Todas as histórias

Questionar o gênero lhe custou o grupo de amigos

Mulher · Destransicionou290
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher destransicionada que voltou a se identificar como mulher e perdeu um grupo de amigos por questionar o gênero como conceito. Tive problemas de saúde que diminuíram depois que acabou o estresse de pisar em ovos com amigos obcecados por gênero. Aconselhei os outros a serem abertos com os parceiros, a pausar a testosterona com orientação médica e critiquei o amplamente citado número de 1% de arrependimento pós-cirúrgico como metodologicamente frágil. Continuo crítica de como a pesquisa sobre destransição se tornou politizada e esperançosa quanto às trajetórias individuais de mudança.

História completa

I lost a whole group of friends recently because reidentifying as a woman led me to question gender as a concept, and that was apparently not allowed among them. What's really ironic is that only days before this began I had talked with one of them, who holds a master's degree, about living in an age of anti-intellectualism. My views on gender are fairly blunt: I don't believe gender envy is real — to me it's just liking how someone looks, and gender is just clothes and stereotypes. Coming from someone who did lose a lot of friends over this, I'd say yes it sucks, but I no longer have to walk on eggshells around them all the time, because to some people gender is literally their entire lives. The relief is incredible. I was having a lot of health issues before this all happened, many of which lessened once it happened, I suspect because they were being exacerbated due to stress. I also found that it was around these people I felt most ashamed of calling myself a woman, because to be "cis" was uncool, lame, hateful, etc. It's a tough thing to go through but in the end something has to give. I also felt that friends who are unsupportive about someone's detransition are being cruel — it's that person's choice and clearly they weren't happy, so it seems like they care more about the identity than the person's well-being. On the biology of sex, I've pointed out that chromosomes aren't the only thing that dictates sex — there are biological females with Turner syndrome with one X chromosome and biological males with Klinefelter syndrome who have XXY chromosomes. I have advised others in the community with care. When someone asked about timing, I said it was when I was about 19 and a half. I've told someone struggling with dysphoria and a partner that I know exactly what they mean, and I'd advise talking to their girlfriend because keeping secrets from each other is going to lead to resentment — something is going to happen eventually whether the concerns are kept secret or not, and it may be better to be open now when there is no tension. I acknowledged that sometimes it feels crazy to live in this world, but noted there's a certain comfort in recognizing that no matter how insane the world might get, we're still in control of ourselves first and foremost and can still choose to live our lives however we want. I told them they're not alone and neither is their partner, that dysphoria is a real beast regardless of where it comes from, and that plenty of people here understand how difficult it is to start questioning the nature of gender while being totally immersed in a world obsessed with it. When someone mentioned hoping to get pregnant to have a "reason," I said that says everything and recommended taking a break from testosterone, with the guidance of an endocrinologist, to see how they feel. I told them no matter what they do, they're still themselves — I think all the worry in trans circles about one's "true self" misses the point that no matter what you do to your body, it's still yours, it's still you. I've also been supportive of people's faith commitments, calling it really cruel when a "friend" calls someone's faith a cult and suggesting cutting that person off if they see detransitioning as some kind of personal slight. I've engaged seriously with the research on detransition and regret. I explained that the commonly cited 1% regret figure comes from one or two meta-analyses pooling figures from studies on post-surgical regret, and I laid out the problems with them: study date, since many only involve the "old" cohort of gender-affirming care patients in which the typical patient is male-to-female, male-attracted, and has a lifelong history of gender dysphoria, rather than the "new" cohort which skews much younger, more female, less same-sex attracted, with more rapid onset — very different patient populations; studies only containing data from patients who actually followed up after retaining contact with their treatment providers, something detransitioners seem less likely to do; studies only surveying post-surgical patients, who aren't representative of the whole transgender demographic, especially the new cohort; an inconsistent time frame of follow-up surveys across studies, ranging from less than one year to nine years in one meta-analysis; and "regret" itself often being poorly defined in these postsurgical follow-ups, not necessarily correlating 1:1 with detransition, since there are detransitioners who don't regret transition and vice versa. Overall I concluded there is a lack of any good information on the rate of transition regret or detransition and the demographics of detransitioners — what studies exist are either out of date, poorly formulated, or not actually representative of the population at hand. I also said it's very sad how politicized the pursuit of this information has become, that I completely understand why from multiple perspectives, but I wish people could put aside their egos long enough to recognize that having more quality information is never a bad thing. Most recently I reacted to someone's before-and-after photos by saying the similarity yet obvious difference is crazy, that they look like they could be their own twin, and that it weirdly makes me optimistic for both trans people and detrans people in their individual trajectories — such clear evidence of how radically we can change. Current status: I identify as a woman again after having transitioned and then detransitioned.