Te zgodbe so bile povzete z uporabo umetne inteligence.
Na Redditu ljudje pogosto delijo svoje izkušnje v več komentarjih ali objavah. Da bi te informacije naredili bolj dostopne, detrans.ai zbere vse te razpršene dele v enoten, enostaven za branje povzetek in časovnico. Vsi sistemski pozivi so navedeni na strani s pozivi.
Včasih lahko umetna inteligenca halucinira ali navaja stvari, ki niso resnične. Toda na splošno so povzete zgodbe točne odsevi izvirnih komentarjev uporabnikov.
Povzetek
Sem detranzicionirani moški, ki je od približno 17,5 leta živel socialno kot ženska približno dve leti in desist tik pred 21. rojstnim dnem, ne da bi kdaj jemal hormone. Obžalujem šest sej laserskega odstranjevanja dlak z obraza, opravljenih pri 20 letih, in se še vedno spopadam z glasom, zaradi katerega me berejo kot žensko, ter z zmanjšano motivacijo po desistu. Zdaj drugim svetujem, naj ne hitijo s trajnimi medicinskimi koraki, in sem kritičen do potrjujočih pristopov, obenem pa priznavam, da imajo nekateri res lahko koristi od tranzicije.
Celotna zgodba
I am a man who was born male, and I am not intersex, though I do look somewhat androgynous. My gender identification phase began around 17.5 years old, and I lived socially as a woman for about two years, stopping just before my 21st birthday. I never took hormones; I desisted before that step, which I attribute partly to an unrelated lucky event.
The roots of my trans identification were unusual, and I recognized fairly early that I wasn't actually trans. I described it as knowing I wasn't trans when I started socially transitioning but just not being able to resist, and I even wondered whether it was something like Munchausen syndrome. A major motivator was that I hated my gender and hated men. When I was feeling down about my life and hating my gender in particular, I wanted to be a woman and searched through some sort of hypnosis content on YouTube. One video suggested that simply feeling good while imagining oneself as the opposite gender could mean you are trans. After several months I realized I wasn't, but the idea was so ingrained I couldn't accept not being trans for another 2.5 years. I later said I felt 'dumb' because I was actually aware I wasn't trans but hated my gender so much that I strived to fake my way into it anyway.
The one lasting physical intervention I regret is facial hair laser removal. I went through six sessions, each one or two months apart, with the last in June 2023. I was 20 while doing it and 21 when I posted about it in November 2023. I paid around $200 for the six sessions, as I am European. It's not completely gone, but you have to take a closer look to see it at all. I noted that my trans phase started shortly after my facial hair began to appear, so I never got to see the full scope of my facial hair anyway. I tried an at-home laser hair removal device as well, which did nothing and which I think is a scam. I hoped for regrowth after laser and tested my natural hormone levels, which I believe are normal.
Another ongoing issue is that my voice is perceived as female. Even after desisting, people call me 'ma'am' when I call them, and internet voice identification claims I have a female voice. It is certainly deeper than when I was a kid, and people I know personally think it sounds more like a guy's, but I am still too often perceived as a woman because of it. I never did voice training, and I wasn't sure whether I was speaking unnaturally high because of my trans past. I had a higher voice even before all of this, but only realized it during the trans phase. I also noted that the whole situation messed up my desires and mind to the point that I don't trust my own judgment anymore.
What moved me toward desisting was falling in love accidentally and meeting people who showed me there is value in pursuing self-comfort. I said I was planning on going on hormones around that time and might still have pursued being trans if I hadn't met those people. Living as the opposite gender gave me actual knowledge of how it felt, and I couldn't shake off a feeling of discomfort while doing so; if I hadn't felt bad as a woman, I wouldn't have considered desisting.
After desisting, I struggled with motivation. I found it much harder to find motivation for my duties, saying that when identifying as trans I didn't really care about my mental wellbeing, which made me more immune to uncomfortable things, and that now, without the single goal of transition to strive toward, I felt kind of shattered and much less able to do anything.
I have reflected on related experiences from my teenage years. When I was a teenager I was homophobic; at 16 I started to accept gay people but was extremely scared I might be gay, despite being attracted to women and seeing no actual attraction to men. I worried that looking longer at men would mean otherwise, and that my attraction to women was fake. I eventually tried gay porn and felt next to nothing, looking at men made me feel nothing, and I realized I am straight. I described this as something akin to HOCD.
In terms of attitudes toward transition now, I advise others to avoid making permanent decisions with long-lasting effects like medical steps, and I told someone considering hormones that they aren't something you just 'try out' like a new haircut because of long-lasting consequences, the most glaring being breast growth. I said trans identity can seem like one magical solution for all problems, but it doesn't solve anxiety, depression, or an inferiority complex. I told someone their main issue sounded like misandry, that there is nothing wrong with being a man, and that feeling less is a sign of depression rather than of being a man. I also said I am not necessarily against transition in all cases and believe there might be people who would benefit in the long run, what I called 'true trans,' but I am critical of affirming therapists who say that if you think you are trans, you are trans. I advised someone with suspected TOCD to talk to a specialist in that field or at least an OCD specialist. I also argued that cis people generally avoid being perceived as another gender and dislike being mistaken for the other, and that constant perception as the other gender is clearly of negative impact. I discussed the David Reimer case, arguing it shows there can be some sort of internal gender identity, though that view was unpopular. I also commented that human sexuality is more fluid than simple categories like straight/bi/gay. I have not described any activism beyond posting and commenting in detransition communities.