Todas as histórias

Um GRC que não pode ser desfeito — e a luta para corrigi-lo

Mulher · Desistiu1,1 mil
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou a Dra. Kirsty Entwistle, psicóloga clínica formada no Reino Unido que trabalhou antes no Tavistock GIDS e agora mora em Portugal; eu mesma não sou trans nem destransicionada. Desde 2019 publico recursos, orientações clínicas e links de pesquisa no r/detrans, cofundei a associação de terapia IATDD e depois a Detrans Foundation, que oferece terapia no esquema pague-o-quanto-puder e defesa de direitos para pessoas destransicionadas. Minha principal campanha de ativismo diz respeito às pessoas destransicionadas do Reino Unido presas a um Gender Recognition Certificate, em que trabalho com um advogado e um grupo de mulheres detrans para tentar restaurar o sexo de nascimento nas certidões de nascimento. Incentivei repetidamente a notificação de efeitos colaterais de hormônios ao RxISK, apoiei o caso Keira Bell e pressionei o NHS England a implementar a recomendação do Relatório Cass para serviços detrans. Continuo trabalhando clinicamente com pessoas destransicionadas e colaborando com pesquisadores e com o NHS England.

História completa

I am a UK-trained Clinical Psychologist, Kirsty Entwistle, who previously worked at the Tavistock GIDS in Leeds and later moved to Portugal. I am not myself trans or detransitioned — I have stated clearly on Reddit that 'I'm not trans or detrans so have no personal experience to offer' and 'I'm a psychologist trying to learn more about the broader context to transition and detransition.' My involvement with the detrans community comes entirely from my clinical and advocacy work. I first posted on r/detrans in October 2019, sharing free online self-help resources (grounding techniques, mindfulness, Compassion Focused Therapy exercises, CBT materials) that might be useful to people who are detransitioning, covering issues like anxiety, rumination and shame. I invited feedback and offered to add more resources over time. In the same month I advised someone about choosing an NHS adult gender clinic, stressing that they should 'take agency rather than feel you have been sent to a certain clinic,' and noted that I had written an open letter about the Tavistock service under my name on Medium. I also explained that I had left the service but that it was not appropriate to go into the reasons publicly. I have been vocal about the science. In November 2019 I pushed back on a video claiming twenty years of neurological evidence for gender dysphoria, citing the ENIGMA MRI mega-analysis from the EPATH 2019 book of abstracts, which found trans people's brains are 'mostly consistent with sex assigned at birth.' I have also questioned the validity of the DSM and gender dysphoria as a diagnosis, repeatedly sharing Erica Bryant's paper on the history of GID/GD and noting DSM-5 was controversial even among its own authors. I have been cautious about outside media coverage. When a filmmaker approached the community in late 2019, I questioned whether they had genuinely been researching detransition for a year, pointed them to Jesse Singal's work, and warned that making a documentary lightly 'could do more harm than good,' noting that some detransitioners who made video testimonies received death threats. I recommended the Swedish film 'Trans Train' as a sensitive portrayal. I regularly share detransitioners' YouTube testimonies (Silas, Mackenzie Leigh, L.A.C, Being, Laura Reynolds, Wheston Chancellor Grove) and comment on them, both to support the people involved and to learn. I have reflected that 'there are a lot of unknowns when it comes to the effects of testosterone on female bodies' and that 'Testosterone is a psychoactive drug,' which helps explain initial euphoria and why negative consequences may take years to outweigh the positives. I have also highlighted case studies on endometrial and cervical cancer in transgender men, pelvic floor dysfunction, and a 2018 review of breast and reproductive cancers. A major focus of my advocacy has been the Gender Recognition Certificate problem. Since March 2020 I have been emailing the GRC panel and the Government Equalities Office on behalf of an anonymous female detransitioner who wanted to annul her GRC, and I was told 'there is no process in law to annul a GRC.' I planned to write to Liz Truss and encouraged detransitioners to write to their MPs. By September 2022 I was working with a lawyer and a small group of UK detrans women stuck with male birth certificates after obtaining GRCs, and I have repeatedly called for others in the same situation to contact me through the Detrans Foundation website. As of August 2024 I confirmed that applying for a new GRC remains the only available option. I have consistently encouraged people to report adverse effects of cross-sex hormones and puberty blockers to RxISK, an independent watchdog, because 'there is no systematic follow up of detransitioners.' I have also supported the Keira Bell judicial review, praising her 'incredible courage and integrity,' and cited a BMJ rapid response survey showing over 80% of 476 UK doctors did not believe children can give informed consent to gender reassignment treatments. In January 2021 I co-founded IATDD (International Association for Detransition and Desistance), an association of psychologists and psychotherapists from the USA, UK, Ireland, Greece and Australia offering therapy to people who are detransitioning or desisting. That website later closed, and in June 2022 a colleague and I set up the Detrans Foundation to offer support, therapy on a pay-what-you-can basis (including pro bono), and advocacy for detransitioners in the UK and Europe whose needs differ from US detransitioners because they transitioned via state healthcare. Other former IATDD members formed GETA. I have also been involved in research: I mentioned research being undertaken with UK young adults who experienced gender dysphoria as children or adolescents, and in April 2025 I confirmed I had met with the person conducting interviews for NHS England's work on detransition services. I have encouraged people to write to NHS England to press for implementation of the Cass Review's recommendation 25 for NHS support for detransitioners, and I wrote to them myself in December 2024 without receiving a reply. Throughout, I have tried to signpost people to therapy, peer support (ImWatson91, Charlie Evans' DetransAdNet), Dr Az Hakeem, the GD Working Group, and academic literature, while being honest about the limits of my knowledge.