Todas as histórias

Uma aula na faculdade, um despertar espiritual e nenhum arrependimento médico

Homem · Desistiu93
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou um homem desistente que se identificou como trans MTF e depois como não binário por volta de 2018, mas nunca tomou hormônios nem fez cirurgia. Um despertar espiritual em 2018, uma aula na faculdade com uma professora feminista radical e a exploração do pensamento crítico de gênero me levaram a redefinir 'homem' de forma puramente biológica e a me sentir à vontade como homem. Tive tendências autoginefílicas enraizadas numa visão hipersexualizada das mulheres, que foram diminuindo conforme fui me sentindo mais à vontade no meu corpo masculino. Hoje me identifico como homem e desistente, e defendo o pensamento crítico sobre normas de gênero e questionar, em vez de afirmar incondicionalmente, quem pensa em transicionar. Não tenho arrependimentos médicos, já que nunca transicionei fisicamente.

História completa

I was born male and first started feeling dysphoria around 2017-2018, when I began identifying as an MTF trans person. I never took hormones or had any surgeries — I was wary of medical transition because I didn't like the idea of depending on something external for the rest of my life, and I questioned what 'wound' HRT was actually healing. I also never experienced genital dysphoria; I was always fine with my penis, just unhappy with how my body was shaped by my sex. In 2018 I had what I describe as a spiritual awakening, which led to a big shift in my development and made me care more about improving my mental state. Shortly after that I desisted for the first time, though looking back I think I did it for the wrong reasons — I concluded I could never pass, so I tried to drown out the dysphoria and started acting more masculine, thinking that was my 'natural self.' A few months later those defenses crumbled. My new outlook from the awakening and re-adopted trans ideology blended oddly; I liked the idea that I didn't need to change my appearance to be a 'valid transgirl,' since it felt like body positivity. A few months after that I identified as non-binary, out of fear the trans label was limiting me. I liked it for a while, but I became critical of other non-binary people turning to hormones for small mood-satisfying changes, which I felt insulted their natural selves. Around that time I started exploring gender-critical spaces on Reddit. I had previously posted in the detrans sub for transition advice and got thought-provoking replies about the definitions of man and woman. Returning and receiving similar replies pushed me to examine what I actually thought men and women were. Exploring gender-critical thought let me stop using 'man' and 'woman' as personality descriptors and use them only as biological ones — for me, 'man' came to mean simply 'person with a penis.' That reframing is what finally let me feel comfortable being a man. About a couple of months before desisting, I took a college English class taught by a radical feminist instructor who introduced me to critical thinking about sex and media — concepts like the male gaze and the happy housewife heroine, and we watched the documentary The Mask You Live In. I also read articles arguing that words like 'man' and 'woman' only need to denote genitalia, not associated gender expectations. Sexually, I now describe myself as a male desister who had many autogynephilic tendencies. I believe I developed autogynephilia because of an oversexualized perception of women — I used to think of women as 'sexy caricatures of the normal humans that were men.' I also had a sexual/aesthetic component to my transition desires: I wanted to be beautiful and thought I'd make an ugly man, partly fueled by media depictions of women as beautiful and men as bland. Since viewing women in a less sexual light and becoming more comfortable in my male body, the idea of having a female body is far less alluring and carries no real sexual interest anymore. I don't believe autogynephilia is a static aspect of sexuality. I don't recall any formal diagnoses, hospitalizations, or medication for mental health. I don't describe therapy as having helped or hurt me directly, but I've noted that many detransitioners had therapists or loved ones who didn't challenge them enough about transitioning 'under the guise of unconditional acceptance,' which propelled some to physical changes they regret. I have no regrets about medical changes because I never made any. I don't describe family rejection or support, relationships, or isolation in detail. I did engage in extensive online discussion in gender-critical and detrans communities, including advising others to read r/GenderCritical and r/GenderCriticalGuys (while criticizing the latter for being mostly anti-trans rather than addressing why men would want to transition). I also recommended reading about feminism and understanding radical feminist perspectives before labeling oneself a woman. Currently I identify as a man and a desister (not detransitioned, since I never medically transitioned). I feel I can let my true self shine without dissociating from my body or distorting my view of biology. I advocate for critical, college-level thinking about gender norms, understanding the difference between sex and gender, and for people to be challenged in their transition decisions rather than unconditionally affirmed. I also advocate for loving and respecting one's body as it is, and for eradicating sexism and social conditioning.