Всички истории

Искаше да е жената в отношенията — HRT сложи край на фантазията

Мъж · Детранзиционирал/а990
Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.

В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.

Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.

Резюме

Роден съм мъж, преминах преход и започнах хормонална заместителна терапия, после се отказах от прехода, и сега се идентифицирам като мъж и казвам, че се наслаждавам да бъда мъж и се чувствам комфортно в тялото си. Вярвам, че преходът ми израсна от усещането, че съм "различен" от средния хетеросексуален младеж, от подчинен сексуален профил и от идеализирането на това да бъда жената в хетеросексуална връзка, подсилено от потапянето ми в онлайн транс общности — макар че казвам, че това беше самоизмама, а не манипулация от някого другиго. Детранзишънът беше по-лесен за мен, отколкото никога да не бях преминавал преход, защото преживяването на реалността на ХЗТ отне фантазията. Все още имам известна трудност да поддържам пълна ерекция по време на секс, което отчасти отдавам на порнографията, и се опитвам да намаля порнографията. Сега съм критичен към прехода за повечето хора, против съм прехода на младите и блокерите на пубертета, и активно се противопоставям онлайн на културата на жертвата и на това, което виждам като социално заразна транс идеология.

Пълна история

I grew up male and, looking back, I had feelings of being 'different' from the average straight boy that made me want to be a woman. I also liked men but never connected romantically in gay relationships, and I started idealizing straight relationships and feeling like the woman in one so I could still like dicks and have a submissive side to my sexuality. That combination pushed me toward transition. I transitioned, went on HRT, and later detransitioned. I don't date the exact years of any of these steps in what I've written publicly, but I know that by my mid-twenties, after detransitioning, I started feeling more attracted to the masculine role in sex, topping, and having more sex with women, which I found enjoyable. I also recall that 'egg' terminology didn't even exist when I was transitioning, which tells me my transition predated the current wave of trans internet culture by at least five years. Looking back on the process, I don't feel I was manipulated by anyone else in the sense that I blame others. I think it was a self-delusion, a self-manipulation that occurred. I also think most trans people are very impressionable: they sit in internet trans spaces all day and soak up opinions and content from everyone else in the 'community,' and they learn that saying something out of turn gets you banned. I see a lot of black-and-white, 'life or death' thinking in those spaces, framing lives around suicide threats, and I think suicide is a social contagion — if you think and talk about suicide all the time you're more likely to do it, and it can be used as a coping mechanism to generate sympathy, which is self-destructive. Detransitioning was, in a specific sense, easier for me than not having transitioned at all would have been. I've said directly that it was 'MUCH easier for me to detransition after experiencing the reality of HRT medical transition,' because if I hadn't experienced it I'd 'still be an idiot thinking HRT was going to turn me into x, y, z and my dreams were just around the corner.' In that way I think desisters actually have a harder road, because they still have to work through the 'what if' fantasy. People who have serious trans thoughts and pull back from the brink need psychological support to break free of the seductiveness of 'life transforming' transition narratives. On physical effects: I've said I never lost any penis size, but I do find maintaining a full erection during sex difficult. When I watch porn and stimulate myself constantly I maintain a pretty rock-hard erection for an extended period, so I suspect desensitization of either my penis or my mind. I hate sex with a not-full-hard dick — it makes me feel like I have a small dick and that my partner isn't turned on by me. I've been trying to do less of this and I tell others porn is very bad and everyone should try to be porn-free; I've said explicitly that porn 'fucked me up for sure' and that it's emasculating a lot of guys, which is why most of them end up with submissive fetishes instead of dominant ones. I've also said I had a consultation with a surgeon in Chicago and didn't pay any consultation fee — that was in the context of advising someone else to just find another surgeon. I've never had FFS myself and I'm quite critical of it: I say FFS is a joke, doesn't remove masculine bone structure, at best softens the natural male skull, and doesn't make it look like a female skull for 99% of transsexuals. I've told people who are jealous of transsexual sex workers that most of them don't make much money, end up as drug addicts, and that I make more money than 99% of them with a normal job. I've met many in person. On identity now: I enjoy being a man. I've said I oscillated from wanting to be a woman because of things that made me feel 'different' from the average straight boy, to being annoyed at things that make me feel less of a man or less attractive as a man. Rather than wanting to be feminine, I now wish for masculine attributes, and overall I'm comfortable with my body even though I'd have a wishlist of improvements. I no longer desire the things transition would have given me, so I have no issues with not having done certain things. I've thought about whether I might transition again — I said 'I did' at times think others will or can, but then I see 39-year-olds transitioning and shrug. I also said I don't feel I was manipulated by others; it's usually self-delusion. On sexuality and AGP: I've discussed AGP extensively with others, saying the intense fantasy kind — having a sexuality revolving around yourself and feminizing yourself — is the difficult kind to deal with, whereas milder forms (like enjoying bottoming with a man) aren't really AGP. I've said that before HRT it's 'hardcore rock hard boner inducing thoughts about femininity,' that gender-bending erotica is common in older generations, and that younger generations get into sissy porn, forced femme and emasculation porn. I've also said AGPs aren't the majority of the trans community, just the most visible online, because they tend to be nerdy and autistic. I've told a 22-year-old who was fantasizing about being a woman after losing his father to be careful not to waste his life on neuroticism, to explore his sexuality in other avenues if it's sexual, and that based on his brief description transition would likely be very damaging and not lead to long-term contentment. I've said 'if you think maybe its fetish, then it's probably a fetish' and urged people to stop watching porn. On my broader views: I think transitioning and similar identity crises attract vulnerable, fragile people, and I find the fragility of trans people (and detrans people) annoying — I've noticed dozens of threads of trans people 'whining about being triggered by the detrans sub.' I believe in tolerance and am against dehumanization, but I don't understand how people who are triggered by Reddit posts navigate a world where most people have viscerally negative reactions to them; my conclusion is they avoid society and live online. I oppose victim culture generally and call out people who transitioned and then blame the medical establishment for their own decisions — I've said 'You did it to yourself. No one did it to you.' I've noted most people blaming others for their transition tend to be FtM and said women tend to have a victim mentality more than men. I'm against transitioning young kids and against puberty blockers, which I believe cement the trans identity and make it impossible to back out mentally, though I acknowledge some individuals benefit from early transitions. I think most people show up to the medical establishment already self-diagnosed with their hands out asking for HRT and surgery, and I've questioned the legitimacy of a gender dysphoria diagnosis, calling it basically a made-up thing from the last 20 years. I've also said I think there's a minority of trans people with a strong foundation for whom transitioning maybe makes sense, but for most others it comes from a weak foundation and weak identity. I don't describe myself as doing formal advocacy or activism, but I do engage heavily in detrans and trans-critical discussions online, offering blunt advice and pushing back on what I see as victimhood, black-and-white thinking, and the influence of porn and socially contagious communities.