Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition, nata femmina, ex uomo trans, che ha vissuto per anni come maschio, ha iniziato il testosterone a 19 anni, ha fatto una doppia mastectomia e un'isterectomia totale e ha iniziato la detransition nell'estate del 2019, passando agli estrogeni dopo aver smesso la T. Ora mi identifico come donna mascolina e non conforme al genere e penso di essere probabilmente lesbica, anche se non ne sono del tutto certa. Nel complesso non rimpiango di aver fatto la transizione, ma rimpiango di aver preso la T prima di aver mai fatto sesso e gli anni persi senza vivere come me stessa. La mia disforia, depressione, ansia e anoressia sono tutte migliorate da quando ho fatto detransition, anche se lotto ancora con la vergogna di essere una donna mascolina e con il desiderio occasionale di tornare alla T. Mi batto per una migliore rappresentazione delle donne mascoline e delle lesbiche, perché le ragazze sappiano che non hanno bisogno di cambiare il proprio corpo.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first came out as a lesbian before I ever identified as trans, and then I lived as a trans man for years. I started testosterone at 19 and was on it for four years. I had a double mastectomy (top surgery) and a full hysterectomy while identifying as male. When I started hormones I was ecstatic and 100% sure it was what I wanted, and it had taken months to get them.
Looking back, I think I transitioned for unhealthy reasons: traumas, misogyny, fear of men, fear of being a woman who loves women, body image issues including eating disorders, and being surrounded by feminine women and homophobia. I had been diagnosed with gender identity disorder at the same time I was diagnosed with depression and anxiety, and I don't feel like I ever really made an attempt to treat those mental illnesses. I always hated the way I looked and felt ugly and fat, and being seen as a man seemed like an escape. I also grew up with strict gender roles — as a child and teen I was never allowed to cut my hair — and I feel like a lot of my issues came from my mother's attitude toward gender non-conforming people. When I was young and surrounded by what I called 'trans trenders' on Tumblr, it all seemed like I really MUST be trans, and I never stopped to consider sexism, homophobia, or body image issues. I also went on T before ever having sex, which I regret.
I started detransitioning in the summer of 2019. In April 2019 I called my endocrinologist to schedule an appointment to talk about stopping hormones, though she was booked out until the end of June. Because I had a full hysterectomy, I couldn't just stop T — my body would have no hormones — so I moved to female hormones. By February 2020 I had been off T for about nine months and on estrogen for about the same time. I don't really like the word 'detransition' because I feel like I'm simply moving on to a new part of my life rather than moving backwards. I took T, I removed my breasts, it made me happy and I don't regret it, but I'm ready to move on now.
What moved me toward detransition was realizing I was tired of fighting against my body and mind, and that it was hell being sad every day because I'd never have a cis man's body. I was finally able to accept that my body is female — a masculine female — and accepting that was easier than continuing to fight for a body I will never have. I also realized I probably transitioned because of other unhealthy reasons, listed above. I got into radical feminism and found it really helpful, and I came to my senses about gender ideology. Realizing I had been dealing with compulsory heterosexuality was very eye-opening. I also recognized that the only time I ever felt comfortable being with men was when they were viewing me as a man, not a woman, and it never occurred to I might be lesbian and was forcing myself to change my body in order to be with men — I just assumed I had to be a 'gay' trans man. I was not seeing a therapist about the detransition itself at the time; I said I was too stubborn and headstrong to listen to others' advice once set in my ways. I did tell my therapists about detransitioning.
Medically, I've had a full hysterectomy and a double mastectomy, and I was on testosterone for four years before stopping. Because of the hysterectomy I am dependent on hormone replacement — I've been off T and on estrogen. Since stopping T I haven't experienced many aesthetic changes except a slight decrease in body and facial hair growth (I never got a full beard on T, just a patchy neckbeard and dirtstache, which I don't really shave). I have decreased energy and rarely get to the gym anymore, and I've gained weight (which was a recovery goal). I'm scared of gaining lots of weight and looking more feminine, especially in my hips. I've chosen not to have any surgery to change my flat chest. I also mentioned feeling like my endocrinologist isn't doing her job and wondering if my T levels are low even for a female, hoping maybe to get on a small dose of T in that case. I've dealt with painful acne too.
