Te historie zostały podsumowane przy użyciu AI.
Na Reddicie ludzie często dzielą się swoimi doświadczeniami w wielu komentarzach lub postach. Aby uczynić te informacje bardziej dostępnymi, detrans.ai gromadzi wszystkie te rozproszone fragmenty w jedno, łatwe do przeczytania podsumowanie i oś czasu. Wszystkie prompty systemowe są zanotowane na stronie z promptami.
Czasami AI może halucynować lub stwierdzać rzeczy, które nie są prawdziwe. Ale ogólnie rzecz biorąc, podsumowane historie są dokładnym odzwierciedleniem oryginalnych komentarzy użytkowników.
Pełna historia
I've been thinking a lot lately about how we talk about sex and gender, and I wanted to share where I'm coming from. I was born female, and I've always been on the androgynous side — people comment on my androgyny all the time. When I speak about that experience, though, I often get told I'm being transphobic, which frustrates me. I relate to gender dysphoric trans folks, but I see myself as a gender dysphoric non-trans person, and honestly my life is great now. I also feel comfortable saying that most people I've talked to in real life have some sort of discomfort with their natal sex or something they envy about the opposite sex, but they eventually accept their bodies — and some are always critical of their bodies, but you can overcome that.
I've been banned from at least one subreddit — not an exclusively trans one — for a post I made around June 2024. In it I tried to make a respectful argument that Men's Mental Health Awareness Month was being overshadowed by Pride, and that most people wouldn't even have noticed it until the political Right pointed it out. I also wrote that women's rights feels like a landmine lately: topics related to sex don't get discussed much because, I felt, neither the Right nor the Left can define 'women,' and every time I've observed a conversation about women's rights referring to females or worldwide issues women face, it gets called transphobic. That experience of being banned made me cautious about where I speak.
Because of the ban-happy culture on the big LGBT subreddits, I've reached out to people directly. I've mentioned r/detrans to a few folks who were posting on lgbt subreddits asking 'am I trans?' — I DM them just to let them know they won't be able to receive balanced criticism because of the culture there, and to offer up conversation and resources. Most of them have been cool; about half have had actual polite conversations with me and were grateful I cared enough to DM them. I did decide to stop mentioning the subreddit itself, though, because the last thing we need is a ban or being flagged as spam.
I also try to give careful advice when people ask about transition. I told one person to take things super slowly — if you have doubts, you can always wait — and to think about it critically: have you researched the risks of surgery, have you ever had any other invasive medical procedures? I suggested talking to older people first, because politics oscillates in the US every 4-8 years and I wouldn't rush a major medical decision just because of politics. I pointed out that there are no medical codes in the US for 'detrans,' so a lot of the stats are skewed. When it came to mastectomy specifically, I listed risks beyond just not having breasts: chronic pain, phantom breast pain, axillary web syndrome, restricted upper body movement, shoulder discomfort, and lymphedema, including nerve injuries from sensory nerves being stretched, transected, or caught in scar tissue. I noted that I have a relative who died getting tonsils removed, so obviously any invasive surgery carries death as a possibility. I also shared a PubMed link about long-term physical changes after mastectomy.
I wrote a longer post in June 2024 asking whether others find the phrase 'Pregnancy does not define Womanhood' odd, and whether the concept of an adult human female being defined by her body's physical development has been eradicated from political correctness. I asked how detransitioners can uniquely help navigate back to a society with mutual understandings of the meanings of words and ideas, and how we can compassionately discuss people who possess the female form and the ability to bring life into the world. In replies I explained my thinking: I believe female bodies were built with the ability to gestate — we shed a uterine lining, for example — so our bodies have different strengths, weaknesses, and needs, and anatomy was basically designed around the ability for females to reproduce. I said I'm called a bigot for believing anatomy is important and I feel like people don't think that anymore. I've heard similar thoughts on C-SPAN, so I believe the idea has entered mainstream society. I also thanked others for sharing that they observe 'women's erasure.'
On children, I've said I think it's an education thing — kids learn to distinguish themselves from others around a certain age, exploring differences, and they probably saw their naked mother before they had conscious memories and later wondered if they would develop into the same thing. I've argued that we're supposed to teach our young to identify similarities and differences between categories of things, including body parts. I feel strongly that gatekeeping medical transition away from children is 100% necessary, because so many kids won't know what 'normal' puberty is, and that scares me.
When it comes to my own discomfort, I've reflected that many of us go through discomfort in our bodies at different ages and with different relationships to our gendered bodies. Sometimes it relates to objectification, and sometimes to how we're treated in accordance with stereotypes rather than as diverse beings with diverse interests. I've written at length about how those of us who feel more comfortable with men tend to gravitate toward effeminate men to teach us how to interact better with women, and that those men usually objectify us less. I've observed that modern transitioners want to go from an effeminate demeanor with a male body to expressing hyperfemininity in both demeanor and body, sometimes overnight, and that when a male friend transitions, our options for people to relate to shrink. I laid out five categories of people we're left with, including females who transitioned and now think we're 'eggs,' hyperfeminine women, hypermasculine men, effeminate men or MtFs, and women like us who are strong, protective, independent, confident, and rational.
I believe it can be GOOD to be both female AND have a protective, assertive, confident, rational, goal-oriented, sporty demeanor, and that our personality doesn't mean we don't still have hormone fluctuations and the capacity for pregnancy. I've said that's essentially the manifesto of a 'TERF,' an ideology banned from polite society, and that just because we're a bullied minority whose behaviors fall within the overlap of male and female doesn't make us less categorically women. I've mentioned feeling insulted when effeminate men who used to be my best friends refer to me as a 'woman' in ways that have nothing to do with being a woman, and that I can no longer correct them without a fight if they're gender ideologues. I've suggested yoga or co-ed sporty places as somewhere to find women you can better relate to.
I've also commented on society's confusion about gender stereotypes — that we can't agree whether to enforce them or not and it's confusing everyone, and that we've ended up with an odd amalgamation of ideologies where nobody knows what words mean anymore. I've broken down 'gender affirming care' into six categories people lump together: clothing/style, name change, pronouns, birth certificate change, hormones, and surgeries. I've expressed a critical view of the trans community as inherently obsessing about and prioritizing themselves and their feelings over others, rooted in poor self-esteem, and more common in males than females. I've also said I think 'non-binary' is going to become a space for people who have modified their bodies, so even though there are only two sexes, society is beginning to make room for people who aren't the norm.
When someone was looking for a therapist, I suggested asking prospective therapists if they've read Abigail Shrier or Dr. Az Hakeem, or hold traditional views, or are willing to work with someone who views gender dysphoria as a mental health disorder to be treated in the mind. I mentioned Gender: A Wider Lens on YouTube as therapists who might have recommendations. Overall I'd say I'm a detransitioned or desisted woman who is critical of how transition is being pushed, especially on children, and who advocates for women's sex-based rights while trying to have compassionate conversations about it.