Todas as histórias

O servidor que ela criou para destransicionadores — e o banimento que o encerrou

Mulher · Desistiu43
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma feminista radical e administradora de um servidor de Discord crítico de gênero, não uma pessoa destransicionada; acompanhava o r/detrans e ofereci aos seus membros um servidor com moderação leve e um canal de destransição. Fui banida do subreddit depois que minha thread de convite foi tomada por usuários que eu via como incels desviando a conversa. A maior parte da minha atividade consistiu em defender a teoria feminista radical contra o que eu via como reação misógina, incluindo argumentos de que a misandria não é equivalente à misoginia. Em agosto de 2019 banni um membro homem do servidor depois que ele respondeu a mulheres que diziam que votariam numa presidente mulher mandando que fizessem sexo oral, e ele voltou numa segunda conta. Continuo crítica de gênero e apoiando os destransicionadores como comunidade, identificando-me como mulher e não como detrans.

História completa

I never identified as detransitioned or desisted — I want to be clear about that up front: I am a woman who follows the r/detrans community but is not detrans myself. My involvement with that subreddit came entirely through my role as the creator and administrator of a Radical Feminist/gender-critical Discord server, which I opened in late June 2019. I created the server because I wanted a space for inter-generational Radical Feminist dialogue among gender-critical people, and I deliberately included a channel specifically for detransition topics and detransitioned folks. I advertised it publicly on r/detrans on June 30, 2019, describing it as "open to anyone GC" with "Age diversity encouraged." My intention was good-faith: I wanted to offer a lightly moderated alternative to what I saw as over-moderated Reddit spaces, where detransitioners and gender-critical feminists could talk without "the usual zealous over moderation." What followed was a sustained conflict. Within a day of posting my invitation, I was trolled in the thread by users I characterized as "obvious incels" — people who called feminists "obnoxious and loud," and one who, I felt, tried to blame radical feminists for transgenderism. The subreddit's moderators banned me, which I took as a betrayal: "These mods burnt a bridge." I was frustrated because I felt I had extended a gracious invitation and had it thrown back in my face with what I saw as misogynistic hostility. The bulk of my comments in this transcript are arguments defending radical feminist theory against users on the subreddit. I made clear, repeatedly, that I was not detrans: "I follow this sub, I'm not detrans, and made space where they can discuss their issues if they want to." I pushed back hard against anyone who used the word "misandry" unironically, arguing that "There is absolutely no valid equivocation of misandry and misogyny," and that men as a class "perpetuate and support a system of oppression that subjugates females and elevates themselves." I rejected the framing of radical feminism as a "lifestyle," comparing it dismissively to "your average male who thinks he's superior to women but no one challenges their blatant misogyny regularly." I was confident in the theory and somewhat amused by the resistance I encountered: "My post invitation became somewhat entertaining lol." I also clashed with a user who I felt was trying to derail the thread by implying he would hide or report my post. I read his comment — "I haven't done anything to hide your post... Other users who see it and are interested will still join" — as "very clearly an implied threat," and told him he seemed unaccustomed to men being criticized openly. By August 2019, the conflict had moved into my Discord server itself. A male member of the server reacted to women saying they would vote for a female president by throwing what I called a "mantrum" and telling the women to "suck his dick," and accusing us of "vagina voting." I banned him, told him I had screenshots, and called him a "rapey pos" and a "homophobe." He returned using another account, and I accused him of being a racist as well, citing his use of the n-word: "When you are a rapist it makes you a rapist. Sorry. Racist rapist." Overall, my engagement was political and ideological rather than personal. I was not working through a detransition of my own; I was an ally and organizer trying to build a Radical Feminist space that included detransitioners among its constituency, and I ended up in a series of heated disputes both on Reddit and in my own server with people I perceived as misogynistic, chauvinistic, or acting in bad faith.