Wszystkie historie

Dysforia od 4. roku życia — i kraj bez tranzycji

Kobieta · Desystencja2,7 tys.
Te historie zostały podsumowane przy użyciu AI.

Na Reddicie ludzie często dzielą się swoimi doświadczeniami w wielu komentarzach lub postach. Aby uczynić te informacje bardziej dostępnymi, detrans.ai gromadzi wszystkie te rozproszone fragmenty w jedno, łatwe do przeczytania podsumowanie i oś czasu. Wszystkie prompty systemowe są zanotowane na stronie z promptami.

Czasami AI może halucynować lub stwierdzać rzeczy, które nie są prawdziwe. Ale ogólnie rzecz biorąc, podsumowane historie są dokładnym odzwierciedleniem oryginalnych komentarzy użytkowników.

Podsumowanie

Jestem kobietą, która zaniechała tranzycji (desisted) — 25-letnia męska, heteroseksualna kobieta, która miała dysforię od 4-5 roku życia, ale nigdy nie przeszła tranzycji medycznej, ponieważ tranzycja nie była dostępna w moim konserwatywnym wschodnioeuropejskim kraju. Doszłam do zaniechania, wychodząc z założenia, że płeć nie istnieje jako pojęcie i że nie mogę stać się prawdziwym mężczyzną, więc teraz identyfikuję się jako kobieta wyłącznie na podstawie swojego kobiecego ciała. Wciąż doświadczam dysforii jako możliwego do opanowania szumu w tle, leczonego terapią CBT, lekiem przeciwdepresyjnym (z możliwą chorobą afektywną dwubiegunową typu 2) i przekierowywaniem uwagi na pracę, przyjaźnie i wolontariat. Mam autoandrofilię, dysforię dolnej części ciała i męską prezencję, która często pozwala mi uchodzić za mężczyznę, i rozważam redukcję piersi dla komfortu fizycznego. Jestem krytyczna wobec teorii płci i opieki afirmującej, ale popieram prawo dorosłych do modyfikacji ciała.

