Todas as histórias

Quatro anos de receitas de T, nenhuma tomada

Mulher · DesistiuPrimeira disforia 17 → Transição social 18 → Desistência 2312 mil
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma mulher desistente que se identificou como trans (FTM) por cerca de quatro anos na faculdade, mais ou menos dos 18 aos 22, consegui uma receita de testosterona mas nunca a tomei, e desisti por volta dos 23. Hoje me identifico como mulher cisgênero bissexual, casada e com dois filhos, e não acredito mais que a identidade transgênero seja logicamente válida. Sinto muita culpa porque meus dois irmãos mais novos se assumiram trans depois de mim e não consigo ser honesta com eles sobre minhas preocupações por medo de ser cortada da vida deles. Minha saúde mental melhorou muito desde que desisti, embora tenha lidado com alcoolismo e siga em terapia. Sou grata por nunca ter feito a transição médica e em grande parte fiz as pazes com a experiência, embora me sinta isolada porque só posso falar abertamente das minhas opiniões em espaços detrans.

História completa

I identified as trans (FTM) for about four years, roughly from age 18 to 22 or 23, beginning around 2011-2012 during college. My dysphoria started around age 17-18, though I was uncomfortable with my body for a couple of years before that. I presented as male whenever possible, used he/him pronouns, wore a binder regularly for a few years, and trained my voice lower through singing (I sang tenor in my college choir). I came out to my family as FTM; my parents were supportive, my mom helped me find a doctor, and I got a prescription for testosterone gel around age 19. I even had it filled, but I never started taking it — I kept the tub of T gel in a drawer for over a year (in one place I say two years, in another, four years) because I was scared of unknown and permanent side effects. Eventually I realized I didn't want to transition. I desisted around age 23, around 2015-2016, timing it with leaving (dropping out of) college, moving back home, and taking a retail job where I let people assume I was a woman. I never formally announced my detransition; I just quietly started living as female. I later joined the Army and moved across the country, building a whole new social circle that never knew me as trans. I'm now a desisted/detrans woman in my late 20s (I mentioned being 26 in early 2020 and 27 in mid-2020, and being the same age as a 27-year-old correspondent in 2021, so I was born around 1993). I'm bisexual (with a slight-to-moderate preference for men), married to a straight man since around 2016, and I have two children (first child around 2020, second around 2022). I'm currently a premed student and also a soldier in the Army. Several factors contributed to my identifying as trans. I was a nerdy, socially isolated, lonely child who never fit in with other girls and was bullied. I had childhood OCD, social anxiety, took SSRIs (sertraline) for about four years during my teens, and went through a period of depression before identifying as trans. My OCD manifested as 'nothing feeling right' and overanalyzing my mental state to decide if I 'felt like a girl' — and since I couldn't identify any part of me that felt like a girl, and I was exposed to explanations of transness as 'feeling like another gender,' I concluded I must be a boy. I was raised in a sexually repressed household that disparaged female sexuality; my parents emphasized accomplishments and character but discouraged makeup and made negative comments about women dressing or acting 'sexy,' which I internalized as shame about femininity and female sexuality. I also consumed a lot of male/male slash fanfiction as a teenager, and I think my sexuality developed while I was mentally placing myself in a male role, which contributed to dysphoria. I believed I was asexual as a teenager. I was also drawn to the trans community because it offered an automatic community and sense of belonging. I had internalized misogyny — not violent or hateful, but shame and a desire to distance myself from being seen as attractive or sexual. I also experienced a sexual assault at some point. What moved me toward desisting: time, gaining confidence in my body through working out and getting stronger (I took a military fitness class in college and got in shape to join the Army), sexual confidence in a long-term relationship with my girlfriend (a bi woman) during college, and spending time in social groups that weren't trans-heavy. My girlfriend's acceptance of me doing feminine things while identifying as a trans man eroded my dysphoria — I found myself more open to dresses and makeup, and eventually started to like my body and presenting as female. The biggest intellectual shift was questioning what it means to 'feel like' a man or woman — I realized there's no feeling all women have that no men have, and that gender outside of sex is just stereotypes and socialization. I also became disillusioned with the trans community after being viciously attacked on tumblr (while still identifying as trans) for observing that trans men and trans women behave differently, possibly due to sex-based socialization — I was called transmisogynistic and received hundreds of hateful messages. That was my first taste of the community's intolerance of dissent. Medically, I never took hormones and never had surgery, so I'm technically a 'desister' rather than a detransitioner in the strict sense. I did bind for years. I experienced SSRI-related sexual dysfunction (lack of desire/physical pleasure) that I initially attributed to dysphoria, and I'm somewhat upset I wasn't informed of the risks of long-term SSRI use. I also had body image/dysmorphia issues as a teenager and young adult. Mental health: childhood OCD, social anxiety, depression (about a year) before identifying as trans, and SSRIs for about four years in high school (I stopped because they felt like they were 'flattening out' my emotions). Since desisting, my mental health has gotten 'way better.' I've dealt with alcoholism (I described myself as both detrans and an alcoholic, working through a recovery program), and I'm currently in therapy with a therapist I feel actually understands me. I've also mentioned depression recently and climbing out of it. Adversity: social isolation and bullying in childhood, a sexually repressed/conservative upbringing, sexual assault, and the experience of being vilified by the trans community. Socially: my family was supportive of my trans identification (my mom found me the endocrinologist). However, both of my younger siblings came out as trans after I did — my older sibling (originally my little sister) as a non-binary transmasculine person who's been stable in that identity for years and takes hormones, and my younger sibling (originally my little brother) as a trans girl who started HRT. I feel intense guilt and responsibility, believing my influence played a large part in their trans identification and that social contagion was involved. I cannot be honest with them about my opinions on gender for fear of being cut off, which creates a painful 'chasm' in our relationship. My siblings are now 25 and 22 (as of mid-2023), and I worry about them — one struggles to hold a job or go to school and seems entirely consumed by the political aspect of transness. I also lost touch with college friends who knew me as male when I detransitioned. Sexuality: I identified as asexual as a teenager, then bisexual in college after a relationship with a girlfriend. I was more comfortable in a same-sex relationship while identifying as trans because straight relationships felt alien and laden with gender roles. After desisting, I became comfortable with straight relationships and straight sex. I'm now married to a man. Regret: I don't have intense regret about medical changes since I never medically transitioned. I'm extremely grateful I never took the testosterone. I do feel guilt about my siblings and some regret about lost time and social losses (losing college friends). Overall my regret is mild and I've largely made peace with it — I've said I can find value in the experience because it taught me about gender roles and the theoretical basis of transness. Over time, my feelings have stabilized into acceptance. Outcomes: I'm now a happy married woman with a stable career, a house, two kids, and I'm going back to school/premed. I've said I'm 'more stable and happy than I've ever been' and that gender plays 'zero part' in my daily life. I still feel isolated sometimes because no one in my real life fully understands my experiences, and I mostly only discuss gender openly on the detrans subreddit. Attitudes: I'm gender critical and no longer believe transgender identity is logically valid — I don't think a male can be a woman or a female can be a man, and I think 'feeling like a man/woman' is meaningless. I support adults' bodily autonomy to transition if they want, but I oppose giving minors hormones or surgery, and I'm critical of 'egg' culture, ROGD/social contagion, and the trans community's intolerance of dissent. I've advocated for detrans visibility — I created the subreddit r/detransparents, posted a detrans meetup form, participated in detrans research surveys, made a video about gender, and I'm active in detrans online communities. I consider myself a feminist and moderate politically.