Тези истории са обобщени с помощта на ИИ.
В Reddit хората често споделят преживяванията си в множество коментари или публикации. За да направим тази информация по-достъпна, detrans.ai събира всички тези разпръснати парчета в едно лесно за четене обобщение и времева линия. Всички системни подкани са отбелязани на страницата с подкани.
Понякога ИИ може да халюцинира или да посочва неща, които не са верни. Но като цяло, обобщените истории са точни отражения на оригиналните коментари на потребителите.
Резюме
Родена съм от женски пол, а сексуалното насилие в детството, аутизмът/СДВХ, ПТСР, тормозът заради теглото ми и баща, който фаворизираше брат ми, подхраниха омраза към това да бъда жена, която погрешно сметнах за дисфория. Никога не съм преминавала през медицинска транзиция — да бъдеш транс не беше опция, когато бях млада, което според мен спаси тялото ми — и дискомфортът ми отшумя от само себе си между средата на двайсетте и началото на трийсетте ми години чрез промяна в нагласата, а не чрез медицинска или терапевтична намеса. Сега съм детранзиционирала/дезистирала жена на 37 години, омъжена с две малки деца, изключително женствена и в близки отношения с баща си. В миналото съм имала суицидни мисли и се справих с тях благодарение на правилото, че мога да сложа край на живота си само ако не мога да намеря абсолютно нищо в живота, на което да се радвам; тази криза отмина. Сега се застъпвам онлайн срещу медицинската транзиция, особено при подрастващи, като предупреждавам, че повечето, които се стремят към нея, са „фалшиво положителни“, подтикнати от травма, аутизъм, ОКР или объркване около стереотипите, а не от истинска дисфория.
Пълна история
I was born female and grew up in Canada. Looking back, my discomfort started early: I was a fat kid and was mocked for it, and in fifth grade my teacher told me to wear a bra. I was shy of my breasts as a kid because they weren't shapely, and I hid my body in general — always baggy clothes, never shorts as a teen. I started puberty at age 8 and began shaving my armpits and privates very early, just for comfort. I shaved my head and wore boys' clothes because I was fat and no one could tell I was a girl anyway; I decided it was better to dress like a boy than to be an ugly girl. I wore men's swim trunks and tee shirts.
A lot of my hatred for being female came from how I was raised. My dad raised us, and my brother got far more attention because he was a boy — my dad took him to play sports and left me behind a lot, even though I was the first child and had identical or stronger interests: building RC planes, monster trucks, motorcycles, science fiction, horror, being outdoors. I'd be gifted things like nail polish and then ignored. No one respected my interests as a kid and teen, and that really fueled a hatred for being female. I was also sexually abused as a child and was diagnosed with PTSD as an adult, though I now think most of my quirks line up more with autism and ADHD. I'm on the spectrum and have some dyslexia, which affects how I pull words during conversation.
I was mocked constantly growing up and took "outcast" to be part of who I was. I diverted my anger outward and basically stopped trying to have friends at all until adulthood. I had a best friend who thought I was a strange lesbian but didn't question it. I wasn't a lesbian — just butch. I loved swimming and dressed stupid for it with shirts and shorts, but nothing could stop me.
Crucially, I never medically transitioned. I never even heard about trans or gender identity when I was young, and I consider that the thing that saved me from destroying my body — it simply wasn't an option in my youth. The most extreme option available was name changes and being a transvestite, with no encouragement to do so. I did change my name at some point and still deal with the paperwork. I believe that if I'd been born later I would have been pressured into medically transitioning and that would have ruined my life.
My dysphoria resolved on its own as I got older — I describe it as happening somewhere between my mid-twenties and early thirties. I changed pretty much nothing except my mentality: I realized labels don't alter reality, and I could like, dress, act and live however I want while being the sex I am. I gradually stopped feeling dirty for doing girly things and just embraced being me. I'm now extremely feminine, probably traditionally attractive, and outwardly friendly and personable — a big contrast to how I grew up. I still struggle to maintain friendships. I got close with my dad; we're basically best friends now.
I'm 32 as of October 2020, so I was born around 1988 — an 80s/90s baby. I'm autistic and have ADHD traits. I was sexually abused as a child and had PTSD diagnosed. I've experienced homelessness at some point ("been there"). I'm married — I called in my husband to assess a voice clip — and I have a 5-year-old and an 11-month-old baby as of May 2021, so I'm a parent. I live in Canada and I'm deeply concerned about legislation that treats parental non-support of a child's transition as abuse, saying parents here are "terrified of losing their kids." My biggest fear is my own daughter going down that path; I've said I'd pull her from school, cut social media, and get therapy focused on depression, puberty problems, trauma, autism or OCD before ever considering dysphoria.
I'm mostly straight — my sexuality never factored into my own experience (0% for me) — and I'd date a lesbian woman over a trans man any day. I have transvestite friends, drag queen friends (my best friend is a drag queen), and gay and bisexual friends, but no actual trans friends in real life; my only real-life trans friend killed himself after regretting his transition.
I've become an active voice in detrans and gender-critical communities online. I regularly counsel people considering transition to wait, to interrogate whether their desire comes from trauma, autism, OCD, body issues, fetish, stereotype confusion, or a need for acceptance — what I call "false positives," people who wouldn't be trans without the current trans movement. I compare medical transition to letting anorexics have liposuction, and describe transition as "extreme cosplay" that adults are free to choose but that shouldn't be encouraged for anyone whose grip on reality is shaky. I support adults living however they want cosmetically but oppose hormones and surgery, especially for adolescents. I've told people bluntly "you are a woman" or "you're a female. Full stop," and advised staying off testosterone because female vascular systems can't handle those changes long term. I've also advocated for detransitioners finding community, defended a trans poster from attack in our sub as a potential ally, and expressed frustration that there's "almost nowhere for us" online without walking on eggshells.
On mental health: I've dealt with depression and body obsession, and I've been suicidal in the past. What got me through was a rule I made for myself — a list of everything in life that brings me joy, starting with pie, and the rule that I wasn't allowed to kill myself unless I couldn't find a single enjoyable thing and wasn't allowed to stop trying new things. "In the end I couldn't do anything because no matter what I still liked pie." I've talked others down from suicide with the same approach. I don't carry intense regret about transition since I never medically transitioned, but I do grieve wasted youth — I was super fat then thin, my body has stretch marks and loose skin, I didn't go to prom or do fun things in my early years. That grief has softened with time; I made up for it later by working on myself and being bold. Overall my quality of life is good now: I'm a parent, close with my dad, and comfortable in my own skin in a way I wasn't as a teen.