Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.
В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.
Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.
Резюме
Аз съм детранзиционирала жена, която се идентифицираше като небинарна, а след това като трансмаскулинна, и приемах тестостерон в продължение на една година след връзка с транс жена. Съжалявам, че увредих певческия си глас и вероятно здравето си — промени, които направих до голяма степен, за да спечеля общност и любов. Сега разпознавам голяма част от своята „дисфория“ като аутистично отчуждение и неудовлетвореност от тялото си, като оставам полово неконформна и бисексуална. Психичното ми здраве и чувството ми за принадлежност пострадаха тежко в транс общността и потърсих детранс приятели и група само за жени. Оставам критична към транс активизма, особено към твърденията, които заличават биологичния пол, като същевременно по принцип подкрепям правата на транс хората.
Пълна история
I am a detransitioned woman. I was a classically trained soprano when I was younger, though I hadn't performed in years by the time I transitioned. I came out as non-binary while I was in a relationship with a trans girl because I wanted to be closer to her. At the time I didn't realise these were my motivations, but I got on testosterone after we broke up because I wanted to stay in her world and thought a drastic change would get her attention. I stayed on it for a year because I gained friends and community by transitioning, plus a new partner who liked that I was a 'boygirl'.
Before identifying as non-binary I had struggled with my body shape: I never developed wide hips or a defined waist, as I was told all girls did during puberty, so I felt abnormal and broken, and I took phrases like 'real women have curves!' personally and thought I was a freak. Identifying as non-binary offered relief from this anguish because there was no standard for how my body should look — I no longer had weirdly small hips for a girl, they were just my hips. I now recognise that a lot of what I thought was gender dysphoria was autistic alienation and masking; I relate to descriptions of autistic masking from experience. I also think I was drawn in by wanting to belong: I felt like I was part of a community for the first time in my life when I was trans.
I was only on T for a year. My voice is the change I most regret: my mid-to-high range is weak and strained, it feels like my vocal cords are stuck in a pubescent state, and I can't really access head voice anymore without it hurting. I've had days where I go to the bathroom every hour, which I assumed was an anxiety thing since it only happened in the office. I also worry I may have damaged my health. Since detransitioning I have noticed some female-typical fat redistribution returning now that I'm off testosterone, though I still have body changes I'd like to lose with weight loss and time. I've reflected that I 'fucked up my voice and potentially my health all because I wanted to be loved by a bunch of people who ended up abandoning me anyway'.
Moving toward detransition wasn't a single event: I had a really rough few years in the trans community and was ready to put it all behind me and start fresh. I started going to a monthly female-only discussion group, which felt like a huge step forward, only to discover the group was being harassed and infiltrated by trans rights activists. I've described a video as feeling like a 'detransition soft-launch'. I also noted that my opinions sometimes need to temporarily swing in the opposite direction to redress the balance.
I dated a trans woman who used dating apps to flirt with people behind my back and blamed it on their dysphoria when caught; they admitted a compulsive need for sexual validation almost like an addiction, but I was made to feel like the bad guy for suggesting they might be AGP. When I broached AGP once with an ex, I was made to feel like the most evil transphobic person alive and told I was making trans women feel unsafe — the same trans women who were mistreating me and crossing my boundaries. Another ex cheated on me repeatedly because validation from girls who called themselves lesbians was worth more than anything I could offer as an openly bisexual person. My ex also pretty much exclusively dated transmascs and talked about wanting to transition to female just to transition back again. I was called transphobic by an ex for saying sex is technically binary.
I am gnc and only attracted to other gnc people, but I don't think I'd be compatible with most people who identify as trans or non-binary. I got more attention while androgynous than I ever did at my prettiest and most feminine. I don't idolise trans people like I used to, though old habits die hard — being clocked as trans at a gay karaoke bar still gave me that 'gender euphoria' feeling that made me transition in the first place, even though I'm fairly certain I'm not trans. I feel lonely and like I don't fit in anywhere, and I've reached out to make detrans friends. I now think the trans community has a serious problem with misogyny, with AMAB trans people not caring about the wellbeing of AFAB trans people, and with people stating objectively false things as though they were literally true. I would still be supportive of trans rights if people weren't trying to do away with sex as a concept; trans women insisting they were not only women but biologically female was as much as I could take. I've recommended a therapist directory (Beyond Trans) to others seeking help, though that isn't what I did myself.