Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.
No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.
Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.
Resumo
Sou terapeuta e entrei no r/detrans no início de 2024 para aprender com as experiências dos membros, a fim de aconselhar melhor as pessoas com quem trabalho; eu mesma não destransicionei. Tornei-me crítica do modelo só afirmativo, acreditando que trauma, ansiedade, depressão e questões corporais às vezes são identificados erroneamente como disforia de gênero e que é preciso muito mais exploração antes da transição. Considero negligência não explicar os riscos e complicações e soube que alguns prestadores viram as reclamações contra os próprios pacientes. Aconselho quem busca terapia a entrevistar os possíveis terapeutas sobre sua abordagem, já que um terapeuta afirmativo de gênero pode empurrar a continuação da testosterona, enquanto um mais abrangente exploraria mais opções. Acredito em respeitar as diferenças dentro dos gêneros sem tratá-las como problemas a serem corrigidos.
História completa
I am a therapist who came to the r/detrans community in early 2024 to learn from people's experiences in order to better assist the people I work with. I have not detransitioned myself; my account is that of a counseling professional seeking to understand detransition and the failures of the current care model.
I began by asking the community what factors were most important in their decision to detransition, what they wish they had known before transitioning, and what they wish therapists knew, asked, or cared about. In response I shared what I was learning: that the affirm-only model is being pushed as the only way forward, and that I was confused about why no one will listen to other options. I noted that this issue has been presented differently than anything else in the mental health world and that it needs much more discussion.
Across many conversations I expressed anger that side effects and negative complications are not really discussed with patients, and I encouraged people to be super honest with their doctors and to find a PTSD therapist who would not make things worse, even suggesting the 988 crisis line when someone was struggling. I observed a contradiction in the field: providers say you can just get implants, which seems to imply people might regret their decision, yet there is denial that people regret it. I repeatedly asked people when their gender dysphoria began and whether trauma or abuse played a role, believing that anxiety, depression, body issues, or other problems are sometimes led to believe they are gender dysphoria and that so much needs to be explored before that determination is made.
I came to believe that some people truly have gender dysphoria while others have other issues, and that no one treatment works for everyone, just as with depression or anxiety. I voiced concern about a big push against womanhood and femininity, and I said I believe it is important to honor the way we were created and allow for differences within our genders without making it a problem to be fixed — more feminine males and more masculine females are ok. I also observed that many therapists know in their hearts what people have said about behaviors but are afraid to say it in today's environment.
I posted a second round of questions asking what made people realize the path they were on was not right for them, and whether they went back to their providers to voice complaints or just moved on. I was disheartened and angered that those who pledge to do no harm seem to be very careless with so many people, and I called the failure to explain risks and complications malpractice. I acknowledged that doctors are often busy, rely on journals and professional societies rather than reading research themselves, and that small numbers of people push big ideas that are supposed to cover everyone but do not seem based on evidence. I suggested that going back to a doctor to explain one's experience could be an opportunity to educate them, while recognizing that takes courage and must be the right thing for that person's journey.
I posted a third thread asking whether anyone had gone back to a provider after being unhappy and received a good, caring response, and whether anyone had seen any change in how providers approach gender dysphoria. I had heard from a few people that the therapist or doctor turned it on them, either not knowing how to help or not wanting to acknowledge that a different path might have been explored.
In April 2024 I offered direct counseling advice to someone considering therapy, cautioning that a 'gender affirming therapist' may say more to encourage you to stay on testosterone, whereas a therapist with a more comprehensive look at your history and issues may explore many more options. I advised interviewing or researching a potential therapist's views and approach, and not hesitating to change therapists if it is not a good fit, because the most important thing is that you click with your therapist. I also told people to interview therapists, saying a good therapist will not be threatened by that, and to make sure they are willing to work on your goals rather than make them up for you.
I have not described any personal transition, detransition, medical interventions, or mental health diagnoses of my own. My engagement is professional and educational: collecting information and understanding so that everyone becomes more and more aware of all the aspects of the choices before them.