Disse historiene er oppsummert ved hjelp av AI.
På Reddit deler mennesker ofte sine erfaringer på tvers av flere kommentarer eller innlegg. For å gjøre denne informasjonen mer tilgjengelig, samler detrans.ai alle disse spredte delene i en enkelt, lettlest oppsummering og tidslinje. Alle systemspørringer er notert på spørringssiden.
Noen ganger kan AI hallusinere eller uttale seg om ting som ikke er sanne. Men generelt er de oppsummerte historiene nøyaktige gjenspeilinger av brukernes opprinnelige kommentarer.
Hele historien
I was born female and I have been gender non-conforming for as long as I can remember. Looking back, I don't think I ever actually wanted a male body in itself — I wanted to go back to a time before my body was sexualized, and presenting male was the closest thing I had to that. I felt sexualized by men from such a young age, with my appearance constantly scrutinized, and I was sexually harassed before I even became aware of my own sexuality, so I never got to explore womanhood in a healthy way. I've said before that my sexuality feels like it was stolen from me.
In middle school I identified as FTM and went stealth for a couple of years before someone outed me. I passed pretty well as a teenage boy because I hadn't completed puberty yet and neither had most of my peers — girls hit on me a lot and didn't lose interest when I told them I was trans, though I wasn't on testosterone. My childhood memories are mostly of being mocked for being GNC and/or trans, physically attacked, getting into fights over it, obsessing over passing, and being rejected from both male and female spaces for being "other." I also felt treated like a fetish object by people I actually loved. The more I was abused for it, the more I clung to it, almost out of spite at a certain point. I feel like I was robbed of a girlhood — I have no fond memories I can associate with it.
I desisted at some point, though I never medically transitioned — I've said I'm "still visibly female," still have my breasts, and am "not on testosterone." My parents did everything they could to stop me becoming trans: my mother threw out and destroyed my binder, neither parent agreed to use opposite-sex pronouns with me, and they refused to let me see therapists or doctors who encouraged me to transition — they would force me to go to therapy but switch therapists every time one encouraged me to transition, which happened at least three times. My mother is an avid gender critical person who sent 4thwavenow articles to my father and gossiped about me in Facebook groups like "Parents of ROGD kids." She would ask why I couldn't just be a butch lesbian, but when I did desist and continued dressing masculinely, she still complained my style was sloppy and I should wear a dress.
Despite all that, the harder they pushed back, the more I wanted to transition. I've taken every medication, visited every therapist, and read every radical feminist thinkpiece. I don't believe I can change my sex and I don't believe in trans ideology, and yet nothing I've done has made the thoughts go away. I think it's a combination of pre-existing issues: I wanted to escape misogyny, I wanted to be able to love or fuck a woman the way only a man could, and my father has told me many times that he used to cry himself to sleep wishing he was born a girl and that if he were born later he would have transitioned — maybe it's genetic. Internalized misogyny plays a part, but I think if I were born on a deserted island I'd still fantasize about being a man. I wouldn't sleep with men, but I want a male body because I find it more aesthetically pleasing — not sexually, since I'm more into women, but I'd rather die than have the body type I seek out in female partners.
I've described myself as bisexual, but I repress my feelings toward men because taking on the feminine role in a relationship worsens my dysphoria and doesn't satisfy what I've called my autoandrophilic urges. I've never struggled with internalized homophobia — if anything I have the opposite. I also have anorexia: I was hospitalized against my weight-gain wishes and forced to gain weight, which made my gender dysphoria much worse. The last time I remember feeling like my body belonged to me was at my lowest weight. I've noted that developing anorexia actually improved my life in some ways — I felt confident for the first time, people treated me better, and my dysphoria diminished because I starved away my sex characteristics. I'm convinced I'll never recover from the anorexia because it's rooted in my gender dysphoria (no fat = no curves), and I believe it will be a lifelong struggle.
I also suspect I'm autistic — I've referenced traits that would be brushed off as social awkwardness in a woman but considered creepy in a man, and I've mentioned ADHD in passing. I've said I have no internal sense of self and that I detransitioned partially because I was obsessed with a female character and wanted to dress like her. Because my female socialization was interrupted by transitioning and then detransitioning, I find it nearly impossible to think of myself as human, let alone a woman — every gendered behavior feels like a conscious performance, and it's easier for me to relate to trans women than to most women. I've said I don't consider myself cis or trans because I don't have a gender identity at all.
