Todas as histórias

Nove meses de testosterona, e depois o longo luto

Mulher · Destransicionou3,2 mil
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher destransicionada que viveu como homem trans e tomou testosterona por cerca de nove meses, destransicionando em 2014. Tive um episódio depressivo grave depois de largar a T, um longo período de luto e ruminação disfórica de gênero e pensamentos obsessivos contínuos sobre o corpo, com os quais o Zoloft tem ajudado. Hoje sou casada com um homem, mãe em tempo integral de um bebê e de enteados, e terapeuta de profissão. A destransição danificou minhas relações familiares de maneiras que não espero mais consertar, e tornar minha história pública causou um dano duradouro de que ainda estou me recuperando. Continuo crítica do establishment médico e da defesa politizada da destransição, mas não tenho raiva das pessoas trans em geral.

História completa

I was born female and grew up Catholic in what I now describe as a narcissistic family system, with a little brother who was the golden child. As a child I was bullied — one bully later reached out in my twenties to apologize for how he treated me in second grade — and I had no adult who particularly cared what was happening between me and other kids at school, so I was a pleasant, completely zoned-out kid with constant stomach aches. Puberty brought a turn from bullying into sexual harassment, which again no adults were talking to kids my age about; I think parents in the 1990s were remarkably checked out. I also had a period as a kid where I seriously suspected I might have Down syndrome and no one wanted to tell me — a sense that something was just very off about me. I transitioned and was on testosterone cypionate for about nine months. I did not pass and knew I wasn't going to without extensive lower-body surgery. What I got from T was a deeper voice, extra body hair, hairline changes I patrolled anxiously, and the private-parts changes — but no passing. I experienced a lot of condescension from people who pretended T was delivering transformative magic as an ongoing favor to me, which infuriated me: "I have intense gender dysphoria, I'm not stupid, those are different things." I also disliked being recruited as a token trans friend. Eventually a pile of logistical realities built up like a math equation: T wasn't helping me pass; I hated being visibly trans and how it changed my social interactions and limited where I could work; I hated doctors and needles; I was angry about how people had treated me as a woman; and I realized my vision of life as a trans man was really a fantasy of what my life would be if I'd been born a cis man. So I detransitioned. I detransitioned in 2014. The first couple of months were extremely messy — I describe 2 months off T as "a really weird, surreal, bad time" with awful ruminating and anxiety. I went through the most intense depressive episode of my life shortly after quitting T and wish someone had suggested antidepressants before I stopped, because T had been functioning as a strong antidepressant. It took about a year and a half before the ground under my feet felt stable and I felt more socially competent, present, and confident. I've been detransitioned for years now and I'm super happy with that choice. I conceptualize my detransition as "the hard, right choice" in a gender discourse where very few people think hard can coexist with right. I've had a long mourning period — I was "super super sad" for a long time and thought for a long while about whether it would be better to un-alive myself, but realized there was no version of my values where that was okay. I'm glad I went through the grief, because when it pops up now I know what it is. I still deal with obsessive thoughts about my body; they come and go, and stress reliably brings back obsessive thoughts about how I don't make sense as a woman. I've had periods of obsessive body-hatred that were intense enough that I wanted my breasts gone — when my breast milk came in after having my baby I thought I might really lose it, I wanted them gone so badly. I still sometimes think about at least a reduction; it's not off the table. I have saggy DD breasts. I take Zoloft, which I started for postpartum depression and which has helped both my obsessive spirals and my body hatred; Prozac never did anything for me. I also lift weights, which helps me accept my body more. I've never been diagnosed with OCD but I now understand why Zoloft is prescribed for it, and my hunch is a lot of detransitioners have OCD that never got identified. I also have ADHD, and I've cycled through explanations for feeling like the one not acting right in every group of women I've been in — queer, straight, Christian, rad fem, trans, hippie, therapists, lawyers, waitresses — first thinking it was being trans, then ADHD, then maybe a personality disorder. I have CPTSD and describe myself as a people-pleaser; I've worked in community mental health where I called DCFS about once a month. I grew up Catholic and have an obsession problem; I no longer take the Church's moral framework seriously and have strong opinions about how religion trains girls to be masochists. Detransition did real harm to my family relationships, and it's been long enough that I no longer believe they'll ever be repaired. The beginning of my relationship with my dad falling apart was an argument about whether the trans community was cult-like — my parents were fine with me detransitioning but not with me saying that, and from that argument onward the relationship unraveled. I think my parents were embarrassed by me being trans and then overwhelmed by the embarrassment when I detransitioned and kept talking about it. I've also lost friendships — both people who wanted the clout of a token trans friend and old friends who couldn't believe I wasn't a secret Republican. I've been publicly out as a detransitioner and speaking publicly was not worth it: it created stress no one in my real life could relate to, isolated me, got me condescended to, and no matter what I said the story became my trauma and how I looked. I'm still trying to heal damage from going public. I've had people who know I've been an active Democrat for decades decide I was a secret conservative. I've been courted by and worked with opportunistic organizations and regret most of the big sacrifices and burdens I took on for the detrans community, because I met lousy, unethical people with no hesitation about using others. I spoke on a panel once as a token detransitioner, driving nine hours, and afterward watched thirty supposedly supportive people treat a restaurant server terribly — the universe shouting at me to get away from those people. I've known people like Ky Schevers and Amy Dyess who flipped from "trans people are a cult" to "TERFs are a cult," and that experience is why I view venting about the trans community with real suspicion. The first detrans support group in 2014 was a beautiful time — just four of us, meeting on Fridays, eating steak and yams, laughing. Ky would call in on Zoom. That group was a saving grace during a time when it felt like suicide was the only relief I was ever going to find. I've met many detrans and trans people from orthodox and evangelical backgrounds. I went through a long period of gender dysphoric rumination after the initial detransition, but making it through the first one proved it was temporary rather than permanent. Meds for anxiety and depression have helped during those episodes; time passing has been the main help. I've also cultivated gender conformity to make earning money and completing school easier, and I'm more authentic in my gender expression now that I have more money. I've been very public about detransition and regret it. I've had my writing and photos used without permission by "allies," been talked down to, and treated as though I have a vacant brain by people with less education, less money, and worse life decisions than mine. I once drove nine hours to speak on a panel. I've had people in the detrans community screenshot and share my posts to figures like Matt Walsh. I've been attacked by trans people, TERFs, and other detransitioners. I'm wary of right-wing organizations like the ADF and helped write an open letter telling detransitioners not to work with them. I've been critical of law firms advertising on detrans forums without transparency about their political relationships, and I've pushed back on the mods about vetting processes. I'm a liberal feminist and have been an active Democrat for decades. After detransition I went "straight" — I'm attracted to men — and dated on Bumble, where I met my husband. I had to vet men carefully to see whether they could respond to my story with intelligence and empathy before disclosing; I made that mistake a couple of times before learning it was emotionally unsafe. My husband treating me as an intelligent, valuable person after I told him netted him a lot of points. I've experienced grief about homophobia I encountered as a young woman and how it affected my self-concept, complicated by the fact that I'm attracted to men. I've had exes who were women who disabused me of the idea that women make nicer partners than men. I had a partner who was super into me transitioning, which I now recognize as a controlling dynamic I've warned others about. I got pregnant about eight years after stopping T, using a fertility tracking app, and got pregnant quickly. Pregnancy and labor spiked my gender dysphoria off the charts; I formula-fed because I knew breastfeeding would leave me resenting my baby, and we're bonded af. I had a huge crisis during pregnancy about relationships built on me acting as a doormat. I have a year-old son (as of mid-2022) and stepchildren — my husband has had four kids total. I started Zoloft for postpartum depression. My periods came back immediately, about two days after a missed shot. I've said that if I could trade the experience of pregnancy for my husband's experience, yes please. I've thought seriously about whether to get a mastectomy even now — in dark moments I've brainstormed how to get a sneaky mastectomy — but I don't pursue it, partly because I won't claim to be nonbinary to make surgery easier to access. I had some laser hair removal on my face but now doubt I needed it; I shave daily with an electric dermaplaning tool. I was once grifted into CoolSculpting at a med spa. My voice kept changing after detransition — I lost upper range but have gotten a fair amount of it back. I don't pass as female in a perfectly conventional way but faces re-feminize quickly. I have a deeper voice, some extra hair, and what I call very strange trauma. I have a gender-dysphoric kid in my household — my daughter, who I allowed to socially transition in the ways she was interested in, and who is now a lesbian. Acceptance and allowing, rather than making it a fight within the family, avoided the concretizing effect of having to fight for an identity. I'm nervous that political fights over trans issues make trans identification more socially rewarding for teens. In my own household my rule is kids can socially transition before 18 but no medical stuff till they're adults. I'm wary of puberty blockers like Lupron and have solicited reports from teens who took it about bone problems for a reporter. I'm critical of pediatric medical transition being politicized, and critical of both sides — I think Republicans use it as a culture-war vote grab and that LGBT groups' pushback creates more incentives for visible trans identification. I don't think the government has business limiting parents' right to consent to transition treatment, but I also think the medicine needs far more rigorous assessment and outcome tracking. I'm critical of therapists I see as shallow or ideological, and of mental health professionals generally — I've written a post arguing that MH professionals often enable relational abuse by pushing "positive thinking" on people with abusive childhoods. I've struggled with suicidal thoughts at times — most notably a long period after detransition, and I've counseled others in crisis by sharing that I've been in dark holes myself. I've said "us suicidal people leave big bombed out craters if we complete our bad idea." I don't self-harm currently. I've used shrooms but they weren't part of my detransition realizations. I can't handle edibles. I drink rarely because it makes me overly emotional and impulsive; I've trashed my life over and over in the past. I do weightlifting, hiking, yoga, gardening, Zumba, and rowing (42.5 pounds as of late 2022). I'm a therapist by profession, though I've also warned people away from going into debt for counseling degrees. I've worked in community mental health. I'm a stay-at-home mom at present. I'm about to turn 40 (as of March 2022), so I was born around 1982. I live in rural Ohio. I'm on Zoloft. I have ADHD and CPTSD. I have a master's degree. My current identity: I'm a detransitioned woman. I don't identify as trans or nonbinary and resist pressure to call myself nonbinary. I take people's requested pronouns seriously and don't clock trans people in public, though I keep my own detransition lowkey with new people. I don't think anger at the trans community is well-placed — anger at doctors and the medical establishment is. I think trans people are generally nice and smart. I believe the most effective thing any detransitioner can do is live very well. I don't think transition is a sin or a failure. I don't believe there's anything that needs to be fixed about a person just because they went through hard things.