Todas as histórias

Uma retenção de 72 horas moldou a visão dela sobre a afirmação

Mulher · Desistiu237
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma defensora próxima da destransição, e não uma destransicionadora: nunca me identifiquei como trans, mas trabalho com crianças no Canadá e sou abertamente contra o que vejo como o perigo de fazer a transição de crianças. Argumento que os profissionais são obrigados a afirmar qualquer criança que diga ser trans, sob pena de perder o emprego ou ter os filhos tirados, e que os resultados pós-CRS são apresentados de forma enganosa como indistinguíveis da anatomia natal. Tenho meu próprio histórico de saúde mental, incluindo uma tentativa de suicídio que resultou numa retenção de 72 horas, o que molda minha visão de que declarações suicidas devem levar ao pronto-socorro e não ser usadas como moeda de pressão. Apoio que se mostrem os resultados cirúrgicos reais e que se adotem medidas menos extremas para a insatisfação com o corpo antes de considerar a transição. Acredito que os destransicionadores estão ajudando a criar mudança ao mostrar os danos do cuidado de afirmação.

História completa

I have never identified as trans, and I want to be clear about that up front — I am not writing from inside a transition or a detransition of my own. What I am writing from is a long stretch of work with children and a growing conviction that the way our culture now handles gender-questioning kids is dangerous. I work with children professionally. Around January 2020 I realized, and later stated plainly, that if a child in my care told me they were trans, I would be required to show 100% support — I could not explore the feeling with them, could not suggest they might not be trans, could not even raise biology — without facing serious consequences at work. I repeated this point several times over the following months: doctors, psychologists, social workers, teachers and parents all face the same pressure, and can lose their jobs or their children if they do anything other than affirm. I described this as a system in which parents or doctors who try to stop children from socially or medically transitioning can have their kids taken away or lose their livelihood. I live in Canada, in Ontario, and in February 2020 I said I was appalled at how our country is handling these issues, while admitting I did not really know what the actual process looks like elsewhere in Canada. I have been in therapy myself for my own issues — not for gender — and I used that experience as a yardstick. When I read that a young person had only been seen by a therapist for eight months before being fast-tracked, I reacted strongly: for something this serious, especially at that age, eight months is only 'the tip of the iceberg' and is 'super fucked up.' I have also said that I am not trans when making that comparison, so my therapy was about processing other material. On regret and outcomes, I have argued that it is false and dangerous for people who have had SRS to claim the result is indistinguishable from a natal vagina and that even doctors cannot tell the difference. I supported a subreddit that posted multiple real post-SRS results, on the grounds that it proved bad outcomes are not limited to one or two isolated cases — my analogy was that when you shop online you want multiple reviews and pictures before committing. I acknowledged that some people on that sub were cruel, which I called unhelpful, but maintained that more examples are better overall. On mental health and crisis behaviour, I have direct experience: I was placed on a 72-hour hold after a suicide attempt, and I described that experience as 'a big fucking eye opener' — a serious thing, not a threat to be thrown around idly to get your way. That experience shaped how I reacted when I read a parent describing a teenager who said not wearing a binder left suicide as her 'only other option.' I called that statement ridiculous and dramatic and suggested the parent consider taking the child to the emergency room when such things are said: if the teen is bluffing she will see what an ordeal it is, and if she is not, she gets help either way. More broadly, I have advised people who dislike their body to try less extreme measures first — working out, which also helps depression and self-confidence, or shaving your head to take control of your hairline — and I said plainly that liking women's clothing and dresses is not a good reason to transition. I questioned the logic of expecting to become the woman you want to look like when you do not like the person you currently are, and urged addressing underlying issues first. I framed my own advice as coming from zero perspective of wanting to transition. By June 2020 I had arrived at a recurring frustration: every time I read a story of someone failed by doctors or mental-health professionals, I ask what those professionals are actually supposed to do, because in my own profession I would lose my job instantly for doing anything other than validating and encouraging anyone who claims to be trans. I said anyone who goes against the grain is called a transphobe, attacked, cancelled, and accused of literal violence and of causing the suicide of trans people. I have encouraged detransitioners directly, telling one person that they are an important part of creating change that will help people realize what I see as the danger of transing children.