Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.
No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.
Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.
História completa
I was born female and for the past 2-3 years (as of my first post in August 2023) I had been identifying as agender/nonbinary/transmasc. Before any medical steps I gave myself a neutral name that I still prefer day to day, cut my short instead of getting it braided, bought chest binders, and switched to loose, oversized clothing to hide my figure. I did a lot of research into hormones, looking into pros, cons, and expected changes, before making a consultation appointment with Planned Parenthood, and I started testosterone 'stealthy' the year before that post.
My initial goal in starting T was not to pass as male necessarily. In my head I wanted a confusing presentation, a mishmash of masculine and feminine qualities so people couldn't tell whether to ma'am or sir me. I told myself I didn't plan to be on T for life and would find a place to stop once I was satisfied, and then perhaps pursue top surgery, since one of the biggest areas of my dysphoria was my chest.
I started at a 0.2 mL dosage and increased to 0.3 mL after about 6 months. I used 3 mL syringes for my injections. The changes weren't too obvious to those around me. My voice became slightly different, not quite male-passing but 'off' for someone perceived female, what I described as a typical 'frog' vocal fry voice. I sometimes got sir'd by strangers or assumed to be MtF because of it. I also grew body hair more frequently, which I'm not a fan of but manage. I kept getting periods regularly even on T.
By August 2023, roughly a year and 3 months on T, I realized I was still ultimately seen as female no matter what I did or how I dressed. I know it's physically impossible to truly 'pass' as nonbinary, and I said I was really just nonbinary to myself because realistically no one sees it as a legitimate thing. I told myself I'd rather be mistaken for a man than a woman, even if neither felt right, but by then I wasn't sure what I wanted out of the transition. T wasn't going to make me an androgynous-looking pretty boy, and I didn't want to be seen as a tomboyish/butch woman either. It's hard for me to call myself a 'woman' but I can easily say I'm female without an issue. I can't really relate to the concept of womanhood or manhood, socially or physically, and felt perpetually stuck in 'gender limbo.'
Part of me said I should stop T because the goal was unattainable, but I didn't want to right then. I kept telling myself I'd stop when my voice was deep enough, yet I was fairly neutral about the changes. I didn't really feel euphoric, just meh or unsure. Thoughts of top surgery flip-flopped: I initially wanted a full double mastectomy, then asked if I could compromise with a reduction to a smaller cup size. I wouldn't hate being fully flat but the chest scars made me rethink it, and a reduction made me fear they'd grow again since fat tissue would remain.
I did stop taking T for a couple of weeks at one point and it made me feel off not doing my weekly shots. Later I stopped for a whole month and not much changed in terms of mood, but I 'felt like shit' when I wasn't on it. My dose was so low I didn't even have enough to be in the normal male range, and I felt it would be all for nothing if I dropped everything cold turkey. I had a therapist but was holding off on sessions due to financial issues.
I described pre-T behavior as very obsessively trying to mask my physique as much as possible. I would physically flinch whenever I was still gendered as a woman no matter how much I bound or layered my clothes. If it wasn't how I dressed, I'd worry about how I acted, talked, walked, my face, and conclude my face and body shape would always give me away. When I was finally prescribed T, I started doing this less and gave up, letting others assume what they wanted. By then I was about 50/50 ma'ams or sirs, or people would just ask my pronouns. I still avoided dressing in a way that drew attention to my body and only occasionally bound rather than every day. I don't particularly love it but don't inherently hate it either. I worried slightly about confrontations in public if clocked more as a guy, since according to people around me my appearance and voice aren't quite typical for a female.
I disliked my physical traits before starting T; that was part of why I wanted it, to make them less obvious. I don't like physically having traits associated with the female body: breasts, narrow shoulders, wider hips, higher/lighter pitched voice. I sort of envy some traits men have: deeper voice, broader shoulders, narrow hips. I'm not unhappy with gender roles or expectations about partners; I'm very stereotypically feminine and only moderately masculine, and I don't associate those things with one sex. I don't really date and don't find myself attracted to anyone romantically or sexually as of that writing, and I've never dated at all, preferring strictly platonic relationships.
I asked myself a question I also pose to other females transitioning non-binary-ly: 'if you were born male and socialized as a man, would you still be nonbinary or ever thought of medical transition in the first place?' I honestly can't answer that.
In November 2023 I posted recordings of my singing voice, hating how it sounded, saying I could hardly sing properly and that the 'frog voice' was apparent. I'd been on T about a year and a half, having skipped a few weeks and gone on and off. I figured if I kept taking it my voice would deepen enough to sound less like that, but after seeing a post on how T affects the vocal tract from a detrans woman, I learned that the vocal cords expanding in a short amount of time is what causes the typical trans guy voice. Had I known that, I would have wanted to stay at a smaller dosage longer, and I was conflicted about going further. My only other option seemed to be voice training as much as possible.
I later learned from my hormone follow-up that when I asked to increase to 0.3 mL, my usual Walmart pharmacy was out of the usual 100 mg vials, and Walgreens gave me four 200 mg vials instead without consulting me. I was taking the same volume, unaware it was much more concentrated, so I was probably taking double what I should have. Even my GP was shocked the pharmacy hadn't consulted me. I also wished my GP had advised me to stay at 0.2 mL for a few years longer rather than giving the go-ahead when I asked to increase after just 6 months. I had assumed going up one mL every 6 months would gradually lower my voice as if stimulating an actual male going through puberty, and I hated myself for realizing how wrong that was.
