Te zgodbe so bile povzete z uporabo umetne inteligence.
Na Redditu ljudje pogosto delijo svoje izkušnje v več komentarjih ali objavah. Da bi te informacije naredili bolj dostopne, detrans.ai zbere vse te razpršene dele v enoten, enostaven za branje povzetek in časovnico. Vsi sistemski pozivi so navedeni na strani s pozivi.
Včasih lahko umetna inteligenca halucinira ali navaja stvari, ki niso resnične. Toda na splošno so povzete zgodbe točne odsevi izvirnih komentarjev uporabnikov.
Povzetek
Sem detranzicionirana ženska, ki je tranzicionirala pri 14 letih s pomočjo neinformiranega LGBT terapevta, ki potrjuje spol, v petih tednih dobila blokatorje pubertete in hormone, in katere jajčniki so začeli propadati v četrtem letu medicinske tranzicije. Zdaj podpiram pravico odraslih do tranzicije, medtem ko nasprotujem medicinski tranziciji mladoletnikov in zahtevam boljšo terapijo, ozaveščeno o travmi, in informirano soglasje. Detranzicionirajočim svetujem, naj poiščejo specializirane terapevte, ne pa takšnih, ki potrjujejo spol, in kritiziram tako medicinsko ustanovo kot ravnanje nekaterih trans ljudi z detranzicionirajočimi. Ne navajam uradne trenutne identitetne oznake, vendar po detranziciji živim v skladu s svojim rojstnim spolom.
Celotna zgodba
I grew up confused about who I was, and I now wish I had seen more people who looked like me as a kid — I think that might have kept me from being so confused growing up. I was adopted, and I also struggled with trauma and identity issues as a child. When I was 14, I transitioned. I went to an LGBT gender-affirming therapist who wasn't informed about trauma and wasn't inquisitive about why I wanted to transition; she just praised and affirmed me because that was what she knew how to do. As a result, she didn't see the signs, and I got access to puberty blockers and hormones within five weeks of starting therapy. I take responsibility for the choice I made, but I didn't do it alone — I was a minor, and if I had understood the gravity of what I was signing up for, I never would have transitioned.
About four years into medical transition, my ovaries started decaying. I share this because I don't think it's fear-mongering — I still think people should be allowed to take that risk if they want to, as long as they understand the potential risks. Transition eventually started to cause me pain, whereas when I was a kid it had helped me cope. I came to understand that it was based in a lie. My brain had developed coping skills out of survival in response to perceived threats, and as an adult I was able to start unlearning the survival skills that were no longer necessary — for me, that was my transition.
What helped me most was practical self-care: sleeping well, eating well, exercising, going on walks, keeping my environment clean, finding a hobby I love, and being kind to my body and brain. I also found a therapist who specializes in adoption, since I'm adopted, and I'd recommend that others find therapists matched to their specific experiences — autism, PTSD, veteran status, and so on. I specifically advise against going to a gender-affirming LGBT therapist, because they won't know how to support detransition. I believe therapists need better training in understanding various traumas; my own gender-affirming therapist harmed me more than she helped. I think months or years of talk therapy should be required before medical transition, with honest information about the risks given upfront.
On policy, I support trans people's right to transition medically and socially, and I support legal protections for them in healthcare, housing, and career, since they're a vulnerable minority. I don't want to take anyone's legal rights away. But I'm critical of medical transition for minors, including invasive surgery and even HRT, which is technically invasive and can be permanent, because minors' brains aren't fully formed. For adults, I believe in autonomy and choice even for things I disagree with — I don't believe in legally prohibiting smoking or drinking either. I do think people are being sold a lie about transitioning, which is an issue.
I'm also critical of how some trans people treat detransitioners. I've seen detrans people called bigots for talking about our experiences, even though many detrans people end up with permanently altered bodies — castration, mastectomy, organ decay, chemical castration, infertility — and face real stigma. Comparing those alterations to circumcision or tattoos isn't fair. I also find it irritating when trans men romanticize the gender role of a man or trans women romanticize the gender role of a woman, since that isn't really challenging gender norms. I don't believe in gender roles at all, and I think people who reject biology's significance are worse than those who at least acknowledge science. I also believe that "normalcy" isn't real and that gay and trans people's social acceptance is part of human evolution — they're always going to exist. More recently, I've described certain attitudes as homophobic and unaccepting of genuine homosexuality in women or gender-nonconforming women.
I don't have a stated current identity label, but I live as my birth sex after detransitioning and no longer pursue transition.