Alle historier

Han transitionerte, detransitionerte og råder nå andre til å avslå

Mann · Detransisjonert1,5k
Disse historiene er oppsummert ved hjelp av AI.

På Reddit deler mennesker ofte sine erfaringer på tvers av flere kommentarer eller innlegg. For å gjøre denne informasjonen mer tilgjengelig, samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte delene i en enkelt, lettlest oppsummering og tidslinje. Alle systemspørringer er notert på spørringssiden.

Noen ganger kan AI hallusinere eller uttale seg om ting som ikke er sanne. Men generelt er de oppsummerte historiene nøyaktige gjenspeilinger av brukernes opprinnelige kommentarer.

Sammendrag

Jeg er en detransisjonert mann som transisjonerte på et udefinert tidspunkt i livet mitt og som nå råder andre til ikke å gjøre det, med henvisning til det jeg kaller min livserfaring. Jeg mener at å være trans er en psykisk lidelse best behandlet med terapi fremfor kirurgi, og at kjønnsnonkonformitet feilaktig medikaliseres. Jeg motsetter meg sterkt pubertetsblokkere, hormoner og kirurgi både av helsemessige og filosofiske grunner, og siterer ofte langtidsstudier for å hevde at transisjon forverrer resultatene over tid. Jeg beskriver trans-aktivisme som en kult eller religion og kritiserer hvordan venstresiden behandler detransisjonerte. Jeg holder detaljene i min egen medisinske historie private.

Hele historien

I have never posted my own story here, but over the past year and a half I have commented extensively in r/detrans, and what I say repeatedly reveals a lot about where I stand and what I have been through. I was born male, and I transitioned at some point in my life — I don't put dates on it in these comments — but by the time I was writing here I had detransitioned and was firmly on the other side of that experience. I describe myself as having "life experience that I am trying to share with you," and I tell people considering transition, "I will always advise people to reconsider transitioning." When someone asked me directly whether I had gone through with a particular surgical step, I answered flatly: "I don't entertain that question for one second." I keep the specifics of my own medical history private. What I do say openly is that I believe transition does not solve the underlying problem. I tell people, "Going through with transition is something that is irreverable, and never actually solves the underlying issues," and I describe surgery as taking skin from one place and trying to form it into something that resembles the other set of genitals, with most people ending up with complications and regular hospital visits for the rest of their lives. I frame being trans as a mental disorder — "It's a mental disorder, in the same way that scitzophrenic people aren't actually hearing voices, just experiencing it" — and I argue the solution is proper therapy, "not therapy where they try to push you into surgery." I also believe strongly that gender nonconformity is being misread as dysphoria. I tell people repeatedly that "it's perfectly fine to be a more masculine woman" and "it's okay to be a feminine male," and I argue that people are confusing gender with personality: "Being a boy who likes things that's generally attributed to girl's interests does not make you gender non-conforming. It just makes you a complex person with different interests than those around you." I accuse the trans movement of enforcing the very stereotypes it claims to oppose. On the medical side, I am deeply skeptical of puberty blockers and hormones. I call "puberty blocker" a misnomer, saying the actual drug is Lupron, which I note is also used as chemical castration for convicted pedophiles, and I argue the development time lost while taking them "will fuck you up for life." I have cited long-term studies — including a PLOS ONE paper and an NCBI article — to argue that HRT is detrimental long term and that post-transition people often become more depressed than they were pre-transition. I have also cited a study claiming increased incidence of breast cancer, stroke, and pulmonary embolism in HRT users. I believe the commonly cited 1% detransition regret rate is a guess, and that the real number is much higher because of social pressure to keep up the façade after transitioning. I hold strong views about children and consent: "Children don't consent to things," and I argue that halting puberty or removing healthy organs is not the same as life-saving medical care. For adults, though, I say they "should be able to do what they wish." I have also argued that pushing kids toward transition could itself meet the UN definition of genocide, and I have pushed back hard on the use of "genocide" to describe legislative restrictions on youth transition. I am not religious, but I have defended religious conservatives who speak up for detransitioners, saying they "genuinely care about the health of others in regards to transitioning" even though I disagree with their other positions. I describe trans activism as a "religion" and a "cult," and I say "transphobia" functions as their version of blasphemy. I mention that my workplace encourages participation in what I call "cult stuff" and that I refuse to put pronouns in my email signature. I also say the left is awful to detransitioners, which is why people drift away from it. I have no patience for the idea that being against transition makes someone hateful: "Hate would be wishing harm to others, not trying to keep others from coming to harm." I have told people point-blank not to go through with surgery, and I have expressed hope that legal action will eventually be taken against people who pushed others into transition on false promises. I have also mentioned doing research — at one point noting a study "popped up multiple times during my reach" — and I have thanked others for pointing me toward cases I hadn't seen. I don't describe my own mental health, family situation, relationships, or sexuality in these comments. What comes through is a person who has been through transition and come out the other side convinced it was the wrong path, and who now spends a great deal of energy warning others away from it.