Pełna historia

I was born female and I live in Eastern Europe — I've said I'm Russian, in a country with active anti-LGBT laws and real homophobia. I'm 25 now (as of my posts in 2025-2026). My earliest memory of wanting to be a boy is from around age 4-5, when I got confused for a boy on a playground and it left me perplexed. I've said those thoughts are 'one of my earliest memories.' I was a massive tomboy growing up, and by 16 it got really severe. I never medically transitioned — partly because transition is essentially unavailable in my country, and partly because I didn't know about transgenderism as a concept until halfway through my teens. I was diagnosed with depression as a teen and got into a non-affirming therapist who worked with me on the depression side of things rather than affirming any trans identity. I've said that being cut off from affirming care ironically 'saved me' — that if I'd been born in the West I would have been 'the perfect case' and 'perfect prey' for gender-affirming care, since I check essentially every supposed box for being 'trans for real.' My dysphoria began to fade around 20-21, and I've described 16-20 as the worst period of my mental health, with things improving markedly by 23. I now identify as a desisted woman — a masculine, straight woman. I never came out publicly; I lived 'as if' I was trans in some sense but couldn't come out in my country. I've said I 'self-identified myself out of being trans' by coming to believe that gender as a concept doesn't exist. Causes and contributors: I've reflected a lot on where my dysphoria came from. I grew up in a very unstable, abusive household — the abuse wasn't targeted directly at me but I was 'collateral damage.' I was raised pretty gender-neutral, 'almost like I was the son,' so outside the family my being different was more apparent. I associate my masculine identification as a self-protection mechanism — femininity felt unsafe and like weakness because it wouldn't have protected me back then. I have internalized misogyny and sexist beliefs about what women can be. I live in a sexist country where being seen as a woman was rough and unappealing, and the image of 'a woman' seemed shallow compared to what I felt. I have a masculine face (people said I look like my dad) and a curvy body, and I pass as a man fairly often even without hormones. I also have autoandrophilia (AAP) — I discovered this about a year ago — and bottom dysphoria, which I say is less common in females. At puberty I realized my attraction to men was more masculine and dominant than other girls', and I felt like I 'gazed on them like a man would on a woman,' so identifying as a 'gay man' felt easier because it had representation, whereas extremely masculine heterosexual women are invisible. I was heavily in fandom and consumed mlm/gay porn as a teen, which I believe exacerbated my dysphoria — I've said porn 'did a pretty heavy damage on me as a teen.' I also have other mental illnesses: officially diagnosed with depression, in therapy for about 11 years, on medication, and currently discussing with a new therapist the possibility of bipolar 2 (I say I'm 'like 90% sure'), with a past suspicion of cyclothymia. I note my most dysphoric times fell during depressive episodes. Process toward desisting: I never set out to transition, but I was planning to migrate and possibly identify as a man somewhere that would believe me. What stopped me was coming to believe that gender doesn't exist as a concept — I reasoned that I can't 'feel like a man' because I've never been male, and that any such feeling is my female body making an interpretation. I've described this as a rational, logical conclusion. I also realized transition wouldn't give me an actual male body with working male genitals, which is what I actually want, so it would only accentuate the problem. I found CBT therapy very helpful — it works with underlying beliefs rather than just feelings. I also credit time, aging, medication for depression, and redirecting my attention outward to hobbies, work, volunteering, and friendships. I've said I 'disenchanted' myself from gender by pure reason. Medical: I never took hormones. I never had any surgeries. I am currently considering a breast reduction — I have a very large chest (H cup) and want to go down to about a C cup — primarily for physical comfort reasons (can't sleep comfortably, can't run, back pain) rather than dysphoria, and I've set a one-year waiting period before pursuing it. I've said this would be the only 'medical' thing I inflict on my body. I've discussed vaginal atrophy as something that put testosterone off the table for me. Mental health: I have depression (officially diagnosed), possible bipolar 2, and lifelong dysphoria. I've said dysphoria is 'a habit in my brain' that has lessened but probably won't fully disappear — I aim for neutrality rather than happiness about my sex. I've had suicidal thoughts in the past but said that my reasoning about gender and reality actually stopped them — I reasoned I can't know death is what I want since I've never experienced it, so 'my ill brain is lying to me.' I'm currently on medication and in therapy. Adversity: Unstable, abusive household as a child; sexism and objectification growing up; depression from a young age; living in a homophobic/transphobic country. Social: I have a small circle of friends who know my views and accept me as a masculine woman. My mother knows about my thoughts. My father was emotionally unavailable, dismissive, and treated me like a 'project' rather than a daughter — I've limited contact with him and made sure I have documents to go no-contact if needed. I'm pretty isolated in terms of community — there's no detrans community in my country. I'm a virgin at 25 with almost no dating experience; I've kissed about three times, once with a woman to test attraction (I'm straight). Men generally don't find me attractive because of my masculine presentation, which makes romantic life hard and lonely. Sexuality: I'm straight — attracted to men, with a masculine/dominant attraction. I like masculine men. I've said a lot of my 'gender envy' was actually heterosexuality — the 'do I want to be him or be with him' confusion. I relate to mlm media because there's no representation of masculine straight women. I have AAP tendencies. Regret: I don't regret transition since I never medically transitioned. I do express frustration at lost time and the confusion of my teen years, but I've said I'm in a far better place now than at 16. I don't describe intense regret — more relief that I didn't go further. Outcomes: I'm now a desisted, masculine, straight woman. I live openly as a woman while maintaining masculine presentation and often passing as a man. I work in art and craft, volunteer, work out, and have a few close friends. I describe my current quality of life as much improved — 'healthy, pretty stable' — though I still experience dysphoria as background noise and have loneliness around dating. Attitudes: I'm very critical of gender theory and the concept of gender itself, which I call 'garbage' and 'one of the top 5 worst things that happened to humankind.' I believe adults should have the right to body modifications but that transition shouldn't be presented as changing sex. I'm critical of medicalization of non-conforming youth, of affirming care, of the financial incentives of pharma, and of the lack of open discussion. I identify as politically libertarian and 'politically homeless.' I don't do formal activism but say that existing openly as a masculine woman is my way of 'tipping the scales a little.'