Todas as histórias

Uma leitura sobre narcisismo, e depois largar o gênero de vez

Homem · Desistiu1,7 mil
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Nasci homem, desisti de uma transição com identificação masculina antes de completar 30 anos e hoje me identifico como uma pessoa detransicionada e de gênero não conforme, casada com uma esposa. Uma leitura sobre o narcisismo como 'uma falha em se autoidentificar' me causou um ataque de pânico e reenquadrou minha disforia como um esconder-me de mim mesmo, e não como a reivindicação da feminilidade; viagens psicodélicas também me empurraram de volta aos meus problemas originais não resolvidos. Hoje não penso em termos de gênero, descrevendo a mim e à minha esposa como 'dois seres humanos queer e ambivalentes quanto ao gênero'. Tenho opiniões fortemente críticas sobre a transição de outras pessoas, descrevendo-a como impossível, narcisista e semelhante a 'masturbação prolongada', e argumento ativamente contra ela online, ao mesmo tempo que defendo o acesso dos detransicionadores às próprias histórias. Não relato detalhes médicos nem ideação suicida e me descrevo como bem equilibrado graças a bons amigos, relacionamentos saudáveis e tempo longe da internet.

História completa

I desisted from a male-identified transition and now write about it from a firmly critical, gender-critical perspective. I was born male. My earliest dysphoric memory I now describe as 'magical fantasy' — something I look back on and simply regard as fantasy. I don't give a precise age for when the dysphoria started, but I know it persisted into adulthood. The turning point came as I was approaching 30: I read material about narcissism and identity that gave me 'a little mini panic attack' and forced me to reevaluate myself. I had been convinced I was 'the main character of life,' so anything I wanted was automatically justified. Someone had to tell me repeatedly: 'You are not special. What you do can be special. But who you are is just a body.' That reframing changed everything. I realized I had not been 'claiming femininity' but was 'narcissistically hiding in the behaviors of someone I liked because I couldn't stand myself.' I came to believe that loving the body you have creates a self-appreciation no one else's body could replace. Now I don't think in gendered terms at all — 'I am what I do,' some of it masculine, some feminine, and I'm not defined by anything besides my actions. I also credit psychedelic experiences: 'Hell yeah shroom trips!' — I noted that mushrooms took me back to the original problems I had been trying to escape, and I wished those problems would look smaller on reexamination. I've said the first time I heard about autogynephilia 'had a big effect on me,' and that being trans is 'fundamentally defined by its impossibility.' I compare gender dysphoria to 'oneitis': if you keep focusing on it, it destroys you; if you move on, you forget about it. I describe myself as lucky: 'I was lucky enough to have good friends and healthy relationships and enough time spent offline that I ended up well-balanced. But I could have just as easily ended up one of these terminally online types with nothing to live for but the next jerkoff session.' I have a wife, and I describe our relationship as being about 'who we are as two queer, gender ambivalent human beings than man/woman.' Since desisting and leaving those circles, the only time I consciously think about gender roles is when people use gender stereotypes as insults — which makes me wonder how much playground taunting shaped self-perception. I don't describe specific medical interventions, surgeries, or hormone use in this transcript, so I leave those details out. I do discuss transition medicine in the abstract: I argue HRT doesn't change biological sex, that even the best SRS produces 'a non-functioning simulacrum,' and that the medical industry's informed-consent model lets doctors 'claim no liability' while trans communities suppress evidence of regret. I've said that critics of detransitioners 'knew the risks' rhetoric coexists with efforts to 'eliminate any evidence online anywhere of risks, regret, or bad results.' I hold strongly critical views of transition for others. I describe being trans as 'a form of extended masturbation,' say I feel sympathy only comparable to what I'd extend to anyone oversharing sexual kinks, and say that hearing persecution claims from trans people makes me angry because they 'failed to be honest with themselves and have basically succumbed to their addictions.' I became 'a stronger feminist' through observing how transbians talk over women, calling it 'the last desperate gasp of white male entitlement' and 'the final boss of privilege.' I'm critical of non-binary identification as 'self-othering,' critical of both conservatives ('fucking morons') and progressives ('mainstreaming quasi-religious woo'), and skeptical of the chemical-imbalance theory of depression and of pharmaceutical framing of mental health. I've been active in online discussions defending detransitioners and criticizing moderation that bans 'even factually true statements if they potentially cause discomfort.' I don't describe any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or mental health diagnoses of my own in this material.