Todas as histórias

A doença crônica tornou a transição arriscada demais — depois vieram as razões

Mulher · Desistiu117
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma pessoa do sexo feminino destransicionada/desistente que nunca fez transição médica nem social e nunca se declarou publicamente, em grande parte porque minhas deficiências, doença crônica, problemas de cicatrização e doença mental me fizeram julgar a transição arriscada demais. Ainda tenho com frequência conflitos internos de gênero, mas aprendi a conviver com eles pela gratidão pelo meu sexo de nascimento e pela saúde que me resta. Acredito que meu desejo de ser homem vinha de trauma sexual, disfunção sexual, uma doença crônica predominantemente feminina e misoginia internalizada — um mal-entendido do tipo “a grama do vizinho é mais verde” sobre a masculinidade. Sou crítica da ideologia de gênero dominante, vendo-a como baseada em estereótipos e um fator que leva à destransição. Convivo com ideação suicida crônica junto com minhas condições.

História completa

I was born female and have struggled with my gender for a long time. I never socially or medically transitioned, and I never came out publicly — I only told a couple of close people, and none of my family. My reasoning for not transitioning was practical as much as it was emotional. First, I realized I would never have a biologically male body. I didn't want to be a woman who looks like a man; I wanted to actually be male, which I can't be. Second, I am disabled and physically cannot transition. I already have too many doctor appointments managing my conditions, and I would not choose to add more visits for hormones. I also worry I would have a bad reaction to hormones, and because I cannot heal from wounds properly, I would never pursue surgery unless it were absolutely necessary. Third, I am mentally ill and do not trust myself to make such major, ill-advised decisions. TLDR for me: not coming out and not transitioning was easier health-wise, and I frankly have bigger things to worry about. My inner gender struggles continue to plague me frequently, but I am learning to live with it. I tell myself you don't always get what you want in life. My disabilities have, in a way, prepared me to deal with disappointment about my body, and my chronic suicidal ideation has toughened me up to lamenting how life could be better if only certain things were different. On the reasons behind my wish to be male: I wanted to be a man because I figured that if I had been born male I wouldn't be struggling with the issues I struggle with — specifically sexual trauma, sexual dysfunction, and a chronic illness that predominantly affects women. I recognize that this was delusional, since men struggle with those things too. I also think, in general, that when women want to transition to male it often boils down to finding masculinity superior to femininity, rooted in stereotypes. What helps me is finding things to be grateful for about my birth sex and about the health I do have. I'm glad I still have some mobility and independence and can work — many people with my conditions can't. I also feel there is something special and spiritual about being a woman, though the same could be said for being a man in a slightly different way. There are pros and cons to both sexes; each comes with its own challenges and strengths. While the opposite sex may have its allure, there is still beauty to be discovered in whatever your birth sex is. I think some people fall into a 'grass is greener' mindset instead of trying to salvage the life they were born into. I also believe a lot of people fall into the trap of having a view of gender based on other people. Anytime a person compares themselves to others they sell themselves short and makes assumptions about other people's lives, giving a false sense of reality. Your understanding needs to come from within and be as empirical as possible — not based on societal implications, not based on how you think members of the opposite sex live, not measuring your worth by immutable characteristics. I'm pretty tomboyish and androgynous myself. I think a significant quadrant of women find femininity as defined by the patriarchy to be 'bad' and therefore believe becoming more masculine is the best course of action, rather than just accepting being their own type of woman — one not gussied up in makeup and girly outfits all the time. I think it's that lack of self-acceptance combined with misunderstanding the opposite sex that causes a lot of confusion. I agree with the framing of internalized misogyny as part of it, and with people not being able to conceptualize someone going against gender norms comfortably and confidently without tying it to a different orientation. My mother put pressure on me similar to what older generations of women faced — things were harder for them, with less freedom and a ton of pressure on 'attracting a husband,' and then they put the same pressures on their daughters. That, among a myriad of other reasons, is why so many young women question their gender. More broadly, I believe all this gender discourse started because people realized they hated how the patriarchy defined how men and women should behave, dress, and their segregated roles in society. They could have just subverted the notion that women = skirts, makeup, housewife and men = emotionless, machismo. Instead, in my view, they invented 'gender newspeak.' You can be a woman and not wear girly clothes; you can be a man and be sensitive. If gender is a social construct, then construct your own sense of self — saying you're a woman but feel different from other women doesn't make you non-binary, it means you should become confident in your personal womanhood. You don't need to adopt new pronouns or risk your biology to eschew patriarchal notions. I also think seeing gender as nothing more than stereotypes is a big factor in why there are so many detransitioners. I have also given advice to others in the community: I suggested to one person that they and their partner try monogamy for a while to sort out their feelings, since outside influences seemed to be the catalyst of their turmoil, and I noted that if they have BPD they need to protect themselves first. I've also encouraged men who feel inadequate about masculinity to find mentors, men's groups, or other sources of inspiration, noting that a lot of people feel lost somewhere in the middle but there's nothing wrong with being an effeminate man. Current status: I have not transitioned, I still experience frequent inner gender struggles, and I manage them alongside chronic illness, disability, and chronic suicidal ideation.