Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.
No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.
Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.
Resumo
Sou uma mulher destransicionada que antes se identificava como homem trans e depois como não binária, e que tomou testosterona sem disforia documentada. Hoje acredito que minha transição foi movida em grande parte por homofobia internalizada e pelo que chamo de autohomoerotismo, e sou duramente crítica da medicina da transição e da ideologia de gênero. Tenho mudanças permanentes da testosterona, incluindo voz mais grave e pelos faciais, e me disseram que ainda pareço inconfundivelmente mulher. Passo tempo aconselhando outras pessoas em fóruns de destransição e incentivando-as a parar os hormônios e a se reidentificar com o sexo de nascimento. Sou crítica da identidade não binária e das abordagens afirmativas, e defendo conteúdo crítico do gênero e de destransição para quem considera transicionar.
História completa
I have spent a lot of time on detrans and gender-critical forums giving advice to other people considering or going through transition and detransition, and through writing to others I have worked out what I think about my own situation.
I was born female. I came to identify as a trans man and then as non-binary, and I underwent what I now call gender-affirming body modifications, including a course of testosterone. I did not have documented dysphoria, which is something I have questioned others about sharply — I asked one person how they got access to HRT without any documented dysphoria, and whether they made fake self-termination threats, and I have been critical of doctors who prescribe controlled substances without proper follow-up examinations. I have also been told by an endocrinologist that quitting testosterone/HRT was a bad idea, which I found unprofessional, since pressuring someone into continuing non-medically-related HRT seems wrong to me. I asked others whether they still had their ovaries, because if not they would need estrogen, since the body needs either the male or female sex hormone to function properly.
I have thought a lot about what testosterone did to me. I know that voice changes are among the more stubborn effects: I have told others that the voice will naturally lighten a bit and some damage to the vocal cords may heal, but that it will never fully return to its pre-testosterone level, and that pain persisting beyond six months warrants medical help. I know that one month off testosterone is not enough for effects to fully revert, and that if someone was on slow-release injections (one dose every 12-14 weeks) the drug is still in the system for at least three months. I have also noted that breasts may shrink slightly once male-pattern body fat redistribution returns, but that HRT-induced breasts will never fully disappear without surgery. I have told people to wait at least another three months before committing to anything after stopping.
I have also dealt with the social side. I have advised people to just quit HRT and start presenting more femininely without announcing it, and to tell family simply that they are no longer trans. I have told a young person that they are too young to be held accountable, that they have not done anything medically, and that their family will probably just think of it as a phase, like being an emo, and be happy they are no longer trans. I have also told someone to change their user flair from 'desisted female' to 'detrans female' since they had already undergone body modifications, and advised them to tell people in advance that they are a detrans female whose voice and physique have been permanently altered.
I have thought about why I wanted to transition. I believe a lot of it stemmed from internalized homophobia — the desire to transition so I could present as a straight man rather than a lesbian. I have suggested Cognitive Behavioral Therapy to identify what in one's thought process causes dysphoria, and I have asked the pointed question: if transitioning were not a possibility at all, what would you do instead to deal with your dysphoria? I have also developed a theory I call autohomoeroticism — transgenderism caused by fetishisation of, or the desire to engage in, opposite-sex homosexual relationships — and I have used the term fujoshi for female autohomoeroticism induced by excessive hentai/manga consumption depicting male homosexuality. I have observed that I would always imagine myself as the masculine and strong person who came to save her when she was in trouble, and I have told others they can still be that person without surgeries or testosterone.
I have also thought about the role of external pressure. I have noted that a partner's father can pressure someone into testosterone, and I have told people not to let anyone coerce them into violating their own bodily autonomy by using synthetic opposite-sex hormones to satisfy someone else's desires — either tell your partner that she and her family will have to accept you the way you are, or leave her.
On the ideology, I am critical. I believe transgenderism is based on queer theory, which states that gender is fluid, whereas race is based on critical race theory, which states race is fixed and immutable — neither of which I consider scientific. I do not believe non-binary gender exists; everyone except a minuscule amount of truly hermaphroditic people is either male or female. I have advised parents not to affirm a child in any way, but to treat them kindly while refusing their preferred name and pronouns and instead introducing them to detrans/gender-critical content.
I have also commented on my own appearance since detransitioning. I have been told, and I agree, that I look uncannily female in photographs despite facial hair, and that nature and common sense prevail over gender ideology. I have noticed that many female transsexuals complain about being perceived as pre-teen boys when clean-shaven and try to compensate for their innate femaleness by growing a lot of facial hair — I think I was one of them. I have been asked why I intend to stay socially trans, and I have pushed back: it isn't like ex-smokers pretend they still smoke, so why be ashamed of having changed for the better?
I have also dealt with practical health matters: I have given detailed calorie-counting and macronutrient advice for weight management, and I have asked others how testosterone made them sick and whether they saw a medical professional. I have also dealt with hair loss questions, noting finasteride was designed for men and does nothing for a woman with normal testosterone levels, though minoxidil may help, and suggesting a wig as a fallback.