Todas as histórias

Três anos de T, sem arrependimento, e ainda butch

Mulher · DestransicionouPrimeira disforia 15 → Transição 21 → Destransição 24556
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher destransicionada — uma lésbica butch/masc de 24 anos que se assumiu trans aos 20, começou a testosterona aos 21, viveu em stealth por cerca de três anos e começou a reduzir a T em 2020 por motivos de saúde, mantendo meu nome e a maior parte da minha apresentação masculina. Não me arrependo nem um pouco da transição; vejo-a como inevitável e digo que ela me deu a liberdade de me descobrir, mas percebi que meu “fracasso” em me conformar à feminilidade nunca me desqualificou de ser mulher. O que me moveu foi questionar internamente a perda da irmandade, o medo da atenção de homens héteros e de ser lésbica, e a constatação de que o gênero é uma construção social e não uma identidade que eu realmente tinha. Ainda sinto disforia de gênero de verdade e medo de ser percebida como mulher, mas estou em paz com ser mulher e não pretendo desfazer quase nada. Apoio a liberdade dos adultos de transicionar, acreditando que a transição médica vitalícia beneficia relativamente poucas pessoas, e já pensei em fazer um vídeo de destransição para pessoas racializadas (POC), mas ainda não fiz.

História completa

I was born female and I'm 24 years old. I first started serious gender questioning around age 15, came out officially as trans at 20, and started testosterone at 21 — I've been on T for a little over three years now, mostly living stealth as a man with my name and gender marker changed. I went the informed consent route for hormones at a clinic; I did see a counselor about gender, sexuality, and other personal issues, but that was separate from the HRT process. I genuinely believed I was a man, both before and during transition — I described having 'life threatening dysphoria' and said I felt like if I didn't start testosterone I would actually kill myself, and I don't doubt I was in danger because I really felt that way. Looking in the mirror I'd feel extremely uncomfortable, like something was wrong, a major disconnect, and I didn't find relief until I went on T. When I started passing more I felt like I was recognizing myself, like it was who I was 'supposed to be.' Transition genuinely improved my life: my mental health issues subsided, my dysphoria became manageable, and I greatly enjoyed life as a man. I was free to be hairy, have messy hair, throw out makeup, let my facial hair grow, wear comfortable clothes, walk around without being harassed, and be my natural witty self. I enjoyed the muscles, the bottom growth, and no longer having triple D breasts. I was not abused as a child and I didn't experience childhood sexual assault. I did experience sexual assault, but it occurred after I started thinking about transition and after years of dysphoria, so I don't believe it caused my transition. I also don't believe I had body dysmorphia. What I now understand is that a big part of my transition was fear of straight male attention and fear of being a lesbian. I'd been followed by a stranger in a van who catcalled my friend and me for several blocks and around corners. I'd said to friends things like I'd be interested in sleeping with women but not having a relationship with one because of negative stereotypes — typical 'straight guy' complaints about dating women — and later realized how openly women-hating that was. I recognized internalized misogyny in myself, but only after the fact. I thought I was bi my entire life with a preference for men when I was trans; now I call myself a butch or masc-of-center lesbian. What moved me toward detransition was a slow accumulation of internal questions, not outside pressure — all the yelling and mocking from cis or non-detrans people never contributed to my realization, it was only my internal questioning. Small questions about gender slowly piled up until I felt I had to sit with them and answer them within myself. A key nagging feeling was a sense of loss over no longer being 'allowed' to share my view on, connect with, or converse about being a woman just because I'd transitioned. It bothered me that I couldn't connect with women the same way, that being with a straight woman or being seen as heterosexual with women bothered me, and that my childhood as a girl felt negated. I loved the newfound brotherhood but felt awful about losing my sisterhood. I also started to fear becoming an old man. The central question that unraveled everything was: does my 'failure' to conform to typical womanhood disqualify me from being female, and why would that qualify me to be male? I realized gender isn't real — I'd thought gender must be real because otherwise why would I have gender dysphoria — and once that fell apart, the logic I'd built to justify being a man collapsed. I realized I can be exactly who I am and be a woman. My process: I admitted to myself maybe a week before my first long post that I don't think I'm trans, after thinking about it for a few months and more seriously in the past few weeks. I started by sitting with myself and asking what I was feeling and why I was afraid to probe those feelings. Then I searched 'detransition,' 'detransitioner,' and ftmtf hashtags on Tumblr, encountering viewpoints I didn't agree with but keeping reading. I watched YouTube videos titled things like 'Why I Detransitioned' and 'I'm Not Trans Anymore,' looking only