By April 2024 I had stopped taking hormones for a few months and felt mostly better, but still had a lingering thought of getting a reduction. I'd gone from wanting a double mastectomy with a nipple graft to thinking a completely flat chest would look odd, but I still wasn't happy leaving my chest as is. I'm fairly well endowed in that area. I thought a compromise would be a reduction without nipples, since I see no real need for them. I didn't want it to seem like a cope to re-transition. The dysphoria around my chest didn't magically go away just because I dropped the trans label. Sports bras and occasional binding only give temporary relief, and a smaller chest would be tolerable and require less reliance on shapewear. I'd rather go the reduction route than a full mastectomy, for myself rather than anyone else; I wouldn't plan to walk around topless and don't care much about dating. I don't have the money for it now but genuinely want it.
In October 2024 I posted asking what to do with unused or leftover HRT vials, unopened syringes and needles. I had boxes of still-wrapped needles and syringes from a year's supply and two punctured, still-partially-filled testosterone vials. I'd disposed of used ones long ago. I said I have no intention of ever going back on T and can't anyway since it's pretty much contaminated.
In June 2024 I posted about feeling like continuing T because my voice felt beyond repair. Ironically my main reason for T was wanting a bassy voice, only to hate it because it sounds cartoonishly off and consistently breaks. I can hardly sing properly and now miss what it originally sounded like. I don't want to go back on T because it'd feel like self harm, but no amount of voice training will restore my original voice, and I still get gendered as male 50% of the time when I talk to people because of it. Voice analyzing apps still register my voice as mostly male. Sometimes I think about going back on a small dose for some chance my voice balances out, but also fear it'll make things worse. It feels hopeless. I said I don't have money for surgeries and don't know the success rate of vocal feminization surgery; worst outcome could be permanently damaged vocal cords unable to speak or sing.
I don't believe losing weight would make much difference to my chest size. I had a period where I suffered an eating disorder as a kid, and even then my chest remained largely the same despite losing a lot of weight quickly. As of April 2024 I was a bit chubby and struggled with body image surrounding my weight.
I turned 25 on April 14, 2024. I've never found myself attracted to anyone and still don't. I've never dated and prefer strictly platonic relationships. I don't plan on ever having bio children.
I detransitioned about 4 years ago as of September 2026, though it's 'a bit washy.' I didn't want to be a 'man'; I wanted some masculine sex traits that could make me perceived as a man, especially a feminine gnc one. It sounds cringe but I heavily looked up to and was jealous of feminine and androgynous men and wished I could look like them. I still want an andro image for myself but doubt it'll ever be possible with my body type. Ultimately I stopped taking T because I was chasing a dragon: my ideal form wouldn't work unless my body was male by default. I still wish to an extent I could have had a normal male body while maintaining femininity. TLDR: yes but I still wish I was male to an extent, just a male one with an estrogenized body rather than a female body with high testosterone.
I never believed in the concept of having a gender identity, let alone one matching my birth sex. My lack of belief in gender is what drew me to the nonbinary label, which became frustrating the more I thought about it while transitioning, and I gradually stopped calling myself that. I call myself a woman because it's what I am biologically and out of convenience. I don't understand nor care about concepts like womanhood/manhood, femininity or masculinity. I wish my body could be a completely sexless blob of nothing, but that's not physically possible, so I just accept I am one because I'm female. Calling myself anything else wouldn't change that reality or make me happier. I technically still call myself agender because I don't feel like I have a gender identity, yet I don't deny I'm female or a 'woman' in the biological sense. Agender is less an identity label and more a description of my feeling of having one.
I have atypical dysphoria: I didn't want to accept my female body but couldn't see myself satisfied or happier with a faux male one either. Dysphoria over not having sex characteristics of both sexes, or over having either one, still counts as dysphoria. Partially being on testosterone and desiring some form of breast reduction felt like I was going in the same direction as any other ftm transition, and that wasn't what I wanted; this was partially why I detransitioned.
I became more critical of gender stuff over the years. I'm fairly neutral on trans issues rather than the full-blown '100% support everything with no questions asked' I was before. I don't talk much about it with friends and keep it anonymous, mostly because many of them are also trans/nonbinary identifying and in their minds anything gencrit = TERF. Leaving Tumblr because it's a giant trans echo chamber was one of the best things I did for myself. I have the detrans tag blocked on Tumblr because 90% of it bothers me.
My overall feelings regarding transness turned 180 when I stopped taking T and calling myself nonbinary. I don't dislike trans people per se, but I'm heavily against certain trans ideals and talking points, which is conflicting. I don't believe the concept of having a gender identity genuinely exists, so my mind defaults to 'trans women are a type of man or trans men are a type of woman who choose not to socially live as the opposite sex.' I view transition more as a personal bodymod choice rather than life-saving medical care, and I basically view it as a glorified bodymod that should be paid out of pocket rather than by insurance. I disagree with trans women in women's sports, children medically transitioning before 18, and I'm against transition being deemed medically necessary or the only way to deal with gender dysphoria. I still believe people should be able to do whatever they want with their bodies as long as they're consenting adults aware of health risks, but there are limits and things that should be criticized rather than blindly accepted.
I posted in November 2018 asking whether more neutral, non-affirming gender therapists would have prevented situations like mine. I've advocated for unbiased therapy, criticized 'egg' culture and pushing GNC people toward transition, criticized trans subreddits pushing dysphoric minors toward DIY, and criticized the 'you were never trans' claim from trans people about detransitioners. I've also argued that most trans-related surgeries are purely cosmetic, that detransitioners shouldn't be dismissed as only doing it because of 'society,' and that biological sex should be accurately recorded on government documents. I've discussed AGP as a real phenomenon motivating some male transitions. I don't consider myself cis or trans; I reject the dichotomy as limiting.