Todas as histórias

Uma lésbica vendo de fora as histórias de destransição

Mulher · Desistiu323
Estas histórias foram resumidas usando IA.

No Reddit, pessoas frequentemente compartilham suas experiências em vários comentários ou posts. Para tornar essa informação mais acessível, o detrans.ai reúne todas essas peças dispersas em um único resumo e linha do tempo fácil de ler. Todos os prompts do sistema estão anotados na página de prompts.

Às vezes a IA pode alucinar ou afirmar coisas que não são verdade. Mas geralmente, os resumos das histórias são reflexões precisas dos comentários originais dos usuários.

Resumo

Sou uma comentarista próxima da destransição, e não uma detransicionadora: sou do sexo feminino, sempre me identifiquei como lésbica e nunca fiz transição médica. Minha preocupação central é que, por volta de 2020/2021, a ideia de que sexo e gênero são a mesma coisa foi usada para pressionar lésbicas a namorar mulheres trans pré-operatórias, o que vivi como um ataque pessoal à minha sexualidade. Sou muito crítica dos subreddits e espaços online lésbicos, que acredito terem sido tomados por pessoas que se identificam como AGP e por uma moderação hostil. Acompanhei com interesse e simpatia as histórias de destransição e as polêmicas sobre pesquisas no Twitter. Continuo sendo lésbica e tenho opiniões críticas sobre a aplicação da transição à atração pelo mesmo sexo.

História completa

I am a lesbian, born female, and I have never transitioned — my account here is about how I relate to the wider trans and detrans conversation rather than about my own medical history. I came out as a lesbian and have consistently described myself that way. At one point I did stand behind the framing that "sex and gender are different" — one biological, one a social construct — and I say plainly that I stood behind that position. That changed for me around 2020/2021. I noticed the first shift in that mindset when a trans woman told me I was transphobic for not wanting to date a pre-op trans woman. My reading of it is that trans women did not like being rejected by lesbians while they still had their penis, and that around that time the claim that sex and gender are the same thing emerged — which I experienced as pressure on lesbians to have sex with them. I have been active in lesbian and detrans-adjacent spaces online, mostly commenting rather than posting. I have described a subreddit for lesbians as having "become such a shit show," arguing that its moderators only care about trans people rather than actual lesbians, since people get banned simply for being members of another sub. In December 2024 I said that sub "has been taken over by AGP's long ago" and that young lesbians just play along out of fear of being excluded, calling it "a massive shitshow." I have followed detransition and survey controversies closely. I noted that a particular survey stopped collecting data in 2018 but only released it in 2022, and I said I had seen a couple of people on Twitter who were part of that survey and who have since detransitioned. I have also commented on specific individuals and communities: I called one person "very harmful and a straight up bully," and I described certain Twitter hashtags around this topic as "just gross." I have been asked directly about my sex and have answered plainly: female, "without a doubt." I have not described any hormones, surgeries, therapy, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, or relationship history beyond my lesbian identity. My concerns are social and political: I feel that lesbians have been pressured and excluded within these spaces, and I am critical of how transition and identity claims are applied to same-sex attraction. I have not described any regret about transition of my own, because I have not transitioned.