Disse historiene er oppsummert ved hjelp av AI.
På Reddit deler mennesker ofte sine erfaringer på tvers av flere kommentarer eller innlegg. For å gjøre denne informasjonen mer tilgjengelig, samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte delene i en enkelt, lettlest oppsummering og tidslinje. Alle systemspørringer er notert på spørringssiden.
Noen ganger kan AI hallusinere eller uttale seg om ting som ikke er sanne. Men generelt er de oppsummerte historiene nøyaktige gjenspeilinger av brukernes opprinnelige kommentarer.
Sammendrag
Jeg er en detransisjonert (eller desisterende) kvinne som identifiserte meg som FTM, sosialt transisjonerte som 16-åring, og tok testosteron i 9,5 måneder fra jeg var nesten 17 etter et år med pubertetsblokkere. Jeg begynte å tro at transisjon var en løgn og en vrangforestilling som ikke hjalp dysforien min, og innen slutten av 2019 søkte jeg aktivt ikke-bekreftende terapi og vurderte detransisjon, selv om jeg fortsatt likte å leve som mann og fryktet foreldrenes «hva sa jeg.» På mitt laveste punkt følte jeg at jeg ville avslutte alt fordi jeg var så fastlåst. Jeg har omfattende psykiske helsediagnoser (kjønnsdysfori, ADHD, OCD, angst, depresjon, autisme) og har vært i terapi siden jeg var 6. Jeg argumenterer nå offentlig for at transisjon ikke kurerer dysfori, at beslutninger bør vente til voksen alder og psykisk stabilitet, og jeg er kritisk til helsevesenet og «trans-sekten.»
Hele historien
I was born female and I've been identifying as trans since childhood. I had dysphoria since I was around 2, got diagnosed with gender identity disorder at age 6, and my mom never did anything about it. She never discouraged masculine behaviors, but she only influenced feminine ones — I wasn't allowed short hair and I was only allowed to wear boys' clothes if I put a clip in or something, basically so I could be seen as a girl. I came out at 13 and my parents never accepted it. I finally socially transitioned when I was 16, and I started testosterone 2 months before I turned 17. I'd been on puberty blockers for about a year before that. I pushed my mom into starting T and kept pushing for 5 years; she was always critical of it, but I was allowed to make my own medical decisions according to my doctors and never needed her signature for anything. Nothing about my transition was influenced by my parents — they still aren't the most supportive.
I've been in therapy since I was 6 and have struggled my entire life with mental illness. I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria and ADHD at 6, OCD and anxiety at 8, and depression and autism at 9. Therapists always told me "you'll feel better by transitioning," so I guess I just believed what they said. I realized a few months ago that I shouldn't just trust whatever therapists say — I find more often than not they try to put words in my mouth, which frustrates me. Where I live in Canada there's next to no funding for mental health, so getting new therapists means years on a wait list, and as soon as I turn 18 I can't see my therapist anymore anyway.
By December 2019 I had been on testosterone for 9.5 months and literally nothing had happened except my voice was deeper. I still looked visibly feminine despite having no hips or tits — I guess it's mostly my face. That made me realize that at this far along I'll never look like a man. I always knew in the back of my mind I'll never actually be a man since it's biologically impossible to change sex. I'd been living as male for 2 years and was mostly stealth; being a teenager, people just assumed I was a late bloomer. I never finished female puberty.
For the last little while I'd been considering detransitioning. For the past maybe 5ish months it was always very present that I am not male and will never be male no matter what I do. I mostly felt bad lying to people about my sex. For the past month or less I'd been getting sort of dysphoria being referred to as male — a mix of shame and guilt for lying to people, and a reminder that I will never actually be male. I do kinda like living as male and I like the few changes I've had from T, but T is hardly doing anything for me and it's not helping my dysphoria at all — it's making it worse. I wish there was alternate treatment. I want an escape from what I called the "trans cult"; I hate being grouped in with them and think most of it is ridiculous and bullshit. I know it's all a lie and a delusion, which is why I want to detransition. I have OCD too, so that thought is permanently in my head and I can't get rid of it.
My main source of dysphoria is that I don't have a penis and never will have an actual functioning penis. My dysphoria is mostly physical; I really couldn't care less at that point what other people see me as socially. Living as a woman would be hard because I can't picture myself in a female role in society — I can't see myself as someone's wife, mother, or aunt. It's funny that I can acknowledge I'm biologically female but can't picture myself in a female role. On the other hand, going back might mean I wouldn't be made fun of for being 5'4", I wouldn't take hormones, maybe I'd actually have a shot at getting a girlfriend, and I wouldn't have to worry about lying about my sex. I'm female and attracted to women.
I was so stuck and didn't know what to do. I didn't want to tell my mom because I knew she'd be all "I told you so" and I'd never be able to live it down — any mistake or anything wrong I do, my parents hold against me. At one point I felt I wanted to just end it all because I was so stuck in this horrible life. I planned to talk it over with a buddy who'd give me his honest opinions. I also went looking for non-affirming therapists in southern Ontario and couldn't find anything; I figured that was against the law and medical guidelines in Canada.
Since then I've been vocal in detransition communities. I've argued that we should wait until people become adults (25+) and are mentally stable before making major life-altering decisions, because mental illness can make you do things you'll regret later. I've said that transitioning often doesn't cure dysphoria and that changing the outside won't change the inside — self love has to come from within. I looked into FTM surgery results at the Montreal clinic (Brassard) about a year before and saw almost none, maybe 3 or 4, and everything I saw was awful; I was disgusted that the clinic apparently has a form you must sign agreeing not to post or talk about results, while the government funds it with taxpayer dollars. I also expected to pass completely as male within a few months and now recognize that's unrealistic and rare. I've questioned whether the trans suicide rate is actually because of being trans or due to underlying mental illness, noting a study claiming the average trans person has 3 mental health diagnoses. I still have dysphoria, but I no longer believe transition solves it.