Todas as histórias

Trans duas vezes na infância, depois agênero por falta de opção

Mulher · Desistiu39
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher destransicionada que se identificou como trans dos 6 aos 10 anos mais ou menos, e de novo dos 12 aos 15, e que se automutilou nessa época por ódio de si mesma. Hoje não me identifico como mulher em nenhum sentido além do físico e material — diria agênero se tivesse que escolher — e sou neutra quanto a pronomes. Tive problemas de transtorno alimentar ligados à disforia de gênero, e o estresse piora os dois. Não faço terapia. Sou contra menores tomarem hormônios, mas também contra tornar isso ilegal.

História completa

I first identified as trans when I was around 6 to 10 years old, and then again from about 12 to 15. During those periods I struggled with self-harm that I traced back to self-hatred. I posted about this in December 2019, asking whether other detransitioners or desisters had self-harmed before or while identifying as trans. Around that same time I was grappling with confusion about gender more broadly. I had read a variety of extreme viewpoints from all sides of the debate about social pressures and "gender experience," and that had left me nearly convinced I was going crazy. I described being completely unable to interpret or measure questions about what it means or feels like to be male or female. I struggled to think of myself in gendered terms at all, and I didn't know how to classify myself or my feelings about gender or self-image anymore. I said I couldn't imagine myself living as either a male or a female, culturally or physically, in any sort of future, and that I couldn't relate to men, women, or people who identify as something else. I also dealt with disordered eating, which I linked to my gender dysphoria. I didn't call it an eating disorder because I don't go to therapists and didn't want to self-diagnose, but I said the feeling of hating the skin you're in and wishing to leave your body were intensely related in my experience. I noticed that stress intensified my dysphoria as well as other issues around eating and self-harm, describing a pattern where when everything in my life was chaotic I would focus on myself as the problem and how I could change myself to cope. On the question of identity after detransition, I found the term "reidentification" — the idea that I detransitioned so I could identify as a woman again — didn't fit at all. I said I certainly identified as a man at one point but I don't identify as a woman now. I don't think of myself as a "woman" in any sense other than the physical. I know I am female because that's what my body is, which by extension leads society to treat me as a woman. I am only a woman in the sense that I am an adult female human, which is my material reality, and not an identity. I relate to other women only in the sense that we are fellow women generally treated by society in the same way, with common experiences. Because of this I said I am not beholden to anyone or anything — I accept that I am a woman but that doesn't bear on how I choose to act, dress, or be attracted to. I described myself as pronoun neutral and said I don't care if people call me "he" or "they" because that doesn't affect my female-ness. I also said I love the word "wamen" and feel very connected to it, and that I guess I'd identify as agender if I had to. But I thought politically rejecting that concept gets people asking questions, leading to deeper conversations and hopefully making people question some of the orthodoxy. I told the person I was responding to that they definitely hadn't lost their mind, and that there's no easy way to exist in this world for anyone, let alone someone who doesn't conform to expectations about their sex. I hoped they could find a therapist they felt more open talking about gender dysphoria with, but I hesitated to give advice. My advice was essentially to do what will make you happy — you only have one life to live, and if you know you'll be happier taking HRT, socially transitioning, or being a gender-nonconforming person, you have only yourself to answer to and should never let anyone else, whether Reddit or a therapist, have any bearing on you. On the question of minors and hormones, I said minors shouldn't be allowed to take hormones, but that at the end of the day we only have one life to live and they shouldn't be ILLEGAL — because that's how you get people hurting themselves with shady stuff over the internet or going to Thailand where there's even fewer regulations. When someone compared it to prohibition, I agreed, saying that's working really well, no one ever smokes weed or heroin. In another exchange I said "We all thought we were trans at some point and my gender dysphoria has ZERO to do with murder," and separately, "None of that has anything to do with hormones." I don't go to therapists, for better or worse. I don't describe any medical transition interventions — no hormones, surgeries, or puberty blockers are mentioned in my posts.