Tutte le storie

Una gonna, he/him e nessuna transizione medica

Maschio · Desistito/a1,5K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo non conforme al genere, nato maschio, che ha fatto desistenza: per gran parte della vita ero convinto di essere trans, ma non ho mai fatto una transizione medica. La mia disforia e la mia invidia avevano radici nella vergogna per i miei interessi femminili, in rigidi stereotipi di genere, nella misandria interiorizzata fin dall'infanzia, nel pensiero bianco o nero tipico dell'OCD e nel senso di colpa cattolico. Cercare di proposito un terapeuta non focalizzato sul genere, concentrarmi sull'OCD, leggere molto e la mia fede mi hanno aiutato a desistere; ora mi presento come voglio, in gonne e abiti, identificandomi come he/him. A volte resto moderatamente depresso e lotto ancora con l'ansia per come mi vedono gli altri e con occasionali pensieri fugaci che la vita sarebbe più facile da donna, ma sono più sereno che mai. Sono critico verso l'identità non binaria e la cultura dell'affermazione, pur non opponendomi in linea di principio alla transizione per gli altri.

Storia completa

I was born male and have never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — but for most of my life I was convinced I was trans, and I now describe myself as a gender non-conforming man who desisted from that path. My gender nonconformity goes back to early childhood. I wore my first dress at age 7 or 8 and my dad almost caught me. From a young age I was drawn to things society coded as feminine — sewing, crafts, colorful and funky clothes, jewelry — and I was frustrated and embarrassed that I couldn't dress how I pleased. I never wore skirts or dresses in public until college, and only for a short while, for fear of being an outcast. I grew up in the 1990s, right before what I call the "transition craze," and I'm convinced that timing is part of why I wasn't sucked in medically. What I now recognize as dysphoria was, in my own telling, largely a reaction to shame. I envied what women were allowed to wear and do; I felt longing, sadness, and envy, thoughts like "this is unfair" and "I'm a bad person." I concluded I must be trans because of my nonconformity — I "wanted to be a girl" all my life, even before I had any word for transgenderism. But I resisted transition for a host of reasons: it was against my Catholic faith, and logically the equation "if I like X, it must mean I'm a girl" never made sense to me. I also realized early that if I became a woman I'd be expected to date men, which didn't appeal, and later that dating a woman as a trans woman would be disingenuous. A turning point came about a year before COVID hit. I was trying to figure things out and gain courage to be nonconforming, and I deliberately sought out a psychologist who did not list gender among their specialties — I didn't want to be led down the transition path. I focused on my OCD instead. My dysphoria was and remains awful, but my perception of it changed. When news and doctors started pushing the line that kids who can't transition will kill themselves, I started wondering that too and began hating myself much more than before — I wasn't quite ready to end it, but it made me confront how much self-hate I carried. I started reading forums, scientific literature, opinion pieces from both political sides, and gender-critical writing, and those gave me tools to cope. The dysphoria hasn't left, but it has less power over my mind. I've been in talk therapy for a few years, working through nonconformity and self-acceptance, though I've realized much of what my therapist suggests isn't actually helpful for OCD. I've studiously avoided any provider listing "gender" specialties. I've also avoided gender-critical and trans subreddits on my other accounts because I know my opinions would be shut down. Several things kept me from transitioning. I found MTF subreddits creepy — the sexualization, the infantilizing of women, the crossover with fetish subs — and that was one component of what kept me from going further. I also feared that if I transitioned I'd be an outsider to both men and women, would forever worry about being clocked, and would feel like a fraud performing "womanness" rather than being a woman. I clock trans people on outfit subreddits sometimes, and it reinforces my feeling that if I'd gone down the HRT path I'd be in the same boat. I've also been manipulated, in my own view: the mere suggestion that someone like me might want to transition made me think maybe I did. I see affirmation as reassurance, which for someone with OCD feeds the obsession — I've watched an IOCDF video on "transgender OCD" noting that for someone with OCD, perhaps the worst thing is to be affirmed. I have OCD with black-and-white thinking, and I've read about TOCD; I'd advise anyone describing classic TOCD to work through the OCD first rather than see a gender specialist. On identity: I don't identify as LGBTQ, don't want to, and frankly hate labels. Non-binary is tempting as a way to explain myself to strangers, but I've never called myself NB and never will. I see NB as a rationalization for GNC and a fad. I use GNC only as a convenient description, not an identity. I present how I want — skirts, dresses, funky shoes, jewelry, knit — styled in a masculine context, and I go by he/him and my birth name. I've never changed my name, mannerisms, or added pronouns to my email or Zoom signature. I've had laser hair removal on my legs and face — not to transition, but because I dislike shaving and hairy legs — and I went by my birth name and never had to show ID. Religion matters to me: I'm Catholic, and faith played a major role in desistance. I've wrestled with whether being GNC is sinful in a Catholic context and concluded the sin would be in deception, which I'm not engaged in. I've read the Vatican's 2019 document "Male and Female He Created Them" and the Summa Theologiae on the subject. My black-and-white thinking made crafts and skirts feel somewhat sinful, and only in the past few years have I let those fears go. Family and social life: my mom was worried I'd be short as a child after a pediatrician wrongly said I'd never grow tall and offered a height-increasing shot I was horrified by — I grew to nearly 6' tall. She was also once worried because I liked a glass decoration; those small comments chipped away at my self-confidence. Well-intentioned family members made comments about my interests that fed my dysphoria. I'm close mainly to my parents, have one close female friend, two at a distance, and work friendships that faded with COVID. I'm right-wing politically, though I acknowledge a contradiction there, and I've told my sister "I'm basically a TERF." One family member still can't accept the difference between GNC and trans despite my repeated denials. Where I am now: I'm in a better place than a few years ago, though still depressed at times. I've largely gotten over the self-hate and no longer feel shame about how I dress. I've received mostly compliments on my clothes and have never been negatively confronted. I still worry about what others think of me — that's my main anxiety — and I still yo-yo occasionally into thinking I'd be better off as a woman, but I recognize that as superficial. I'm not happy exactly, but I'm more content and settled than I've ever been. I have no interest in transitioning and consider accepting my GNC nature the only lifeline that doesn't involve transition. I'm cautious but not opposed to others transitioning; I mainly worry it's overused and misapplied, reinforcing stereotypes, and I advocate for separating clothing and interests from gender.