Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.
В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.
Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.
Резюме
Аз съм детранзишън човек (конкретната ми история на преход и настоящият етикет на идентичност не са напълно ясни от споделеното), който е силно критичен към движението за гендерно разнообразие, което виждам като социална зараза, особено вредна за хора с гранично/хистрионно личностно разстройство и нестабилност на идентичността. Поддържам строго материалистичен възглед, че ние сме телата си, че гендерът като абстракция трябва да бъде изоставен и че медицинският преход е самоотричане, а не самоутвърждаване. Аутист съм и имам деформиран крайник, което оформя възгледите ми за телесната несъответност. Застъпвам се за по-гласна общност на детранзишън и съм разтревожен от самостоятелната ХЗТ. Поддържам и малцинствени възгледи за динамиката на пола и гендера, твърдейки, че властта тече в двете посоки между мъжете и жените.
Пълна история
I've been thinking a lot lately about the overlap between personality disorders like BPD and HPD and people identifying as non-binary or trans. I asked about it openly because I've seen it happen with someone in my own life — someone who previously used female pronouns and identified as gender fluid, and who was already androgynous, but who has since started taking testosterone to become more androgynous, switched to they/them pronouns, and now identifies as non-binary. This person has actually admitted to me that they believe themselves to have some kind of personality disorder, and they have some awareness of mental health terminology because of a family member with a mental health background. I think what's happening is partly an attempt to escape a traumatic background and get a 'blank slate,' which I don't think is really possible.
I'm autistic myself, and I think autistic people often fall victim to having their eccentricities and deviations from the norm hyper-categorized. I also have a deformed extremity, so my body differs quite a bit from other people's — but I don't know any different, and the only difference I recognize is that my body is different from others, which creates a kind of incongruence. If I had never encountered another human, I wouldn't have that notion of incongruence at all. That experience shapes how I think about the whole concept of bodily 'incongruence' that underpins a lot of gender identity discourse.
My overall view, which I hold as a strict materialist, is that we are our bodies, and changing the 'hardware' doesn't solve a 'software' problem. I think the concept of gender as a reified abstraction needs to be dropped entirely. Pronouns and terms like male/female should refer to the body, not to internal feelings or 'tastes' that no sex has a monopoly on. I don't think people should be stereotyped into gendered behavior — I actually think the opposite — but the body does influence thoughts and emotions, and hormones do affect sexed bodies in real ways (testosterone with spatial abilities, aggression, risk-taking; estrogen with emotional sensitivity and mood). I see medical transition as an act of self-denial rather than self-affirmation.
I believe the gender diversity movement functions partly as a social contagion. We had perfectly good labels before — tomboy, bohemian, effeminate — that were capable of integrating gender-nonconforming people. These communities appeal to people with identity diffusion because they offer immediate acceptance, validation, and uncritical attention, often when that affirmation itself can be harmful. I've seen this happen with people in my own life. I think people with BPD/HPD are drawn to these identities as a standardized package to latch onto. I'm critical not out of bigotry but out of genuine concern for people who lack a stable sense of identity.
I'm also concerned about what I see as semantic inflation — applying labels to so many characteristics that they lose meaning. Non-binary, for instance, is a poor label because by placing yourself outside a binary you just create another binary. I think today's problems stem from a severe lack of meaning and breakdown of social fabric, an anomie that drives people toward these identities.
I want the detransition community to become more vocal and visible in public discourse. I believe there are far more detrans/desist people than are visibly vocal, but they're often left without a voice. I think the problem needs to be met at the root — on platforms like Reddit and social media where the issue started. I'm also very concerned about DIY HRT; I think it sounds like a bad idea and very risky, and I don't understand how it makes people think they aren't struggling with mental health issues (though I have my own problems and don't want to stigmatize). I've also seen people in comments debating whether DIY testosterone is a good idea, which bothers me.
I posted about how sad it makes me that our world has made modifying yourself equal to loving yourself. I also shared a post showing how people are encouraged to alter their bodies without hearing both sides of the story — the point was to show the social enforcement of transition in practice, not to rant or vent.
On gender dynamics more broadly, I hold some unpopular views. I don't think saying the female sex is oppressed tells the whole story — I think it understates the power women have over women. I think men tend to have better opinions of women than women have of men, and I've cited the 'women are wonderful' effect and studies on self-opinion to support this. I think power goes both ways between the sexes, and that oppression is more fiscal and economic than by sex or gender. I've pointed out that FGM is often carried out and policed by women, as a sacred rite excluding men — not to justify it, but to complicate the black-and-white view. These views have gotten me heavily downvoted in some spaces.
I'm agnostic but I don't believe in remarriage — I see it as disrespectful to a deceased spouse's memory, and I think love should be permanent. I'm critical of Viktor Frankl (whom I suspect someone was referencing) as pop-psychology rather than real philosophy, and I prefer Nietzsche because he lived through real experience. I think trans people often become trans because they lack a feeling of power over themselves, and from that power you arrive at purpose.
I support removing the trans/gender diversity debate from the LGB discussion entirely.