for individuals with my birth sex, not organizations with agendas. Journaling was probably one of the more important steps — just me, paper, and a pen on my porch, being honest without anyone else's opinions. I talked to friends who listened without giving opinions or advice. Then I found community, which is where I was at by the time I found this sub — I actually only discovered the sub after making up my mind. I started detransition during lockdown, and quarantine gave me privacy from the larger world to think. I'm currently weaning off testosterone, with my last shot probably a couple months away, but I'm stopping only for health reasons — fear of ovarian cysts and potential ovarian and uterine problems after some years on T, plus uncertainty about whether I'll get internal organs removed. I don't plan to change my name back — I never liked my previous name and it felt far too feminine; I chose an ambiguously gendered name and a male middle name I like. I haven't told my parents or family any time soon; I've told my sister and close friends. I still pass as male depending on my hair, whether I've shaved, or my outfit, and I live as male to everyone I haven't told. I might change my gender marker back eventually. I never got my birth certificate changed; my gender marker change only required a letter from my HRT doctor. Medical history beyond hormones: I had naturally large breasts with a hefty size difference between the sides, and I got implants to correct that. I wore a binder the entire time I had the implants, binding 12+ hours, which destroyed my breast tissue. I panicked pretty quickly after getting the implants but made some peace when they dropped. I eventually had them removed almost two years ago — out of pocket, cheaper than getting them in, under local anesthesia while awake. After removal I now have AA cups; my surgeon said it was the combination of binding and implants. Breathing became painful and I'd become faint often, which I attributed to abusing my binder. I have a very noticeable peri scar on one areola, double incisions under both breasts, plus two horizontal scars on the sides. I still have a pretty flat chest and said I'd still get top surgery if I had the money, and I'm not opposed to keyhole if they get bigger. I used to want bottom surgery but knew it was unlikely; I've made some peace with my vulva though not fully with the internal organs. I gave myself a haircut because I was looking too female and it made me physically sick — I still have dysphoria and likely will for a long time. Mental health: I had 'many mental health issues' that subsided after starting T. I don't describe a specific diagnosis. I don't experience suicidal ideation now; I described the pre-T period as feeling like I'd kill myself without hormones. I do experience guilt and embarrassment about things I said and did during transition, 'like a similar feeling to leaving a religion,' but no real doubts about detransitioning. Family: my parents are fine with me being gender non-conforming but think being trans is a sin; when I came out my mom asked why I can't just be a masculine woman. My culture (I'm Hispanic, part Dominican, and visibly brown — darker now because of testosterone) played a big part in family reaction to coming out. I went through similar racism before and after transition. I briefly attended fashion school and have always made my own clothes. I have no regrets about my transition or testosterone — I see it as almost inevitable and I'm extremely glad I did what I felt was necessary to survive. The only thing that bothers me is how tiresome and shameful it will feel to change my gender marker back. I'd say I'm a stone butch or butch/masc-of-center lesbian, though I don't like calling myself a woman — just female. I'm comfortable with he/she pronouns and my current name. I don't like being perceived at all and I 'let pronouns happen to me.' I don't want straight male attention and the thought of being in a relationship with or having sex with a man disgusts me, so I go by that. On transition for others: I'm not interested in preventing anyone from transitioning, and I believe adults should have the freedom to make that serious decision, but I think it's pretty rare the number of people who would benefit from lifelong transition. I think gender is fake — 100% there is no man or woman — but it has real-world consequences, so some people benefit from transitioning; I believe trans people are 'real' and that I was 'truly trans' by that logic. I think if society were more accepting of people wearing and doing what they wanted without gender, there would be no need to medically transition because no one would develop gender dysphoria. I think it's a societal failing, not a moral, ethical, spiritual, or mental one. I wish when I was 15 someone had told me it's normal for women and girls to experience gender dysphoria, that other 'trans' people can be wrong about being trans too, and that failing at girlhood doesn't disqualify you from being female. I've thought about making a detransition video/YouTube channel as a person of color since there's very little POC detrans content, but I haven't yet because everyone is home and I need to film alone. I also discussed medical discrimination against trans people, worried about protections being removed, and I noted that when I got my gender marker changed, a state worker said they get hundreds of requests per day or week, which stunned me.