Mentally, I was diagnosed with gender identity disorder at the same time as depression and anxiety, and I've struggled with disordered eating — I've been working on recovery from anorexia over the past year. Since stopping T and having my dysphoria lessen, my eating disorder has been much easier to deal with. I also have anxiety; I thought transition would give me confidence — first hormones, then being flat chested, then passing 100% as male — but I was never satisfied because transitioning was just another coping mechanism used to avoid dealing with my actual problems.
In terms of adversity, I've dealt with trauma, misogyny, strict gender roles in my family, homophobia, and body image issues including anorexia. I had a partner who was trans and asked me for permission to see other people, which felt like cheating and took a big toll on my self-esteem; at the time I was reliant on them because I had no job, and it ended badly. A very close friend told me he could never be friends with detrans people because we lie and 'take resources from real trans people,' and he was awful to me when I told him I was detransitioning, spread lies about me, and gave my phone number to weirdos.
Socially, I've only come out in real life to my mom and my best friend (a trans man), and both have been very supportive; I also told my therapists. Both still call me he/him pronouns but I haven't asked them to stop because I don't really care about pronouns or gender since I'm at peace with my sex. My mom doesn't care that I'm a lesbian — I was out as lesbian before I was a trans man, and transitioning was much harder on her. However, she has recently made several comments about how I should try looking more feminine, growing my hair out, etc., and I feel sometimes like she's embarrassed of me and doesn't think I can love myself as a masculine woman. My older brother claimed my lesbian identity was because my mom was a man hater when I was growing up. I'm pretty close with my mom but I love her while feeling a lot of my issues have come from strict gender roles and her attitude toward GNC people.
Regarding sexuality, I was out as lesbian before identifying as trans, then assumed I was a 'gay' trans man, and after detransitioning I've been re-identifying as female and trying to reconnect with my female lesbian identity — or possibly bi, I'm not really sure yet. I now realize I've been dealing with compulsory heterosexuality. I went on T before ever having sex and regret that. Being a 'submissive female with a straight man' was what I hated and why I only wanted to be viewed as male when I had sex with males.
I don't necessarily regret transitioning because I had to do what I did to know myself, and I enjoy looking masculine anyway — it's part of my journey. However, I do regret going on T before ever having sex, and I feel I missed out on living as myself as a gay female during my trans years. I also feel shame about being a masculine woman — it feels weird calling myself lesbian sometimes, I feel like people think I'm lying or even think I'm a trans woman, and it feels weird telling doctors I'm female. I've struggled with wanting to go back on T because it felt like it would solve a lot of these problems. I have some lingering discomfort seeing myself naked from the waist down and distress/sadness seeing my genitalia, though it's not that I wish I had a penis. Overall my dysphoria is much less than it used to be, and embracing that I'm a masculine, gender non-conforming woman has been a big relief after years of dysphoria and self-hate.
I don't like the word 'detransition' — I feel I'm moving forward, not backwards. I now think other options should have been presented to me: if I had seen other masculine women or happy lesbians and realized it was ok to be that way, I would have reconsidered transitioning. I want young girls and questioning girls who might be gay or masculine to have this information and to have people to look up to so they realize they don't have to change their body to be their own version of a woman. I advocate for better representation of gender non-conforming women, butch women, lesbians, and awkward women who thrive and love themselves. I disagree with trans ideology but I don't use slurs like 'tranny' since it's not mine to reclaim now that I'm not trans-identified. I also believe 'butch' is a term only for lesbians. I've been active in the detransition community online, offering support and sharing my experience with others considering stopping hormones.
Shopping for women's clothes after detransition gave me anxiety since I pass as male; I was afraid of being harassed in the women's section at Walmart. I like wearing masculine clothing and mostly shop in the men's section, though I wanted women's boxer-style underwear. Before top surgery I was a 32B. I only recently got into makeup while identifying as male because it felt like a fun safe thing, but now re-identifying as female I feel I can't wear makeup without looking like a man in drag. I treat my post-mastectomy chest like a 'male' chest — I allow myself to be shirtless and don't bother wearing bras.