Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.
В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.
Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.
Резюме
Аз съм жена, обърнала прехода си или отказала се от него, която никога не е преминавала медицински преход, но беше близо до това, и преживях това, което наричам бързо настъпила джендър дисфория, подтикната от самота, тормоз от мъже, завист към мъжете, телесна несигурност и дискомфорт с джендър ролите. Купих си пристягаща превръзка за гърди и фуния за уриниране и се вманиачих на транс-мъжко съдържание, но спрях преди хормони или операция. Сега формулирам опита си като нездравословна обсесия, подхранвана от транс общността и трансмедията, и активно изкоренявам джендър идеологията от живота си. Клоня към трансмед възгледите и имам критични възгледи за транс движението, като същевременно признавам несигурност относно сексуалността си заради мисли, които съм имала за други момичета.
Пълна история
I was born female, and I never medically transitioned — but for a stretch I came very close, and I've spent a lot of time since then trying to understand how I got there.
The feelings I had about wanting to be a trans guy kind of came out of nowhere, though when I look back I can see they were an accumulation of loneliness, harassment from guys, envy and jealousy of men, body insecurity, and discomfort with gender-role expectations. Once those ideas got into my head I became obsessed with anything trans-guy related — I was binge-watching transition and detransition videos on YouTube for months, taking notes on patterns among detransitioners, and I started having urges to wear a binder, to pack, to wear male clothing. I even bought a pee funnel device. I also bought a binder off Amazon that I still occasionally wear when I want to wear button-downs or certain t-shirts; I'm a B-cup so it gives me the flat masculine look I want, and when I'm not wearing it I'm usually in a tight sports bra or a big jacket, hoodie, sweatshirt, or oversized t-shirt to decrease the appearance of my chest. I live somewhere with four mostly cold seasons so I can get away with that style. I've told myself it was a good thing I was still sane enough at the time not to consider medically transitioning, but I haven't been mentally the same since these ideas got in my head, and I still entertain thoughts of being a guy and having those urges.
I've come to frame what happened to me as rapid-onset gender dysphoria — I even linked an article about it to someone else — and I noted that obsessive binge-watching of transition/detransition videos is itself a symptom of it. I blame the trans community and transmedia for my gender identity issues and for confusing other young people who ended up as detransitioners. I've said that I'm slowly cutting all of this gender stuff out of my life because it's become an unhealthy obsession for me.
I've thought a lot about why girls in particular end up here. My view is that if society treated you the way you wanted to be treated as a woman, you wouldn't be transitioning at all, and that a lot of girls aren't comfortable being girls because of trauma or how they've been treated, so identifying as a guy feels like a perfect solution. I've argued that what many of these people needed was therapy, not hormones or surgically modifying their body, and that transitioning was for some people a kind of fun costume or personality they could try on to escape discomfort with living as their birth sex. I've recommended to others that they find a gender-critical therapist rather than a gender-affirming one to work through discomfort around being a woman.
I lean transmed — I still don't really understand identifying as another gender without dysphoria — and I've said the whole thing seems to have more to do with something like body dysmorphia with gender added on. I'm critical of the trans movement broadly, including what I see as its targeting of women and homophobia, and I've argued that top surgery and most changes on T are irreversible and that people come to regret them. I've advised others considering transition that they should do their research and think long and hard about repercussions first.
On sexuality, I've said I'd date based on attraction rather than what's 'normal' for my gender, which I compared to compulsory heterosexuality, and I've acknowledged that with the thoughts I've had about other girls I'm not sure I'd call myself mostly straight. I don't currently identify as trans; I'm working on pulling all of this out of my life.