Todas as histórias

Cinco anos no Reddit, vendo vozes da destransição serem apagadas

Homem · Desistiu727
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou um aliado da destransição, homem, que observa e comenta na comunidade de destransição do Reddit desde meados de 2019, sem descrever nenhuma experiência pessoal de transição ou destransição. Concentrei-me em conscientizar sobre o aliciamento online de crianças, o excesso de diagnósticos médicos, a disposição de terapeutas em escrever cartas de transição e o que vejo como censura ideológica das vozes da destransição no Reddit. Fiquei profundamente preocupado com a onda de banimentos do Reddit em junho de 2020 e o banimento breve do subreddit de destransição, pedindo aos moderadores que fizessem backup do conteúdo e migrassem para plataformas alternativas. Não descrevi nestes posts nenhuma disforia pessoal, transição médica, condições de saúde mental ou destransição.

História completa

I am a detrans ally and a long-time lurker of the detrans community on Reddit, first posting in August 2019 after about two months of lurking. I have never described myself as having transitioned or detransitioned in these posts; rather, I have consistently identified as an ally of detransitioners, and in one exchange I referred to myself as a boy, indicating I am male. My engagement with the community has been primarily as an observer and commenter, offering support, flagging concerns about censorship, and trying to raise awareness of issues affecting detransitioners. My involvement began in mid-2019, when I commented on posts about parental responsibility and the way vulnerable people can be drawn into trans communities because those groups were 'the only ones who were listening' and 'showing respect.' I expressed concern about online grooming of children, saying it was 'absolutely scary' and suggesting that parents might need to homeschool and keep kids away from the internet to prevent it. I also commented on medical over-diagnosis, comparing it to doctors 'slapping on ADHD and Autism Spectrum diagnoses on every single thing even if it didn't fit those categories.' In August 2019 I made my first post, sharing a story or campaign I felt needed coverage, acknowledging I wasn't sure if it was the right subreddit and hoping it wasn't offensive. I received feedback that it may not have been appropriate there, and I accepted it gracefully, saying I appreciated the feedback and would also post in radfem subreddits, though I wondered if they would want to help 'a boy.' I have been vocal about what I perceive as censorship and ideological pressure on Reddit. In October 2019 I expressed hope that the detrans subreddit would stay up and not be 'taken down by the far-left idealogues of Reddit,' calling it an important sub for people who need advice or healing. I also raised concerns about 'fake-detrans comments or posts' and asked what moderators could do about them. In November 2019 I engaged with a user whose post had been removed, attributing it to 'typical Reddit censorship.' In February 2020 I commented on a post about a therapist who quickly agreed to write a letter, calling it 'disturbing' and saying such stories need more awareness. In April 2020 I engaged with a user who I felt had 'woken up from the propoganda' they were fed as a youth, asking about their age and the nature of their dysphoria, and suggesting the r/RoleReversal community as potential support for their relationship preferences. I also wished them well in finding a compatible partner. The most significant event for me was Reddit's June 29, 2020 banwave. I was 'genuinely afraid' the detrans subreddit would be targeted, given past accusations of hate speech against it by brigaders and trans activists. I posted to mark that it had survived, calling it 'at least one rational decision' by the admins. I shared links to lists of banned subreddits, noted that not all banned subs were hate speech but rather ones that 'challenged mainstream narrative,' and said this was why the detrans sub was in danger. I discussed alternative platforms like SaidIt and Ruqqus, noting that safe spaces for marginalized groups like detrans had moved to Ruqqus. When the detrans sub was briefly banned and unbanned on July 11, 2020, I called it 'despicable' and urged the moderators to back up content and migrate to other sites. I also said the banwave made me seriously consider leaving Reddit altogether. Throughout, my stance has been supportive of detransitioners and critical of both mainstream medical/activist narratives around transition and of what I see as increasing ideological censorship online. I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, or detransition, nor any medical interventions, mental health diagnoses, trauma, or family circumstances in these posts.