Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione (autistica, bisessuale, in passato un uomo trans FTM in terapia con testosterone) e ho fatto detransizione a maggio 2024 dopo una relazione con un uomo AGP e ripetute umiliazioni pubbliche per la mia non conformità di genere. Credo che la mia disforia abbia una componente genetica ereditata da mio padre, che ha vissuto una disforia di genere per tutta la vita senza fare la transizione, e ho la disforia fin dall'infanzia, che la sola terapia non ha risolto. Da quando ho fatto detransizione continuo a essere molestata e misgenderata in pubblico, e lotto con l'odio di me stessa, il vuoto e l'incapacità di immaginare qualsiasi relazione futura come donna. A settembre 2024 ho preso seriamente in considerazione il testosterone a basse dosi come lesbica butch, ma al momento della trascrizione non l'avevo iniziato. I miei atteggiamenti verso la transizione sono critici e gender-critical, anche se provo risentimento anche per l'ostilità anti-trans dei conservatori.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up autistic and gender-nonconforming. From around age 7 to 11 I was homeschooled, and when I entered middle school as an autistic GNC child with no social skills I was bullied heavily. When I was around 8 or 9 I stayed over at my mother's friend's house and her sons bullied me for "acting too much like a boy" and having a deep voice; at one point they locked me in a basement and beat me with a metal rod until my skin turned green. My voice was always strange because of my autism and people made fun of it — I sound more like a young boy than a woman. I developed an eating disorder because I wanted to make my female bullies jealous of me.
I transitioned (FTM) at some point — I've described myself as a "bisexual trans man, never outwardly identifying as non binary," with both feminine and masculine traits, "somewhat clocky." I was on testosterone; I've noted that if I stop testosterone my voice will remain deep but fat redistribution will become more feminine, and someone advised me that with enough time off T my fat would redistribute and my body would look female again. I don't have exact dates for starting or stopping hormones in this transcript. I came out as trans to my father, who told me I'd be "a freak like Michael Jackson," that I'd never be a man, and that he'd never refer to me as his son because he wanted to prepare me for the real world where no one would ever see me as a man. I was repeatedly they/them'd even after introducing myself with an unambiguously male name, including by liberals and other trans people.
I detransitioned around May 2024. The proximate triggers were a relationship and community disillusionment: I'd been seeing a man for about half a year who was more feminine than me — "I'm more like 'the man in the relationship'" — and who I came to see as autogynephilic and "the most narcissistic person I've ever met," flip-flopping between identifying as a trans woman and wanting to get ripped and grow a mustache. An argument with a trans person who told me I was just mad because they passed better than me (they didn't) also pushed me over the edge: "I'm done. I'm detransitioning. I don't want this to be the community I'm stuck in my whole life." It took me two times but I finally left him for good. Part of why I wanted to detransition was that I was "so sick of how I'm being treated for being GNC."
Since detransitioning I've been harassed in bathrooms frequently and called a man at least twice while wearing a full face of makeup, a short skirt and platform boots ("100% intentional"). On a train a ticket collector said "Can you ask him or her or whatever that is to wake up?" and the guys across from us snickered; people still laugh when I tell the story. Recently a woman knocked on my bathroom stall door and asked "are you a man?" because of my deep voice. My family was going on a trip to the South and I was paranoid about being harassed. I've said "No shit every GNC person wants to transition when this is how androgynous people get treated" and that I admire people who detransition and stay butch, but "I'm never putting myself through this again. I want to burn all my masculine clothes."
I've thought a lot about the causes. I believe I inherited gender dysphoria from my father, who told me about a 12-step program where he chose to go outside in full drag as his fear challenge, who lived across the street from a trans bar in New York and regretted never going, who made me listen as a kid to I Am A Bird Now by Antony and the Johnsons (by a deeply self-hating trans woman who came out at 45), who was heavily bullied for being feminine as a kid, and who after we watched I Saw The TV Glow together said "Christ, that movie made me wonder if I'm trans." I also have a cousin who identified as a boy until around 14 in the 1980s. I think transgenderism has a genetic factor, like bipolar — triggered by outside factors — but not "male brain/female brain." I've also said that if I have actual clinically diagnosable gender dysphoria not induced by social media I'll have to cope with it for the rest of my life, even knowing it was caused by internalized misogyny, sexual trauma, etc.
I've been in therapy: "I want to treat my physical dysphoria and therapy alone isn't helping, I've had dysphoria ever since childhood." In September 2024 I posted asking about opinions on butch women taking testosterone, saying I'd discovered a community of butch lesbians who take T to cope with physical dysphoria and wondering if it would be viable for me, since after assimilating into male communities I realized I didn't want to be a straight man in the social sense. I said I'd rather take the chance and regret it than never try, but also that if I went on T I wouldn't take it for more than a few months because of health risks.
Mentally I've struggled since detransitioning. I wrote that I always dreamed of being a man, specifically a father; that I'm bisexual but can't fathom dating a man as a woman, or being a lesbian; that "I feel like I killed off my inner child by detransitioning"; that "Being trans wasn't authentic, but being a woman doesn't feel 'real' either. I just feel like this formless soul wandering through the world, stuck in a human shell" and that I "still feel empty, like there's this whole inside me that nothing can ever fill." In a post titled Humiliation I wrote "I cannot believe I ever thought I passed as a man... I try to put a happy face on and pretend like I'm a normal person but I hate myself so deeply." I've described my dysphoria as sometimes making me become "a narcissist" with "obsessive Patrick Bateman-esque routines" to keep up a masculine appearance, like noting every male customer's height in a grocery store to calculate the average. I've been angry at naturally feminine women "all the time" and felt like a bad person about it. I saw the film I Saw The TV Glow and it was "like reliving all of my worst nightmares all at the same time" — I broke down sobbing. I've also mentioned having had a shroom trip where I was Timothée Chalamet in Dune.
Sexuality and relationships remain my hardest area. I've written that I'm "usually able to keep my dysphoria under control but I can't imagine being a wife, mother, or girlfriend and the idea freaks me out" — that I've made progress on internalized misogyny and grown to accept being she/her'd, but can't shake the fear of being in a relationship: "I feel like I have to choose between being able to cope with my gender dysphoria and being alone forever or being in a relationship and being incredibly dysphoric." I've said I would only date a man if I could be "the man in the relationship." I read Stone Butch Blues and found it "incredibly painful and relatable" and would identify as stone butch if I were a lesbian, but I don't think I am one. I had self-identified queer women use me as a "practice boyfriend" before dumping me for a dude. I've also advised someone else to be vocal about boundaries if a partner is grabbing them without permission.
On the wider debate, I care more about "trans ideology" than the body modification itself: if people got bolt-on tits like tongue splitting I wouldn't mind, but "nothing exists in a vacuum" and society sells people the idea they can change sex through surgery. I've said I hate it when people here say "just be a feminine man/masculine woman" because "that's exactly how most of us got here" — being GNC is so hard people will do anything to escape it. I've also said society doesn't value masculinity in trans men or butch women, and that hatred toward goth males is 100% homophobia. I've been publicly hostile to my childhood attacker, who is now a trans woman, saying I "managed to escape the cult and detransition before it was too late" and wishing her "estrogen induced bone disease." When a trans person commented "good luck on your TERF journey" on my detransition post I replied "thanks, I have JK Rowling on speed dial." At the same time, when I see conservative males hating on trans women it pisses me off, and I've said I don't want to hang out with trans people but feel that way anyway. I've worried publicly that detrans women who don't pass as their birth sex can be in physical danger, and I've been harassed myself. I've told someone to get off 4chan because it isn't a reflection of how normal people think.