I've experienced ongoing social punishment regardless of how I present. Frat boys have called me a slur on the street; I've been stared down by a woman wearing a cross necklace in a women's bathroom; I've been mistaken for a feminine man or a trans woman four times in real life without being on testosterone; a friend's little brother asked if I was born a man; a drunk man at a party talked to me about shemale porn and asked about my genitals; an older woman hissed "that's a man" in a bathroom. I get read as some flavor of "genderspecial" about 70% of the time even though I no longer identify as trans. Most women seem more scared of me than of actual men, and I get along better with men, but no straight man wants to be friends with a woman he doesn't want to sleep with. When I present femininely, people treat me better but only as a "pump-and-dump" prospect and won't be seen in public with me; when I express even mild gender non-conformity, people treat me ten times worse and walk on eggshells around me. Strangers approaching my friend group will chat up my friends and avoid eye contact with me. This makes me want to blow my brains out, and ironically makes me want to transition, because at least if I looked fully male people wouldn't walk on eggshells anymore.
Being trans was also deeply alienating. People would lie to my face and validate me out of fear, but exclude me in subtle ways — no one ever asked me to hang out or invited me to parties, and I only understood why later. I've felt constant guilt over encouraging other trans people to keep transitioning in the past; I think I knew deep down something was wrong but didn't want to admit it, maybe because if everyone around me was like me I wouldn't feel so alone. Of two people I encouraged, one is no longer in my life and the other I've tried to gently push in the right direction without success. I also have a 16-year-old friend with a history of rape victimization, anorexia/bulimia, self-harm, PTSD, BPD, possible autism, and a homophobic family who has SRS scheduled for when he turns 18, and I feel powerless to stop it — I've been grieving someone who isn't even dead.
I don't want to let go of my male name — it represents something that belongs to me alone, and I associate my birth name with being heavily bullied by people who would deadname me constantly and with my parents refusing to use my male name. But every time I tell people I used to go by it, they laugh. I still need to tell people who use my male name and pronouns to stop, and it feels like killing off a part of myself. I've posted a recording of my voice asking how people would gender it, wanting honest answers without "hugboxing."
I've considered telling people I'm intersex because normal people don't know much about intersex conditions and might treat me better if they thought I wasn't actively choosing to become a freak. I've also proudly called myself a "tr@nsvestite" ever since an evangelical neighbor called me a "tr@nsvestite imbecile." I'm interested in transhumanism and extreme body modification because I've always felt like an alien among people, and modifying my body feels like a way to reclaim the freakishness imposed on me against my will — I admire Genesis P-Orridge — but my problem is when big pharma pretends these are cure-alls for mental health issues. I think transition would be healthier if viewed as a form of body modification.
I've said I've been going through this for nearly a decade and I'm sick of being told to "just be myself" by people who never had to struggle to be themselves. I've noted that I can't tell how many times I thought I made a genuine connection with someone who then didn't want to maintain it because they didn't want to be seen in public with me. I've considered trying to force myself to dress hyperfemininely again because everyone treated me so much better, but the dysphoria always comes back. I've also said I feel pressure in the opposite direction — I feel I have to repress my feelings and live as a GNC woman even though I hate it, because every mildly quirky woman I've met ended up becoming non-binary or trans and I don't want to be seen as a trender.
I've engaged with gender critical and detrans communities online, and I've acknowledged that spending time in internet echo chambers — both GC and trans spaces — has driven me "completely insane," advising someone else to get off the internet and connect with women in real life. I've criticized GC types for infantilizing FTMs and for the "transitioning is conversion therapy for GNC children" narrative, since I was neither a tomboy nor a girly girl as a kid. I've also noted that most people critical of transgenderism come from a conservative rather than gender abolitionist perspective, which makes it hard to find people who share my views. I've expressed that a lot of the discrimination detrans people face is actually just transphobia, especially since detrans women often get mistaken for MTFs.
On the medical side, I've discussed vocal feminization surgery, electrolysis, implants, and facial masculinization surgery as options, and I've watched Buck Angel videos about vaginal atrophy on testosterone. I've said I don't want to go off something (context unclear) and asked about a test's name. I've considered microdosing testosterone and even said I could go on TRT to get a deeper voice again, though I haven't said I've done so. I've said I don't believe HRT should be banned, comparing it to abortion bans creating black markets.
I've said that one of the reasons I desisted was seeing posts about FTMs becoming incels after transitioning, figuring that going back to being a lesbian-leaning bi woman would make dating easier — but it didn't. Literally no one hits on me despite my being visibly female and not butch at all, and I don't know if I'm ugly, have a terrible personality, or both. I've said I'm "unfuckable" and that much for "life on easy mode." I've also observed that I get hit on least when I try hardest to come off as feminine — the more I try to become normal, the more obvious it becomes to normal people that I'm not like them.