Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.
В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.
Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.
Резюме
Аз съм детранзиционирала жена, която живя като мъж дълги години и до голяма степен се възстанови от половата дисфория, след като реши, че преходът не работи за мен. Дисфорията ми имаше взаимосвързани корени в аутизъм, порнографско/фетиш съдържание във FTM средите и детски асоциации от религиозно възпитание. Детранзицията беше мое собствено решение (моят консервативен годеник се опита да ме разубеди) и огромен товар от поддържане на външния вид и криене падна от плещите ми. Станах християнка след детранзицията, което ми донесе утеха, и сега се чувствам по-уверена като жена, въпреки че физическите промени от тестостерона остават като напомняния, които се опитвам да залича. Оставам критична към непоследователността на транс движението относно половите стереотипи и скептична към небинарната идентификация.
Пълна история
I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a man for many years and was, in my own words, 'transgender in every way' — people took me for a man — but it never felt right socially or otherwise. I never felt I fit in with other men; I always felt like an intruder and thought 'I'm not the same as them,' which eventually made me decide I would rather live as a woman than keep failing at living as a man.
My gender dysphoria had several interconnected causes. I am autistic, and my thinking was closer to the male average — I log thousands of hours in rhythm games, paint model tanks, and have experimented with Arch Linux for audio latency — so I rarely relate to girls unless they are also autistic, and most of my role models were men or fictional women, which I think contributed to my transition. There was also pornography and fetish content in the ftm/artist spaces I was in; I believe a significant number of girls transition partly because of a fetish for becoming the cute boys they consume content of, and that girls are shamed for 'fetishizing gay relationships' but can avoid that by becoming men themselves. My dysphoria was also tied to childhood associations from a religious upbringing I am still working to undo. I had a longstanding rejection of everything feminine that I now recognize as unhealthy; after detransitioning I found I actually like or am neutral about many feminine things I had only associated with my upbringing and being pressured to behave in certain ways before I was ready. I am still overall a tomboy.
Detransition was my own decision — my conservative fiance even tried to talk me out of it, thinking it was an impulse. I started dating him during my trans identification and we are still together; he was never hateful, just skeptical of the loud voices in the movement, as was I, and he never made me feel gross about myself. Coming out to my family took a long time originally, which was embarrassing, but they basically treat it like nothing ever happened and there was no 'I told you so.' I explained it simply: 'I transitioned because I wanted to live as a man, not as a transgender man, but it doesn't seem like that is possible for me, so it'd be easier to stop.'
Since detransitioning I have largely recovered from my gender dysphoria — I very rarely have any dysphoria anymore, and when I do it relates to those original childhood religious associations. A huge burden has lifted: I never realized how much thought I was putting into how I looked, spoke, and even moved, or how much stress I was under trying not to be found out — all of that left. I feel more confident as a woman because I no longer have a big checklist of things I need to change, whereas living as a man I had insecurity about not matching how I felt I should look. I did enjoy the hormonal changes while I was living as a man, but after detransitioning the physical changes became reminders of my mistake and are now just annoying. I am working on reversing what I did to myself through exercise and hair removal (I use at-home IPL because I can't afford professional removal for several years, and I use retinol for acne I've always had). My thin hair at the top is improving — I found vitamin D and thyroid levels affected my hair more than testosterone did.
I became a Christian after my detransition, which has brought me great comfort and helped me realize why I was led so astray; I believe sincere faith and study of the gospel means you wouldn't want to transition at all. I don't spend hours a day on detrans content — my detransition time goes to exercise, hair removal, and mental and spiritual health. I don't accept the framing that there are people who are 'not really transgender' or who 'detransition because they're a normal woman'; I was never a normal woman, I just don't need to be trans anymore. I also don't believe gender dysphoria is incurable. I have a close relative who is trans despite us being raised apart, and I've wondered whether there is a genetic factor.
I am critical of the broader movement: I see it as based on gender stereotypes and incoherent, with no ideological consistency — plenty of ftm people present very femininely and still insist on male pronouns, while others say liking superheroes or hating dresses is how they knew they were a boy, and both are treated as valid in mainstream circles. I see gender as instincts wired into men and women that allowed us to survive as a species, with average differences being objective reality, and I see gender as only an extension of sex. I am skeptical of nonbinary identification, arguing no one will ever truly register you as nonbinary and the 'truly inbetween' look is only viable in photographs and can't be maintained as you age. I also believe a lot of fetishism and pornography addiction exists in ftm spaces, particularly artist spaces. I have been active in the detrans community, arguing with moderators about definitions of detransition and defending the relevance of discussing these issues in the support group.