avoid places like GC, RadFem, Incel/FemaleDatingStrategy, and MGTOW just as I'd warn them about the TQ+ agenda — those forums are filled with hysterical people, and if you have a level-headed or objective approach and aren't willing to cast a wide blanket on whatever group, you won't fit in. I spent a little time on the GC forum because at the time I thought it would be a discussion board about problems facing LGB people (I'm straight) and male/female erasure in the name of convenience, but it wasn't that, and there was plenty of hatred. I describe myself as "politically homeless" — you can agree with the positive sentiments behind a message without supporting the unspoken requirement to hate others to prove it, and that means everyone hates you. I've also described leaving such a group as like being in a cult, then one day the fog clears and you make your exit, but now you're being chased by the mob you left behind. I'm critical of the medical side. I believe, reinforced semi-recently by my own doctor, that it's simply easier for practitioners to tell sufferers "you're right — your birth was wrong" and put them on hormones forever, and then the money rolls in. I think our mental healthcare is a joke more broadly: when we stopped trying to walk the long-and-hard roads in favor of quick-and-profitable results, we were done. I've also relayed what I heard from my own doctor who swore off the practice — that there's plenty of incentive to tell someone "yeah, your penis is definitely a vagina, wanna be on hormones forever?" On masculinity and sexuality, I've reflected that I only know life as a heterosexual male and it hasn't had much of the safety or security others mention. There were times I wished I were female so society would be more incentivized to lift me up instead of disregarding my concerns. I've wondered aloud why I don't find women as funny as men even when their humor lines up with mine, speculating that males are "supposed" to be comical and that television usually makes males the butt of nudity, rape, and weakness jokes, so we may have internalized humor as a shield against calling out for help. I sign off jokingly as "a straight-lightskinned-heterosexual-man-of-faith-who-by-current-standards-is-literally-Hitler" and note it's no fun to suddenly be thought of as some sort of Hitler-grade evildoer. I have no personal regret about transition because I never transitioned. What I feel instead is strong sympathy for those who took more permanent steps before "the fog lifted." I've said there's no way I could imagine the nightmare-tier level of stress caused by that cruel irony, and I endorsed the statement that no one should have to detransition alone and without help, raising a mug to it. I support people offering support to detransitioners, and I generally encourage people toward okayness with themselves.