Todas as histórias

Seis anos discutindo nos espaços de destransição

Mulher · Destransicionou158
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher destransicionada que posta em espaços de destransição e críticos de gênero desde 2019. Fiz fertilização in vitro por volta de 2019 e falo do ponto de vista de alguém que viveu como mulher depois de destransicionar. Sou fortemente crítica da transição como é promovida hoje, da ideia de gênero como espectro e do que vejo como o movimento transgênero impondo papéis de gênero tradicionais. Defendo ativamente essas posições na comunidade e incentivo outras pessoas a evitarem hormônios e a viverem de forma autêntica. Não descrevi nestas postagens cirurgias específicas, datas nem diagnósticos de saúde mental.

História completa

I have been posting in detrans and related gender-critical spaces since at least May 2019, and my comments show a consistent set of views shaped by my own experience of having transitioned and then detransitioned. In my earliest comments here (May 2019) I was talking to someone who had been single for 27 years and wanted tests 'down there'. I asked whether they had actually been denied a Pap smear as a female person, or whether they were just asking for fertility and health tests, noting that 'all tests for fertility (and also for contraception etc.) are pretty much out of pocket' and adding 'Welcome back to womanhood!' I had just been through IVF myself at that point, which is how I knew how the testing and costs worked. I also asked them their age and country. By July 2019 I was offering reassurance to someone afraid of failing at transition or detransition: 'You can't fail at transition or detransition - they're not absolute states of being.' Around the same time I pushed back on the idea that a woman must sound a particular way, saying 'a woman doesn't need to sound any particular way! Women's voices come in many ranges and you're a woman no matter your vocal range.' In August 2019 I got into a sharp exchange with a male poster who had had zero-depth genital surgery. I told him directly: 'saying "everything looks right" is inaccurate, as biological females have a vaginal canal.' I argued there is 'a big difference between getting traditional SRS and zero depth procedures' and that he was 'being deliberately obtuse by not revealing that you have not had what most here would consider traditional SRS.' I also said 'you can not have vaginal sex as you have no vagina (only what you call a vulva). So your experience isn't truly comparable,' while acknowledging that zero-depth procedures for males are safer with fewer complications. I corrected him when he implied a vagina could be seen externally: 'You can't see *any* part of the vagina as a woman walks down the road because it's an internal organ.' I told another male poster presenting as female that 'It's a fetish for you, and you acknowledge that. Be aware that fetishes don't bring any sort of lasting happiness, only true connection with your inner being can do that.' In September 2019 I wrote that 'The real downfall comes when they acknowledge that they are not women, and have become a rudimentary caricature of what they desire. This notion becomes horrifying, and maybe grotesque, in the true meaning of the word.' I also argued that if sex/gender is a spectrum rather than binary, 'you have to accept that everyone is in fact, non-binary or part of the spectrum, by your own definition... you literally/grammatically cannot have it both ways.' In November 2019 I told someone questioning whether to take hormones: 'Plenty of sexy guys wear makeup and plenty of women don't! Lift weights and wear makeup - I love it, and you should do what you want. Hormones are synthetic and eff your body up.' I repeatedly argued that 'gender non conformity is a spectrum' is 'gobbledygook', that 'We are all gender non conforming because gender is a construct', and that 'The transgender movement does *not* advocate for gender non conformity; the opposite. It *enforces* and upholds traditional gender roles.' I also told someone over 40 that they 'should be able to more clearly state your position' and that 'I just think you, and this website, is/are confused.' In January 2020 I commented: 'TIL that girls who want short hair and hate their periods are considered men now. WTAF.' In March 2020 I signed off a comment 'Def Femme.' Overall I identify as a detransitioned woman, I am critical of the current framing of gender identity and of transition as it is currently promoted, and I actively argue against it in these communities. I have not described any specific surgeries, dates of transition or detransition, diagnoses, or mental health history in these comments beyond the reference to having done IVF.