Tutte le storie

Un semestre di estrogeni, poi di nuovo uomo

Maschio · Detransizionato/a141
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un maschio che ha fatto desistenza e che ha preso brevemente ormoni femminilizzanti all'università prima di capire che non sarei mai passato per donna e smettere, in parte perché non potevo permetterli. Ho fatto la transizione per totale alienazione dalle aspettative di genere maschili e per misandria interiorizzata — sono un uomo bisessuale sensibile, sottomesso, tenero, che la società tratta come una minaccia. Il rifiuto da parte di un gruppo trans e di spazi femministi e queer mi ha convinto che non sarei mai sfuggito all'essere percepito come maschio. Ora, in età più avanzata, ho fatto pace con il mio corpo e il mio sesso, anche se mi sento ancora un disadattato, e ho trovato accettazione soprattutto tra uomini gay e bi demisessuali. Sono stato aggredito da una persona FTM e sostengo che gli uomini che fanno detransition abbiano i propri spazi separati.

Storia completa

I'm a detransitioned (desisted) male who lived as a woman for a time and briefly took feminizing hormones before stopping. I hate being male, honestly — that's how I got myself into this mess before desisting. Nothing about what I feel or how I experience love, sexuality, or life tracks with what's expected of males, especially the aggressiveness. I'm sensitive and emotional, I don't do casual sex, I don't like violence or aggression, I tend to be submissive in bed, I like to feel desired rather than pursue, and I love tenderness and gentle affection. I'm not even that into penetrative sex — I've only ever had penetrative sex with women because they insisted on it, and I don't know a single other man with that experience. When I was young I could pull off androgyny, but after my mid-twenties, no way; the only look I can pull off anymore is a masculine one, a neat beard and such. I'm hairy, with a low voice and facial hair. It took me decades to come to terms with my body changing so radically, and desperately flirting with feminizing hormones was my early reaction. I desisted because I could see the hormones weren't going to be enough — I'd never pass as a woman, I'm just not androgynous enough, and I knew I'd still be seen as male, and then people would find me even more off-putting than they already did. I also couldn't afford hormones, so that alone would have forced me to desist anyway. I've masculinized and done my best to alleviate myself regardless. The core driver was total alienation from masculine gender expectations and despair at being trapped in them. Every time people talk about what men are, what men want, what men do, what men should be, 99% of it is the opposite of who I actually am. It overwhelmed me to feel that most people find who I am repulsive. I hate being seen as a threat, hate being talked about as a weapon or having my body parts compared to knives and pistols, hate feeling unattractive to most people because they don't like sensitive men, hate having to force myself to act more stoic than comes naturally just to get along with strangers, and hate that the only reward for being true to myself is isolation. Internalized misandry, too. At first I got deeply involved with feminism thinking that was the ticket, but they ridiculed me too, said it was unattractive, said feminism wasn't about men crying or being sensitive and they expected men to 'man up' too. Radical feminism is what made me hate my own body so much to begin with. Misandry is also what led me to start hormones, though I desisted because I saw it wouldn't ever lead to people hating me less. I've always been okay with being in a male body — it's the meaning of that body to society, and hyperawareness of how it is perceived and how that affects how I'm seen and treated, that made me hate having one. That's psychologically different from someone who believes they were born female and always meant to be female. When I was in university and starting to take anti-androgens, I joined a trans group. It was all trans men plus a cis woman who would gush about how she loved trans men and thought penises were disgusting, then glance at me and say 'hee hee, no offence,' and the rest would laugh and say he doesn't mind. I did mind; it hurt. I was lonely and isolated, hoping to find friends who might relate to feeling depressed and trapped by gender. As the group got warmer and would hug or cuddle during meetings, I thought I belonged too, so one day I snuggled next to someone I thought I'd made friends with. The reaction was like the face you make holding something fished out of a toilet bowl with a pincer grip — I will never forget it. It hit me like a train: 'These are not your people. You do not belong here. And you will never not be male!' Where I live now, queer groups create 'women and non-binary' groups that are really just female-born-only spaces. My girlfriend, who was big into trans rights, wanted to fight them to let me in, but I told her I don't want to fight to be allowed into a group of people who don't want me there — I'd rather be in the group with the men, where I feel accepted, weird but accepted. I'm bisexual, so I don't have to hope against hope I'll find the handful of women who might be attracted to a guy like me. Even so, I have ended up dating women. Dating men hasn't been much easier; I've realized I'm just very picky about partners. I had a girlfriend who felt bad about her breasts as an unwanted source of being sexualized and was thinking of getting them cut off just for that; I always treated her chest indifferently, never focused on it or commented on it, and she started feeling better and stopped wanting a mastectomy. I was assaulted by a person who was FTM. The only guy to ever try to push himself on me on a date was a trans man. I've noticed most MTF people I've met have been most similar to the most aggressive and masculine cis men in temperament, ways of speaking, and personality; the most feminine AMAB people I've met aren't trans, they're shy cis guys who aren't trying to be anything. Once a group of guys asked each other what the first attractive thing they noticed was, and the answers were mostly tits and ass; when it was my turn I said 'eyes,' they laughed at me, literally, so I stopped hanging out with them. I don't know what it's like to be turned on by tits and ass and never will. Getting older has helped. I'm much more reconciled with being male, even if I'm not anybody's idea of a proper male. The older I've gotten, the more identified I've felt with being a man, because I've accumulated a lifetime of knowing what life is like when you're treated as a man. I've never related to actively and enthusiastically identifying as a man, but I relate very strongly to being passively identified as one. I still feel like an alien stuffed into the wrong suit, like being misclassified, like I live in a parallel reality. But I've accepted my own existence the way I am. I'm at peace with my body — it's not my body's fault I came into this world. I exist, and embrace myself as I am. Somewhere inside me is still a scared, abused little boy, and I'm doing my best to protect him. I'm never going to surrender my own sense of innocence to society. I may be a trampled flower, but I'm still a flower. Making friends with demisexual gay guys has helped me a lot — they're the closest thing to 'me' I've ever found on Earth. I mostly hang out with gay/bi men now; they're the only ones who really accept me the way I am in the body I have. I also lean into video games, the one stereotypical thing I share with other men, which makes me happy and gives me some genuine connection with my birth sex. I'm introverted, and I struggle socially; I feel the internet has made social fulfilment much harder for introverts. I go by a gender-neutral nickname of my birth name, though some people pointedly ignore it. I don't have traumatic associations with my birth name, but I have bad associations with my mother's name and her boyfriend's name. I think what's called 'gender dysphoria' hides many different patterns — OCD, sexual titillation at the idea of oneself as the other sex, body rejection, belief of being in the wrong body, or horror at how one is perceived — that should be studied independently. I think male detransitioners need their own spaces; I feel we've overstayed our welcome in mixed detrans spaces and would rather be in a male-specific one.