Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.
No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.
Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.
Resumo
Sou um homem bissexual feminino destransicionado (ou voltando atrás) que comentou no r/detrans entre 2019 e 2020, embora não tenha compartilhado as datas nem os detalhes médicos da minha própria transição. Passei boa parte do tempo sem querer viver, mas não descrevi tentativas, e concentrei minha escrita em criticar a bifobia, o “apagamento butch” e a ideia de que o gênero é opcional ou puramente pessoal, e não social. Também incentivei outros membros da comunidade que enfrentam pensamentos suicidas e insegurança física e profissional. Não expressei nestes comentários um arrependimento explícito da transição em si.
História completa
I have never posted a standalone thread; everything I've shared has been comments in the r/detrans community between June 2019 and July 2020.
I have identified as a bisexual man and, from what I've written, I appear to have transitioned to male at some point before 2019 — I don't give dates for coming out, hormones, or surgeries anywhere in this transcript, so I can't lay out that timeline. What I can say is that by mid-2019 I was living as a feminine, long-haired, bisexual man and was confident enough in that identity to reject what I saw as pressure to conform.
My views on gender and sexuality have been the through-line of everything I've written. In June 2019 I said plainly that "It's hard not to loathe the LGT 'community' at pride as a bisexual," which tells me I'd experienced biphobia inside queer spaces and felt alienated from them. In July 2019 I pointed to "butch erasure" in queer and women's communities, particularly butch women's communities, arguing it had been happening for years — I framed this as a pattern of women being pushed out of womanhood. In December 2019 I suggested that a lot of "the push for trans comes from simple homophobia," and that some people have internalized homophobia so deeply they can't imagine being gay even when they don't desire the opposite sex. In March 2020 I argued that gender is not "opt-in": "Nobody chooses to come into this particular world with these particular hang ups about sex groups. We are taught everything about gender, it doesn't exist in our skull lumps or in our brains, it exists in our society." I concluded that believing you can change gender without changing society "is an illusion that usually hurts people."
I've been open about my own mental health. In June 2019 I told someone, "I don't want to live a lot of the time," which indicates recurring suicidal ideation, though I didn't describe any attempts or a diagnosis. In the same exchange I was blunt but compassionate with another person who had attempted suicide using fentanyl, telling them there were "better and nobler ways to leave this world" and hoping they would "retake agency over [their] own life." I also acknowledged painful things others had done to me indirectly by expressing sympathy for what "your parents and so many other people did to you."
In April 2020 I wrote at length to another detransition community member who seemed to be struggling with feeling physically weaker than men and doubting their career success. I drew on my own experience, saying "so many of my own negative thoughts are about what I see as my career failures even though I have also been in very objectively good places," and I noted that "for the ambitious, an objective victory can still be a subjective defeat." I pushed back on their framing — "I am weaker than most men, so I am objectively weak" — as too narrow, compared it to assuming technology and armor win every war, and urged them to study John Boyd's strategic work, referencing cheng and chi and arguing that no warrior is ever guaranteed to be stronger than their enemy. I told them I could see they had "an incredibly strong personal will" and believed they had the moral strength to keep fighting. In a follow-up I said there were people of both sexes who would find their strength, ambition, and drive attractive regardless of appearance.
In July 2020 I responded to a woman describing biphobic exclusion by saying I was "so fucking glad by the time this shit was widespread I was confident enough as a feminine bisexual man that I knew it was bullshit," and I expressed fear for "the smooth-faced long-haired angels of the future being erased from manhood," hoping they could still learn enough feminism to know what's real.
I haven't described a formal detransition process, a specific date of detransition, surgeries, hormone use, fertility concerns, medical complications, diagnoses, therapy experiences, family reactions, or a current relationship status beyond what's implied above. I also haven't expressed explicit regret about transition itself in these comments — my energy has gone into critiquing how gender and sexuality are policed, both in queer communities and in trans-adjacent discourse, and into encouraging others. I haven't done any formal advocacy or activism that I've mentioned.
My sexuality as I've described it is bisexual with an attraction to women; I've written approvingly of a woman married to a man who shares her attraction to women, and I've identified myself as a feminine bisexual man. I don't have anything in this transcript about internalized homophobia in my own case — I've raised it as a phenomenon in others.