Alle historier

Ikkebinær for å unnslippe søsterens misandri — og så tilbake til mann

Mann · Desistert4,4k
Disse historiene er oppsummert ved hjelp av AI.

På Reddit deler mennesker ofte sine erfaringer på tvers av flere kommentarer eller innlegg. For å gjøre denne informasjonen mer tilgjengelig, samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte delene i en enkelt, lettlest oppsummering og tidslinje. Alle systemspørringer er notert på spørringssiden.

Noen ganger kan AI hallusinere eller uttale seg om ting som ikke er sanne. Men generelt er de oppsummerte historiene nøyaktige gjenspeilinger av brukernes opprinnelige kommentarer.

Sammendrag

Jeg er en detransisjonert mann som en periode identifiserte meg som ikke-binær, mest som en usunn mestringsmekanisme for å flykte fra misandrien jeg opplevde da jeg vokste opp, særlig fra min eldre søster. Jeg tok aldri hormoner eller hadde kirurgi, og opplevde aldri kjønnseufori – verken feminin eller maskulin presentasjon ga meg egentlig noen følelse. Etter å ha innsett at identiteten handlet om å flykte fra dårlig behandling for å være mann, og funnet mennesker som ikke så det verste i meg, forsvant mye av smerten, og jeg har siden vendt tilbake til en maskulin identitet. Jeg har ADHD, en anfallslidelse og høyt blodtrykk, og er en agnostisk kristen konvertitt som finner ubetinget kjærlighet i troen min og kirkefellesskapet. Jeg forblir kritisk til trans-bevegelsens nettkultur, «sølvkule»-rammeverket for transisjon og det jeg ser som kultlignende trekk, samtidig som jeg sier at jeg ikke tror det bokstavelig talt er en kult.

Hele historien

I was born male and grew up in a family I describe as pretty conservative. My older sister was very progressive and, in my account, abusive toward various members of the family; she would lose it and yell at my mother, and because I slept right next to my parents' room for most of my life I could physically hear my mother crying herself to sleep. My sister had her own trauma — she was almost taken away from us by her birth mother when she was around 10, and she is now almost 30 and still suffering from the effects of that. My family eventually adopted her from birth. Growing up, I was exposed to a lot of misandry, mostly from my sister but also from people at school and online. People treated me like I was always trying to get into women's pants, like I was some kind of rabid, rutting animal just because I had a penis. If I tried being friendly to a woman, it was assumed I was trying to get into her pants. If I explained or taught something in detail, I was "mansplaining." If I held a door open for a woman, I was saying she was weak. I remember being in my teenage years and having people treat me like I was always trying to get into women's pants. I also recall an incident where I was DMing a D&D game with female players and played a stubborn, grizzled dwarf NPC, and the first reaction from one of the female players was "ugh, I hate men," said with real disgust. All of this made me hate being a man because, in my words, all it ever brought me was harassment, and I never experienced any of the supposed benefits of being a man. I never fully transitioned and never took hormones or had any surgeries. For a while I identified as non-binary. I have described this as an unhealthy coping mechanism and "a means to escape the misandry I experienced growing up." I never experienced gender euphoria — the first time I did anything seen as feminine I just felt nothing, and the same when I did masculine stuff, which made me feel like something was wrong until I learned to stop caring. Eventually I realized that a lot of my problems came from the misandry I'd been exposed to, and once I found people who didn't immediately assume I was looking to get into women's pants just because I have a penis, the pain mostly went away on its own. I have since gone back to identifying as male. I have said I'm not gay and that I would like to have kids in the future. I have described the whole thing as having "a lot in common with cults" — love-bombing, no allowed criticism, us-vs-them language, no leaving, and leavers being demonized — while clarifying I don't think the trans movement literally is a cult. I've also said I think egg culture is hypocritical and creepy; I once posted a picture of myself wearing a kilt in a Discord server (I'm about 20-ish% Scottish and wanted to reconnect with my heritage) and the third message someone sent called me an egg, which I found really creepy. I've said I lost a couple of friends just for saying I had some concerns about the trans movement as a whole, without even stating what the concerns were; neither of those friends was trans. I'm an agnostic Christian who later converted, saying I believe in the Christian God but don't take a totally literal view of creation. I've said religious people showed me more unconditional love than any progressive person I knew, and that going to a local church was where I felt more loved and accepted as a person regardless of my views. I describe myself as slightly conservative, attributing it partly to my sister's progressivism and her abuse, and say I mainly just don't like extremism. I'm a "level-headed moderate." I have ADHD, which I say interferes with my ability to focus, and I also have a seizure disorder — my brain having the potential to randomly "spaz out" while driving and kill myself and anyone nearby. I also have high blood pressure, for which I take medication, and I take fish oil supplements which have reduced my morning headaches. I hate the terms "neurodivergent" and "differently-abled" because of this. I've said I don't have much personal experience with therapy. I've described a coworker who disliked me for years after I made a passing comment that she looked good in a dress she was wearing; I apologized multiple times and even tried ignoring her, but she'd find ways to hate things about me, like harassing me for liking a certain game. I also have a coworker who is a single mom who smokes and talks about her ex-husband. My uncle was prescribed Xanax for anxiety and was on it for about ten years, which turned him into a zombie — his wife left him, he lost his job at a school, and he started stealing from my Alzheimer's grandmother's account; the doctor who prescribed it lost her medical license. I have uncles who did drugs when young and are only now experiencing psychological effects like depression, anxiety, and minor schizophrenia. I got off Twitter a while ago and culled the Discord servers I was in, and my mental health improved immensely; for a while after deleting my Twitter account there felt like a hole in me, but it got much better. I've recommended others do the same. I enjoy playing D&D, various RPG video games, and recently started dabbling in 3D modeling software (Blender), and I occasionally enjoy writing. I've recommended Persona 4 Golden to someone, saying the game did a lot to help me accept the ugly parts of myself. I've said I'm pretty confident that in time the number of people who regret transitioning will prove much bigger than the trans community thinks, and that gender dysphoria only having one way to treat it goes against most medical practice. I've said I feel anxious when someone tells me they're transitioning because I think there's a good chance they'll regret it, especially if it involves surgeries and hormones, but there's no socially acceptable way to warn them. I've also said I wonder how many people are transitioning just because of sexism they experienced, and that I know that was at least part of what it was for me.